3 ms·
Microsoft's Quake 2 AI experiment sparks negative reactions
- kirtakat 2y agoCurrently this is a fever dream of non-Euclidean space - but the fact that it can reliably do this at all is extremely impressive.
- timewizard 2y ago> but the fact that it can reliably do this at all is extremely impressive The better question is could you achieve the same thing using much less computing power and simpler methods? Would a Markov chain be able to do the same thing? If so, I'd have to with the articles sentiment, this burns a bunch of electricity to do something with extreme inefficiency and waste.
- jsheard 2y ago> The better question is could you achieve the same thing using much less computing power and simpler methods? If only there were a way to play Quake 2 on a 90mhz Pentium with 16MB of RAM...
- perrohunter 2y agoI think it's pretty cool you can start generating games this way
- jsheard 2y agoWell, nobody seems to have figured the "generating" part out yet. What we've actually seen so far is crappy approximations of games which already exist (Doom, Minecraft, Quake 2).
- Almondsetat 2y agoThis seems such an out of place comment when looking back at the last year's progress in generative AI
- jsheard 2y agoFunny you should say that, because the AI Doom demo was 8 months ago and in that time we seemingly haven't got any closer to making novel games. This Quake 2 demo is yet again just a wonky version of a pre-existing game, attempting to be a 1:1 copy of the original, rather than extrapolating something like Quake 2 that isn't literally Quake 2 again.
- fancyfredbot 2y agoGenie was generating platform games based on a sketch in Feb 24.. https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/02/29/1089317/google-deepminds-new-generative-model-makes-super-mario-like-games-from-scratch/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/02/29/1089317/google-d...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mrdependable 2y agoFrom the way Satya explains it, you can’t, but Microsoft plans to.
- crazygringo 2y agoIt won't load for me, but here's a video of someone playing from earlier today: https://youtu.be/m8Qjg7xJ2SA?si=bdcBYpz3QLK24AVR&t=151 https://youtu.be/m8Qjg7xJ2SA?si=bdcBYpz3QLK24AVR&t=151
- renewiltord 2y agoThis is absolutely incredible: surprising amount of consistency and the whole thing live-generated. It’s incredible how quickly we can get inured to technology that would have been sheer magic when I was younger. I recall being blindingly excited about Windows 98 and a gradient title bar but these days everything new I see is incredible and everyone is bored with it. I don’t get it. The game is being generated frame to frame!
- timewizard 2y ago> The game is being generated frame to frame! The world is. I would struggle to call this a "game" in the sense that it would be highly rewarding to play. It's also impossible to compete with your friends for high scores or best times. It completely ignores everything about what human "games" are and instead focuses on what the "billion dollar copyright theft machine" can crank out this week. > and everyone is bored with it. It's almost like the people pushing this technology are not human. Or don't live human experiences. I can't rightfully apprehend how they thought this would be received well. Perfection is lots of little things done well. The current AI slop is lots of things done poorly. And if you squint your eyes and tilt your head you can _almost pretend_ it's something novel. Of course it earns yawns.
- seedboot 2y ago> these days everything new I see is incredible and everyone is bored with it Information saturation
- fullshark 2y agoThis is beyond that, a lot of people are uncomfortable with computer algorithms mimicking human ingenuity and creativity, even at hackernews where we're all trying to figure out how to get rich from it.
- sva_ 2y agoPerhaps if the transistor was invented today, some people would be disgusted at how it mimicks the ingenuity of humans calculating
- r1chardnl 2y agoI wonder whether it'll be possible to compress enough of the game to make (almost) every possible scenario that you could encounter in the game be playable. Same issue that the previous AI experiment for Minecraft and others had is that objects and enemies seem to pop in and out of nowhere. Could the "learned" probability be high enough for this never to be an issue? You ever think you're seeing something in real life but it's just an optical illusion, it kinda feels like that to me. Obviously this still requires an entire game to be made before you can train on it, but could maybe open up other development and testing of games.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jsheard 2y ago> Obviously this still requires an entire game to be made before you can train on it, but could maybe open up other development and testing of games. The idea of developing a game where the "code" is totally opaque and non-deterministic honestly sounds like an absolute nightmare. How would you even begin to QA something like that?
- EvanAnderson 2y ago> The idea of developing a game where the "code" is totally opaque and non-deterministic honestly sounds like an absolute nightmare. How would you even begin to QA something like that? I have a fear that we are going to experience a significant regression in our ability to develop software as new "programmers" normalize the idea of "generating" "code" this way. Some kind of dystopian future where people who think an "is-negative" module is a good idea, but coupled with that module having been "generated" by "AI". Bone chilling. Re: QA Clearly we just need another generative "AI" to act as QA in an adversarial capacity to the "AI" generating the "code“. Turtles all the way down. "The Machine Stops".
- jsheard 2y agoThis proposed direction is even worse than generating code, it's eliminating code altogether. The project "source" would just be a big blob of weights that you indirectly prod and poke until it hopefully does what you want, and nobody could understand exactly what's going on under the hood even if they wanted to.
- twalkz 2y ago> It notes that interactions with enemies need to be improved, since they will often appear fuzzy, and that because its current context length is 0.9 seconds of gameplay (9 frames at 10fps), it will forget about objects that go out of view for longer than this. Checking out the actual video in the tweet was more impressive than this description setup for me. Definitely more “tech demo” than “game”, but pretty impressive. Side note —- what an irritating way to put an article together: - Don’t actually embed the tweet in question that contains the demo video, or even mention there’s a video - Focus on a few negative replies to the tweet from random people - The biggest piece of media on the page is a screenshot of a tweet from Tim Sweeney without any context of who he is, or that it’s a reply to the tech demo… But I guess I clicked on the link, read the article, and gave a bunch of ad impressions, so I’m part of the problem! Link to video of demo: https://x.com/geoffkeighley/status/1908593030141202635?s=46&t=6y7W1egDSobEC5yWo9u23g https://x.com/geoffkeighley/status/1908593030141202635?s=46&... Link to the demo to try yourself: https://copilot.microsoft.com/wham?features=labs-wham-enabled https://copilot.microsoft.com/wham?features=labs-wham-enable...
- itchyjunk 2y agoSince you had already figured out the gist, I was hoping you'd have shared the demo link, so I don't have them ad impressions! But I notice a YouTube link below so I'm going there instead. :)
- twalkz 2y agoRealized the hypocritical nature of my post and updated with the demo link! Copying it here too: https://copilot.microsoft.com/wham?features=labs-wham-enabled https://copilot.microsoft.com/wham?features=labs-wham-enable...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tetrisgm 2y agoAt this point, HN is the only place I see positive reception of AI products. Everywhere subreddit or gaming forum or social media I follow is overwhelmingly negative. Usually characterized as slop, stealing, low quality, or stealing jobs from craftsmen. I’m not saying AI is bad, but people are very strongly opposed to these kinds of products. In that sense, HN is the only place that seems to resonate with those.
- lostmsu 2y agoYou should look at more suitable metrics than reddit or gaming forums. Don't see reasons not to trust this source: https://explodingtopics.com/blog/most-visited-websites#top-100-most-visited-websites-globally https://explodingtopics.com/blog/most-visited-websites#top-1... ChatGPT.com is #9, above whatsapp.com, amazon.com, and netflix.com