7 ms·
The Wisconsin cartographer who mapped Tolkien's fantasy world
- jfengel 2y agoAtlas of Middle-earth is a truly monumental feat. I think the article writer misses how much of it is really about The Silmarillion, rather than about Lord of the Rings. Tolkien put a lot of work into First Age geography, an entire (interminable, excruciating) chapter of The Silmarillion. Very little of it would be familiar to viewers of the films, and a lot of it opaque even to readers just of LotR.
- rimunroe 2y ago> an entire (interminable, excruciating) chapter of The Silmarillion I’ve read The Silmarillion easily more than 20 times and I swear Of Beleriand and its Realms gets longer every time I read it.
- jfengel 2y agoI just wish it had been relegated to an appendix. A lot of people drop Silmarillion there, but you can just skip it and get on to much better material. It could be replaced on first read with a decent map. Or even a mediocre map. Or nothing; you just don't need it.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> I just wish it had been relegated to an appendix. It was; it wasn't even published.
- bombcar 2y agoMost of the Silmarillion can be read out of order, if you want. That should have been made more clear to the "casual" reader (as if casual readers pick it up!).
- devilbunny 2y ago[dead]
- thordenmark 2y agoI have The Silmarillion on Audible and use the chapter Of Beleriand and its Realms when I'm having trouble going to sleep.
- andrewl 2y agoMy favorite parts of the Silmarillion were the ones where I learned the back story of the world: the Valaquenta, the Ainulindalë, and Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age. I don't have my copy here, but if I recall correctly that last section starts with Of old there was Sauron the Maia.... That's the stuff I wanted to know.
- andrewl 2y agoI was also impressed by Tolkien's creation myth. I'm not really familiar with the various religions or mythologies, whether invented by a single author or developed over time by pre-scientific societies, but his is the only one I know of where the creation was based on music.
- krupan 2y agoIt's a really great analogy for how God can allow his creations free will without it messing up His Work. Melkor uses his free will to try and make his own "music" discordant from Eru's but Eru just incorporates it into His music and makes the whole song better.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoSo you're saying that Eru and Miles Davis are one?
- krupan 2y agoI'd never thought of that, but yes now that you mention it, I think that's exactly what I'm saying
- AlotOfReading 2y agoYou might be familiar with another musical creation story written by Tolkien's friend C.S. Lewis. In The Magician's Nephew, Aslan sings the land of Narnia into existence.
- jonchurch_ 2y agoNot to imply OP doesnt know this, but hoping someone gets to be one of the lucky 10k today. Tolkien himself didnt “write” the Silmarillion the way people might assume. He spent decades writing and iterating on mythology, world building, creating languages. He had multiple versions of many stories and ideas, many drafts in various states, but he never pulled it all together into a single book or officially canon narrative. After his death his son Christopher took on that monumental task, with great care and understanding of his father’s work. Combing through who knows how many mountains of notes, unfinished stories, and contradictions to create what we know as the Silmarillion. Tolkien himself often said of things in the LOTR canon “I don’t know” or something loke “I havent translated/uncovered that yet”. He looked at it all as if he was a literary archaeologist, translating passed down texts. So with that came lots of uncertainty and hearsay. The fact that his son tackled that, maintained that mystique, and created the Silmarillion is really exciting and lucky in my opinion. Good kid, I guess!
- eszed 2y agoI'm sure you know this, but to clarify for those that don't, it goes way deeper than the volume published as The Silmarillion. In The History of Middle Earth, Christopher pulled together all / most of the drafts and published those, along with notes and commentary that relate them to each other and try to put them into their linear and creative context. It got up to I think fourteen volumes, and there's probably no more-complete record of a great artist's life-long creative process. It is, as you say, a truly monumental work.
- db48x 2y agoIf only version control had been invented earlier. Some of the in–progress versions of the stories are quite hilarious. In the earliest drafts of the story of Beren and Luthien, Beren sets off to cut a Silmaril from the Iron Crown of Morgoth and is more or less immediately captured by one of Morgoth’s lieutenants, Tevildo. Who is a talking cat. With a whole castle full of talking cats that mostly laze about on the terraces but occasionally waylay passersby and make them serve as scullery maids. Christopher Tolkien calls him “the appalling Tevildo”. By many changes small and great Tolkien went from Tevildo, Prince of Cats to Sauron, Lord of the Rings. If you ever write a book, keep that in mind when you hesitate to cut or rewrite what seems like your best ideas.
- davidjhall 2y agoA wonderful atlas -- my favorite are her trail maps where she depicts a character's daily journey in the book. The article (almost) footnotes her other work which was equally impressive: * She also created atlases for the worlds of fantasy authors Anne McCaffrey, creator of the “Dragonriders of Pern” series, and Stephen R. Donaldson, who wrote “The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant” series.
- gainda 2y agoOne of my biggest takeaways from the first time I saw her work was that Beleriand was actually situated to the west of Middle Earth prior to sinking. I had seen far too many erroneous maps placing it north of Middle Earth (https://static0.gamerantimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/arda-Cropped.jpg https://static0.gamerantimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uplo...)
- mryijum 2y agoThe infamous lung map! David Day must've introduced so many people to the various interesting aspects of Tolkien's world but there's so much fanfiction mixed into his works. Though in the case of the map it's not really fanfiction, it's just wrong.
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoIn my ~35 years of being a Tolkien fan I've never actually seen this. Wow, so inacurrate.
- foldr 2y agoThe Journeys of Frodo is also worth a look if you like this kind of thing. The author isn’t a professional cartographer and it’s more focused on LOTR locations than general world building. Anyway, I was completely captivated by it as a child when I stumbled across it in my high school’s library. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journeys_of_Frodo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journeys_of_Frodo
- bombcar 2y agoIn a similar vein, if interested in that type of thing, is Flora of Middle-Earth: Plants of J.R.R. Tolkien's Legendarium.
- duxup 2y agoWhat a wonderful thing to do. Map making is such an amazing skill.
- at_a_remove 2y agoIndeed. I started off making a general "land" for the small city a friend is working up for a prospective module of Dungeons and Dragons. I quickly found myself re-adjusting various distances, estimating the impacts of elevation, considering "rain shadows" caused by mountains, coming up with a new scale of "how far can one reasonably ride on horseback per day?" as a kind of measurement, considering climates and microclimates (then making adjustments based on trying to justify what I wanted), looking at historical patterns of settlement growth, checking in on that set of tables of population centers and occupations long ago, and so on. If you do not consider these things, you get Monster Hotels and general ridiculousness. If it falls too close to reality, it is boring. At the same time, things can be Too Much. So, for my philosophy, you want the mountains to be taller and the valleys to be deeper ... but only sometimes. Spaces to breathe for the beleagured traveler, but then drips and splashes and slashes of Tolkien, The Black Company, and even a little whimsy to break it up.
- krupan 2y agoDo I love maps because of the fantasy books I read as a kid? Did I love (and still love) the fantasy books because I love maps? I may never know. I've heard of the Atlas of Middle Earth but never knew this amazing story behind it. Thanks for posting it, bookofjoe! Also, really cool to know she did D&D maps too. Maps are just rad
- bombcar 2y agoI love that she could build so much of the world from the geographic descriptions, of things like mountains and rivers.
- dhosek 2y agoI think it’s the latter for me. We had a 1960s Reader’s Digest atlas when I was a kid that gave me countless hours of entertainment examining the various maps of the world and the regions within it (there were also maps showing continental drift, a new(!) idea at the time, the paths of the 15th–16th century explorers and I forget what else. The endpapers were reproductions of a 16th century world map.
- nelblu 2y agoEvery time I read a chapter from LOTR and then hike with my dog, I imagine myself being Frodo and my dog being Samwise, and I find myself talking to the dog, sometimes yelling at him - hey don't go there, there might be Orcs there or maybe Dark Riders were here etc. Of course my dog doesn't care, but I love this silly monologue with him. Just ordered this book and can't wait to start reading LOTR again!
- aegirth 2y agoKaren also did the Atlas of Krynn, the world of the Dragonlance Saga. I still have my copy. Wonderful illustrations and maps.
- zem 2y agoI love fantasy in general, and have read a ton of it. other than tolkien, I have never read a novel with that strong a sense of geography in a constructed world - specifically, that there is an entire rich land out there, and not just a graph of interesting places with the focus shifting from one point to another. when the hobbits have to go from the shire to rivendell, or aragorn has to take the paths of the dead to reach his destination in time, tolkien really manages to convey the experience of a difficult journey that takes a significant amount of time even when nothing plot-significant is happening along the way.
- gerdesj 2y agoPratchett's Discworld is pretty well mapped out and that which is left to the imagination is well described. Death's house and garden seem almost tangible ...
- zem 2y agopratchett is my all time favourite writer, and I love the discworld series, but I never got a good sense of the "spaces between" the way tolkien could do it - e.g. the logistics of traveling from ankh morpork to the ramtops were alluded to, but the journey scenes never really came alive for me in the way that scenes set within ankh morpork did. the deverry series did come close, and to some extent the wheel of time books (though it's been a while since I read those).
- prawn 2y agoI'm a couple of pages from finishing The Two Towers and feel like Frodo and Sam's journey there is an especially good example of the spaces between. They pass through a broad variety of landscapes and you get a great sense of the transitions from craggy rocks down gullies to marshes. Or from badlands to Ithilien.
- db48x 2y agoAgreed. Whenever he is describing the terrain somewhere it is either fairly generic or specifically a parody. Hence the plains around Ankh Morpork where all the farms grow brassicas and nothing else. Cabbages, broccoli, turnips, mustard, collard greens, and so on for hundreds of miles around.
- docmechanic 2y agoI still have my copy, less the paper book cover. In storage at the moment, but I’m pretty sure it was first edition.
- ananmays 2y agoWhat a wonderful article (public radio!) and what wonderful work. Heartening to see amidst a time of attacks on higher education.
- gavmor 2y agoFor rich, authentic old-style maps you want to make at home on the PC (or iPad) is there any better resource than K. M. Alexander's? https://kmalexander.com/free-stuff/fantasy-map-brushes/ https://kmalexander.com/free-stuff/fantasy-map-brushes/
- timonofathens 2y ago[dead]