3 ms·
> all of which, AFAICT, are in agreement with the second view: As you presented it, the speed is an important factor in the second view - I disagree. Proper re
by beagle3 14y ago
> all of which, AFAICT, are in agreement with the second view:
As you presented it, the speed is an important factor in the second view - I disagree. Proper regulations (assuming they are observed and diligently enforced) should be time-scale independent.
Glass Steagall kept the system-as-a-whole safe -- e.g., it would have greatly reduced the effect of the "subprime" crisis (though sadly, blame lays just as much with the Clinton administration, which means GlassSteagall might not have helped). But is mostly unrelated to HFT - e.g. Knight Capital, which lost $440M million in the course of 45 minutes last week, would not have been subject to Glass Steagall.
The fact that everything seemed stable does not indicate everything was indeed stable - e.g. Madoff was doing his thing for the last 17 years, and things blew up only because many people wanted to get their money back in the same time (as a result of their losses in other places).
There is an interesting result from complex system theory, which is that when such a system breaks down, it always looks like there is a specific culprit / event, but the truth is that any one of hundreds of qualitatively different events would have started the ball rolling.
All of the big banks (and most governments, including the US, Japan, UK) are bankrupt - or at least would be, if they were run like a business, no one dares admit it (although greece and ireland were already forced to, spain italy and portugal will need to admit that sooner than later).
We will hopefully know the truth about this crisis in the future. It is unlikely that we will have a reasonable idea before 20 more years have passed (and especially the statute of criminal violations....), though.
- cs702 14y agobeagle3: yes, in an ideal world, regulations should be time-scale independent, and they should be observed and diligently enforced. The problem is that human judgment -- which is still necessary for enforcing regulations in the face of market participants who're constantly trying to game them -- is not time-scale independent. As I presented it in my first comment above, the second side believes "it's a terrible idea to have market stability relying on the second-to-second behavior of automated trading systems that can make decisions and act on them much, much faster than humans could ever react to a market debacle." (Emphasis added.) As I see it, we're largely in agreement.