5 ms·
Our New AI Website Builder
- nadermx 2y agoSpeaking of WordPress, hows the entire WordPress debacle going with Matt Mullenweg?
- bslalwn 2y ago[flagged]
- cabalos 2y agoDevelopment has dropped off a cliff over the last couple of months. The release cycle has moved from quarterly to yearly. He's basically taking his ball and going home. My guess is we'll see more internal initiatives like this AI builder instead of focusing on the core product. This would be an okay strategy if his core product wasn't in such a state of disrepair. I've seen multiple issues on Github projects from Automattic developers saying "this would be easy to fix upstream but we're not allow to fix anything in WordPress right now." It's pathetic and actively harming his own business.
- johnebgd 2y ago[flagged]
- cdolan 2y ago"it's pathetic that no other company benefiting from WordPress has stepped up either" ^<-- hard to justify doing so when Wordpress' package ecosystem (the open source platform) is tethered to Wordpress.org (matt's personal website)
- cabalos 2y agoAlso, good luck sending in a PR and getting it merged. Unless you are part of Matt’s inner circle, it isn’t happening. Even the most basic bug fix PRs are routinely ignored.
- molochai 2y agoDisrepair is too right. 5k issues and 1.7k open PRs on the Gutenberg GitHub repository. I wish this all had happened before Full Site Editing was put into .org.
- throwawaymatt 2y agoThey're still battling out in court, with a timeline that extends into 2027. Meanwhile: (very quick summary) Matt's pulled his developers off the project, and the release schedule has slowed. Some commercial vendors have increased their support, while others have pulled back. Meanwhile the ecosystem of devs and agencies basically shrugged it off. If we need to get rid of Matt we will (with big vendor support), no big deal.
- Mystery-Machine 2y agoI believe it is actually Pretty Big Deal™. No big deal on splitting the community in half? Matt will not go and you will have half the people supporting him, half forking the project. Actually less than half on each side, when you count in the people that will completely leave the ecosystem...
- throwawaymatt 2y agoSplitting the community in half? Nah. If Matt needs to go, the community who is more interested in just making money (we're not "post economic" like Matt) will move aggressively to cut him out like cancer. Sure he controls a scary amount of the ecosystem NOW, but we've seen big vendors express interest in hosting repositories, and major plugin vendors move quickly to secure their distribution and update models. My tiny agency has already mitigated many risks and shifted our support towards developers who see a future PostMatt™ We'll be fine because WordPress belongs to us, not Matt.
- Implicated 2y agoCopium. Wordpress is dead. Argue all you want. 5 years from now the trajectory of installs/users/commercial opportunity will show that the last year was more than enough to incentivize/motivate the current and potential users to reach for something else. I say this as someone who makes my primary income managing a very large WP/WC shop. Sure, WP isn't going away overnight. But it's dead in the water at this point. Literally like a dead whale, still going to support an ecosystem for some period of time. Though, it's peak is behind us and the unwinding was accelerated immeasurably.
- AlienRobot 2y agoFor 99.99% of the people, it doesn't matter. Even if Wordpress stopped getting updates today, the code already works and it's open source, thanks in part to Matt for maintaining it for 20 years. It was just the weekly Internet drama of the programming niche probably pumped by Youtubers and influencers in need for content to drive views and then by memes. Barely anything of substance was actually written about it. After all, if Matt were such a negative factor in the project, it would be trivial to just take all the code and fork it and then for all the developers to just move to the new project. The fact that this didn't happen shows that there is non-trivial infrastructure being provided that is separate from the open source project. How do such smart people as programmers fail to understand this when they repeatedly conflate the open source project with the whole trademark/plugin hosting thing is beyond me. Does nobody question the whole thing before pointing fingers and picking their pitchforks? I've seen a Youtuber who interviewed to Matt in one video and the Youtuber himself raised the point of hosting costs, and then in a next video they conflate the two concepts as if they had completely forgotten about everything they said and heard. It's surreal.
- nrdgrrrl 2y ago[dead]
- pluc 2y agoThey just laid off 16% of workers https://www.theverge.com/news/642187/automattic-wordpress-layoffs-matt-mullenweg https://www.theverge.com/news/642187/automattic-wordpress-la...
- LordDragonfang 2y agoMaybe I'm wrong, but I can't help but feel this is a solution in search of a problem. I feel like "building a simple website" has been a solved issue with templates for decades now. The only thing you need to add is the text, and for a useful website, you're already going to have to be typing 90% of that into the prompt anyway - most of what an LLM is going to add will be more of a value-subtract than a value-add. Sure, that still leaves the tweaking and customization, but I feel like that's the part most people enjoy the most? Humans love decorating. Maybe I'm seeing this the wrong way, and I'm forgetting truly non-technical folks exist, and this is for the people who would otherwise be forcing their nephew to help them make a basic website, and that's the role the LLM is playing here, as a conversational interface. I think the marketing copy for this announcement is total bullshit, then (plastering "AI" all over the announcement is more for marketers than customers), but I can at least see that use case.
- frereubu 2y agoI have no idea about the quality of the sites this produces, but I think your comment about non-technical folks existing is on the money. There are many people who really don't understand how to properly structure even a simple website, and being walked through a conversation with a series of pertinent questions will be a much more satisfying process.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI am one of them. Without help from a capable and kind developer friend back in 2004 I never ever would have been able to create mine.
- browningstreet 2y agoGoing from a basic template to all the little changes you need to make to build the basic shell you need for a new site is still a lot of work. Think of all the best practices cruft required for the pages typically linked to from the footer. A sporting good site is different than a directory blog is different than a single serving social media aggregation site. I think it's plausible for AI to help with the tedious setup stuff and get you to the part where you start making it your own.
- imagetic 2y ago[flagged]
- paul7986 2y agochatGPT (pro at least) creates amazing logos in 30 seconds, amazing look websites around the logo you settled on and then codes the front-end (html,css,js). That can all be done in 5 minutes or less. As UX Designer and UI Developer who does all the above (also do UX Research which anything where you interface with humans i think is safe for awhile) it's slightly disheartening to see my skill-sets future worth..... Where I work we were told we can't use GPT and that is fine, but in what a year to three or five Im sure their stance will change.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoFrom an audience perspective, if you use an AI generated site, I'm just assuming your product is shit. And not even because I'm opposed to the way AI is being used in many places (though I am) but for the same reason I don't buy products that advertise with shitty commercials that look like they were filmed in 2006 on a budget of $500. If you don't have a marketing budget for proper advertising, I'm assuming your product is some fly-by-night garbage that's likely to break on first use, if not an outright scam. Is that fair? No probably not, but I don't know what to tell you. That's always been a rule of thumb for me: if the marketing presence of anything, services, products, tooling, what have you is cheaply/poorly made, I avoid it. I always have almost instinctively.
- paul7986 2y agoIf you have GPT pro or know someone try it out .. create a logo with it then ask it to create a website around your chosen logo and then ask it to code the front-end. Im sure it can do the back-end code too. The logos and the web design it creates around the chosen logo look amazing .. extremely pro level. I'm not sure how you or anyone would be able to decipher if a website and or brand used chatGPT (pro). I'm betting no one would be able to tell just that it looks really good to great and professional! Personally it's a wake up call for my skill-sets of over 15 years and that increasing my skillsets to 2025 modern day skill sets is best thing for me and any in my field!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymatt 2y agoyawn Pretty much every major WP builder has an AI component. I'm sure this one is as half-baked as all the others.
- AlienRobot 2y agoWordpress: create your own website in minutes! Wordpress new AI: create your own website in minutes!
- fragmede 2y agoThe bus, when you live on the route: Get to work in 30 minutes! A car: Get to work in 30 minutes! (you still have to live and work in the right locations for that to be true, but you now also have deal with traffic)
- rchaud 2y agoSo they finally gave up on making "Full Site Editing" a thing, I take it. I maintain that trying to transition the product away from PHP into a React-ridden mess for the "Block Editor" in 2017 started us down this path of ruin. Clearly they felt threatened by site builder plugins like Elementor Pro, Beaver Builder, Bricks and others that massively improved the WYSIWYG experience to the point where WP was relegated to the role of invisible scaffolding, a dumb pipe. Considering how badly they botched the redesign into the block editor era, and the madness about WpEngine, they are struggling to shake investor worries.
- frereubu 2y agoI run a WordPress agency and while I think the block editor was foisted on wordpress.org far too quickly, it's been a godsend in terms of allowing our clients much more control over their content. The prospect of going back to the TinyMCE WYSIWYG editor and templates makes me shudder.
- AlienRobot 2y agoI don't get the criticism either. Every time I try to post on a platform I miss the ability of just dragging a paragraph around to reorder it.
- artpi 2y agoThis AI builder is actually doubling down on blocks - everything is block based and the canvas it works on is the full site editing. Without block editor, this wouldn’t be possible
- thetwopct 2y agoWordPress.com ≠ WordPress Conflating the two is like mistaking GitHub for Git.
- rchaud 2y agoThey are much more similar to each other than Git as they share the same plugin ecosystem, core developers and the base layer CMS is identical. I imagine there are many more feature differences between Git and Github.
- thetwopct 2y agoFeel free to insert an analogy that pleases you. WordPress.com is a hosting company that has its own staff and contributes approx 40 hours per month to the WordPress open source project. WordPress core development is made up of contributors. The AI builder is not available for WordPress, it’s exclusively for the hosting company WordPress.com. WordPress.com on their basic plan restrict any plugin usage. There are no usage restrictions on the open source software. This is just a taste of the distinctions. The title of this post has now been updated, but regardless, WordPress.com is not WordPress.
- partiallypro 2y agoI deal with WordPress a lot, and at least for my set of clients they just don't even have time for this, even with AI. They just wants leads. AI currently is good I guess for a standard 3-5 page site just like some of the other standard builders, but clients with hundreds of pages and heavily reliant on getting leads through campaigns and SEO, I currently don't see any danger (or use) here. Great for SMBs that just need something up quick though.
- rustc 2y agoWordPress.com launches would be a better title. This builder is not available in WordPress (the open source software) but only WordPress.com (a hosting company owned by the creator of WordPress). For a moment I thought they added AI integration to the open source Gutenberg plugin.
- throwawaymatt 2y agoA very important distinction indeed. Wordpress.COM is not the same as the self-hosted version at WordPress.ORG While they've made recent changes to .COM to bring it closer to .ORG mostly as a knee-jerk response to the Matt v WPE scrap, they are still very different experiences. I rarely advise clients looking to DIY solution to go to WordPress.com
- pluc 2y agoIt's funny that the whole lawsuit thing started because Mullenweg was claiming wpengine was confusing customers, when .com and .org is way more confusing.
- webspinner 2y agoI keep them straight usually. However, I don't have to. I just use Classic press.
- webspinner 2y agoVery true! Oh and I would hope not.
- dang 2y agoSince wordpress.com is displayed next to the title above, we can fix this by reverting the submission title to that of the article. I've done that now. (Well, I used the minimally baity substring.) (Submitted title was "WordPress launches new free AI website builder")
- croemer 2y agoOriginal title: "Just Say the Word—Try Our New AI Website Builder for Free"
- dang 2y agoYes. I've replaced the submitted title now - see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43657916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43657916 for more details.
- webspinner 2y agoPersonally, I wouldn't use anything coming out of there right now!
- Apfel 2y agoIf anyone's interested in the prompts they're using here, they're viewable via devtools. Full dump of what was showing on my end here: https://gist.githubusercontent.com/furnivall/aa95e8d9dc330f30fcdc524aac1de071/raw/7aabe6907f32d3ac87d374afe325e41bc2317552/prompt.json https://gist.githubusercontent.com/furnivall/aa95e8d9dc330f3...
- codemartial 2y agoLooks like landing pages with templates
- redwoodsec 2y agoFwiw just tried the WordPress AI web builder it sucks
- kara4151 2y ago[dead]