4 ms·
The internet comment section “pick a side and deride the other” doesn’t work on these situations. Two things can be bad at once. The IT consulting can be too e
by Aurornis 2y ago
The internet comment section “pick a side and deride the other” doesn’t work on these situations.
Two things can be bad at once. The IT consulting can be too expensive. Cutting it all at once with no other plan can have disastrous consequences.
Rash moves like this are things politicians and corporate ladder climbers alike love to do, but then they run far away from the consequences. They know they can convince enough people that their bold move was a good thing and that the consequences will diffuse throughout the years on to other people.
This very well could become more expensive to cancel abruptly when you consider the second and third order effects.
- grandempire 2y ago> Cutting it all at once with no other plan can have disastrous consequences. I think this part is overestimated. It will get fixed.
- tclancy 2y agoBy whom?
- grandempire 2y agoThis comment by saying it will be disastrous. Remember all the twitter predictions?
- const_cast 2y ago[dead]
- t-writescode 2y agoUnderfunding and breaking of, for example, unemployment benefits systems causes real harm, real loss of medication, real loss of house, etc. But that won't make the news in any meaningful way, and the destitute will often be too busy to make loud noises. And the populous at large will sigh and shake their head and say "what a shame", but the loss can be *enormous*.
- grandempire 2y ago> Underfunding and breaking of, for example, unemployment benefits systems causes real harm, real loss of medication, real loss of house, etc. I thought we were talking about firing IT consultants? Let me know when that happens. > But that won't make the news I think that would make the news immediately. The media is very interested in DOGE and its shortcomings.
- t-writescode 2y ago> I thought we were talking about firing IT consultants? Let I read this whole thread as being about the broader 'cutting' trend, OOP: when discussing the overall trend of cutting programs in other fields where the majority doesn't have that expertise, the conclusion is the opposite. Parent: Rash moves like this are things politicians and corporate ladder climbers alike love to do, but then they run far away from the consequences.
- t-writescode 2y agoBreaking critical systems like SNAP, Medicare/Medicaid, weather forecasting and many many many other systems that people literally depend on for their being alive *kills* people. Programmers that work on critical systems are actively trained to take into consideration every contingency to not increase the death rate of their systems, to the best of their abilities. Aggressive, comprehensive and non-robust axing of systems when literal lives are on the line - especially when it's government systems and those lines maintain any semblance of some people's ability to literally be alive - touch and impact more lives than any single Boeing plane or NASA space shuttle's crash. They are even more critical than those systems - though not as flashy when they fail.
- grandempire 2y agoThis is a nerd fantasy where you imagine your skills and expertise are what keep society turning. Computer problems are fixable, and they are secondary, and there are many people and services who can be hired to fix them.
- t-writescode 2y agoWhat are you on about? The systems I'm referring to are human systems with lots of humans doing human things. Cutting funding, removing departments, those are removing the humans doing human things to solve human problems.
- grandempire 2y agoThis is what I replied to in my comment above: > Two things can be bad at once. The IT consulting can be too expensive. Cutting it all at once with no other plan can have disastrous consequences.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y ago> Cutting it all at once with no other plan can have disastrous consequences. Destroying everything because you don't know how to fix it or work within the system is an amateur move. Weakness masquerading as tough guy strength.
- rdsubhas 2y agoFrom the article: > The contracts "represent non-essential spending on third party consultants" for services Pentagon employees can perform
- fckgw 2y agoThe source is the person doing the cutting. Of course they're not going to say "We're cutting essential staff for no reason"
- mywittyname 2y ago> This very well could become more expensive to cancel abruptly when you consider the second and third order effects. That's the goal. The whole conservative ideology for the past 40 years has been to make the government inefficient so it can complain about government inefficiencies. What we are seeing is the end game of this idea - turn the government itself into an gigantic inefficient corporation designed to siphon as much money as possible from people. In this specific situation, these expensive contractors will be replace with even more expensive "AI contractors" that work for companies founded by the Global Elite Tech Bros. So more money spent on on less outcomes. Destroying the system first ensures that there's no direct performance comparisons that can be made between the old expensive, but functional system and the new even more expensive, disfunctional one they created.
- VirusNewbie 2y ago> The whole conservative ideology for the past 40 years has been to make the government inefficient so it can complain about government inefficiencies. People say things like this, but then have trouble explaining California, where the left has had a supermajority for almost as long.
- fundad 2y agoAnd California is an incredibly successful economy and people dream of living there.
- airforce1 2y agoThen why is everyone fleeing to escape the high taxes and crime? California is losing house seats at the present. Also, I don't know if you can really credit the left's supermajority for the success of SV... CA's politics have pivoted over the years. Look at an election map of CA in 1980 and you'll see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980_United_States_presidential_election_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980_United_States_presidentia...
- 2y ago