5 ms·
Honestly, most of these are necessary evils these days. New sound cards are cheaper than old ones, and don't support software mixing. Hence Pulseaudio. (Not
by jrockway 14y ago
Honestly, most of these are necessary evils these days. New sound cards are cheaper than old ones, and don't support software mixing. Hence Pulseaudio. (Not to mention things like Bluetooth headsets, which don't appear as ALSA devices and instead are natively supported by Pulseaudio.)
NetworkManager is similar -- editing wpa_supplicant configurations is a nightmare. It works from the command-line now, so it's not like it's imposing anything on you anymore.
- raverbashing 14y agoYes, wpa_supplicant is a nightmare, this is one thing FreeBSD got right I didn't need PA with any of the new sound cards, and the BT dongles don't "support" PA (some are certainly ALSA, but others may "get in" in another way), but what happens is that it makes it easier to use it with it That being said, I don't care to use new hardware, unless it's something essencial like a video card, chipsets, etc
- jrockway 14y agoThat being said, I don't care to use new hardware, unless it's something essencial like a video card, chipsets, etc. Why upgrade your computer then? You don't need the newest version of an OS if you don't want to do anything that the old version didn't do.
- raverbashing 14y agocpu speed, disk space and things that break
- kmm 14y agoHasn't software mixing been in ALSA for ages, with the dmix plugin? I don't think Pulseaudio is necessary for everything. I do see the Networkmanager is a necessary evil, but why does it have to be so awful? It's great if it works, but if it doesn't then solving the problem is extremely hard because of the bloated, uncommunicative nature of the program.
- jrockway 14y agoPulseaudio can abstract over multiple devices, allowing you to mute individual applications, move streams between physical pieces of hardware, and so on. Audio mixing in kernel-space is brittle and the wrong place for the code anyway. Doing it in userspace is more secure, more flexible, and generally a good design.
- esolyt 14y agoNot if you care about minimizing audio delay, which greatly matters in certain use cases.
- raverbashing 14y agoNothing is more brittle than Pulseaudio in a modern linux distribution. Maybe the flash plugin, but still it uses less cpu than pulseaudio usually Nowadays I only have to restart PA once a week. This is simply ridiculous. ALSA software mixing never gave me a problem.
- kmm 14y agoIn theory, maybe. In practice, Pulseaudio is just horrible and gave me troubles I have never experienced with ALSA. I'm personally convinced it's one of the biggest mistakes made in the Linux world. However, if we're going to put the sound server in userspace, which isn't a bad idea, the kernel side should be broken down. This would be an excellent time to deprecate ALSA!
- icebraining 14y agoI much prefer Wicd to NetworkManager, though.