2 ms·
You're not making much sense. If all filenames that make it to the filesystem have passed through this layer, then this layer is effectively part of the filesys
by eridius 14y ago
You're not making much sense. If all filenames that make it to the filesystem have passed through this layer, then this layer is effectively part of the filesystem. And since you say it shouldn't be part of the filesystem, then this must not be what you're trying to say.
If only filenames that are shown to/input by the human go through this layer, then you're fucked. You open the door to having all sorts of nasty filenames that the human cannot distinguish between, or that the human cannot even type. This is not good.
And I really don't get your point about new codepoints. Unicode is not going to introduce new composed codepoints. The set of composed codepoints that exist now is the same as the set of composed codepoints that will exist in 5 years.
It really seems like you're arguing for massive extra complexity that introduces all sorts of really bad edge cases simply so you can say "my filesystem preserves filenames", without actually getting any benefit of that because normal interaction is going to be normalizing those filenames anyway.