4 ms·
The seems to define impartial news as news that has no particular point of view. What does that mean to not have a point of view? Any news source is disseminati
by Apreche 2y ago
The seems to define impartial news as news that has no particular point of view. What does that mean to not have a point of view? Any news source is disseminating information. This always carries the point of view that the information being disseminated is factual.
If we’re talking about pure opinions, like movie reviews, I would argue that isn’t news.
Many people seem to think that impartial news is news that covers all sides. They share all purported and contradictory information from all sources without confirming which information is true, and which is not. This allows the audience to decide for themselves how to see the world rather than being forced to see the world as it is. The upside is not being forced to see only a false world as envisioned by others who may have unseemly motives. The downside is many are left confused and unsure what is true. This defeats the purpose of news entirely, as the audience is just as uninformed after reading as they were before.
The only truly impartial news source is one that will adhere to rigorous standards of evidence. Given all the available information they will take a firm stand in declaring what the facts are, and to what degree of certainty.
The problem is that in a world with vaccine deniers, climate denial, etc. a purely fact-based and impartial source of news would be branded as very extremist.
- freen 2y ago[flagged]
- ryandv 2y ago[flagged]
- weregiraffe 2y agoAnd people dislike biases, which is why reality can't win elections...
- tomhow 2y agoPlease don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- danielheath 2y ago“There was a time the news told you what had happened, and you had to figure out how you felt about it. Now, the news tells you how to feel about it, and you have to figure out whether or not it happened“. I have been enjoying “The Continent” lately- not perfectly, but it does largely stick to reporting established facts with less emphasis on whether or not they’re a good thing.
- healsdata 2y agoI would go so far as to say it's nearly impossible to have completely impartial news. Everyone has biases and pressure being applied to them that will appear in their work. As we've seen just this year, an author's choice of style guide is political.