2 ms·
From this article: > Conservationists often claim that the reason to save charismatic species is that they are necessary for the sound functioning of the ecosy
by eesmith 2y ago
From this article:
> Conservationists often claim that the reason to save charismatic species is that they are necessary for the sound functioning of the ecosystems that support humankind. Perhaps the most well-known of these stories is about the ecological changes wolves drove when they were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park. Through some 25 peer-reviewed papers, two ecologists claimed to demonstrate that the reappearance of wolves in Yellowstone changed the behavior of elk, causing them to spend less time browsing the saplings of trees near rivers. This led to a chain of cause and effect (a trophic cascade) that affected beavers, birds, and even the flow of the river. A YouTube video on the phenomenon called “How Wolves Change Rivers” has been viewed more than 45 million times.
> But other scientists were unable to replicate these findings—they discovered that the original statistics were flawed, and that human hunters likely contributed to elk population declines in Yellowstone.Ultimately, a 2019 review of the evidence by a team of researchers concluded that “the most robust science suggests trophic cascades are not evident in Yellowstone.”
- nemomarx 2y agoyeah but that's just the benefits being overstated, not a downside that I can see? and it it led to less required human hunting of elk or deer without any other effects I think that would still be beneficial in the future.
- eesmith 2y agoI'm one of those urban people with no interactions with wolves, which statistically means I agree with you. Ranchers, however, are not the only ones against wolf reintroduction. Hunters want to shoot elk or deer, and see wolves as a threat to game species. Rural land owners don't want the government telling them what they can or cannot do on their own land (ie, shoot wolves). Some think it's a waste of money, for something which isn't that important. If there were a tropic cascade as described, fewer people would think it's not worth it.