3 ms·
A consent decree doesn't give the White House binding control over Columbia; it gives a federal judge that control. Consent decrees with universities aren't unp
by tptacek 2y ago
A consent decree doesn't give the White House binding control over Columbia; it gives a federal judge that control. Consent decrees with universities aren't unprecedented; there are several over ADA issues, for instance.
I'm not saying this is good (I have no idea, but given the actors involved, probably not), and this isn't a normative claim.
- Avshalom 2y agoThis particular consent decree would a give judge binding control to enforce whatever the White House says. The ADA is, in important contrast to this situation, a law.
- tptacek 2y agoAs I said: it gives a judge binding control, not the White House.
- Avshalom 2y agoA distinction with out a difference because this is entirely about whether Columbia agrees to do whatever the White House says it has to do.
- tptacek 2y agoNo. The consent decree will be agreed to ahead of time, and a judge will interpret and police it. It isn't an arbitrary delegation of authority to the executive branch. We'll have to wait and see what the consent decree says to evaluate it further.
- wredcoll 2y agoGood point, we'll just have to wait and see if the people with the proven history of bad faith and process subversion will subvert it this time, too bad there's no way to know ahead of time!
- tptacek 2y agoNo. I know this is an emotionally satisfying thing to say, but, again, my point is that a federal judge administers the consent decree, so the White House can't simply go back and say "gotcha, we meant XYZ, not ABC" a year after agreement is struck. The administration also doesn't generally get to pick the judge. Given where Columbia is, it would presumably be a random SDNY judge.
- Tadpole9181 2y agoA very important detail: Who picks the judge?
- tptacek 2y agoThe court district itself, but generally: it's random (within the district).
- rickydroll 2y agoIf we could listen into the consent degree negotiations, I would expect something like.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNZKUozrBl4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNZKUozrBl4
- cherry_tree 2y ago>A consent decree doesn't give the White House binding control over Columbia; it gives a federal judge that control. It’s gives the judge control to enforce the White House’s decree. What meaningful distinction are you making?
- tptacek 2y agoThe distinction between Article III and Article II of the Constitution? A randomly-chosen SDNY judge is overwhelmingly likely to be a Clinton, Obama, or Biden appointee? I still think this will be a shitshow, but the headline that "the White House is seeking binding control via a consent decree" is misleading; that's not how a consent decree works.