3 ms·
Well, in between step 1 ("ban billboards") and step 3 ("ban advertisement") you'd need step 2 ("repeal the First Amendment of the United States Constitution").
by tptacek 2y ago
Well, in between step 1 ("ban billboards") and step 3 ("ban advertisement") you'd need step 2 ("repeal the First Amendment of the United States Constitution").
- gkoberger 2y agoThey're banned in 4 US states already, with seemingly no infringement on the 1st Amendment. Legally speaking, the validity of banning billboards tends to be evaluated based on the Central Hudson test. More practically, there's numerous limitations to commercial speech... for example, you can't blare an audio ad from your rooftop.
- tptacek 2y agoBillboards? Banning billboards is fine by me. Banning all advertising is unconstitutional.
- whateveracct 2y agoBanning targeted advertising probably wouldn't be.
- bee_rider 2y agoI’d rather ban the behavior required for targeting (building invasive dossiers on everyday normal people), than the (admittedly annoying) speech.
- whateveracct 2y agoThat's probably about what it'd look like. Some combination of things that make it impossible to profitably advertise the way companies do today.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoCommercial speech has limits, even as the first amendment is interpreted today. Well, for now at least.
- nobody9999 2y ago>Well, in between step 1 ("ban billboards") and step 3 ("ban advertisement") you'd need step 2 ("repeal the First Amendment of the United States Constitution"). Let me know how that goes! For most of US history, Commercial speech was not afforded full free speech rights. Nor does it currently enjoy them, although it is more protected than it used to be[0]: Commercial speech, as the Supreme Court iterated in Valentine v. Chrestensen (1942)[1], had historically not been viewed as protected under the First Amendment. This category of expression, which includes commercial advertising, promises, and solicitations, had been subject to significant regulation to protect consumers and prevent fraud. Beginning in the 1970s, however, the Supreme Court gradually recognized this type of speech as deserving some First Amendment protection. As such, it wouldn't require repealing anything. Just reinterpreting how the First Amendment applies (or not) to commercial speech. And given the wholesale tossing out of precedent by recent SCOTUS personnel, it's certainly possible (albeit unlikely -- and more's the pity -- in this configuration) for them to do so. [0] https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/commercial-speech/ https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/commercial-speech/ [1] https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/valentine-v-chrestensen/ https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/valentine-v-chresten...
- tptacek 2y agoI don't know what you mean by "full" free speech rights. But for the last 50 years, under the Burger, Rehnquist, and Roberts courts, pure commercial speech has been held to be protected by the First Amendment. The Burger court overturned Valentine.
- kelnos 2y agoRight, but there is past (obsolete) precedent that suggests otherwise. If Valentine can be overturned, then the current way of thinking can also be changed.
- tptacek 2y agoThe opinion overturning Valentine noted that 30 years of jurisprudence since Valentine had arrived at a consensus that Valentine sure was pretty dumb. Not just Burger's court.
- ceejayoz 2y agoStep three seemed to pass First Amendment muster for cigarette companies.
- tptacek 2y agoCommercial speech is protected by the First Amendment. Regulations of commercial speech need to pass the "Central Hudson Test", which requires a compelling government interest (subject to heightened scrutiny) and narrowly-tailored regulation. Under this rubric, you can get cigarette ads off billboards, but you probably can't regulate Nike's ads.
- kelnos 2y agoIf SCOTUS can develop a test to determine when the government is allowed to violate 1A, then they can loosen that test's requirements. They won't, of course, but I don't see why they couldn't, if they wanted to.
- ceejayoz 2y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 2y agoNobody is surprised that a Republican or Democratic nominee might have a strong take regarding Roe v Wade, because it's practically a litmus test for nomination. No nominee has ever been asked about Central Hudson v PSC NY. There's a reason for that. It's been 50 years and 3 different distinct courts and the only thing that seems to have happened with this body of case law is that protections for commercial speech have gotten stronger.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Nobody is surprised that a Republican or Democratic nominee might have a strong take regarding Roe v Wade, because it's practically a litmus test for nomination. The point is they'll openly say "settled law" and then immediately unsettle it. "Corporations get free speech" is a concept granted over time (and fairly recently) by the courts, not explicitly laid out in the Constitution. (Doubly so at the state level; it wasn't until the 1920s that SCOTUS even said the First Amendment applied to states. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gitlow_v._New_York https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gitlow_v._New_York) > It's been 50 years… Right about the same amount of time Roe v. Wade stuck around. Look, this current Court certainly isn't gonna ban advertising; if anything, it's more likely to permit government-required advertisements right into our Neuralink headsets… but a future Court could easily say fast food advertising or social media for minors is just as bad as cigarette advertising was.
- tedunangst 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Taek 2y agoSo, I dug into this somewhat deeply, and it's true that there's some case law which would make an outright ban of commercial advertising difficult, however: The law is pretty consistent about the idea that any paid endorsement has to be "truthful". And as we've learned more about sociology and advertising, we've realized that things like paid endorsements are fundamentally not truthful, because they are misleading the public to believe that some figure or trusted source (even if only at a subconscious level - which is still enough to change consumer behavior!) is in favor of a product or brand. So maybe if you could argue that paid speech is inherently untruthful (which I believe that it is!), then you could make legal policy that bans paid speech complaint with the First Amendment! (caveat: I am not a lawyer, I am not a legal activist, etc)
- tptacek 2y agoRead Va Pharmacy vs Va Citizens Consumer Council to get a sense for how well you're going to fare with "paid speech is inherently untruthful". It's addressed directly!