3 ms·
Maybe it would be helpful if there were a way to see a user's 100 highest rated comments. I'm thinking it would help both in socializing the influx of new users
by Alex3917 18y ago
Maybe it would be helpful if there were a way to see a user's 100 highest rated comments. I'm thinking it would help both in socializing the influx of new users, and also in getting an idea of what a given person like.
- pc 18y agoGood idea.
- mnemonik 18y agoDon't downmod this guy(gal) in to oblivion just because (s)he didn't say too much or you don't agree... Especially in this thread. This should be reserved for trolls. I think a nice 0 or -1 (to discourage pointless comments) would be fine but (s)he's already at -3 when this is still a pretty new submission. Don't hop on the bandwagon just because.
- someperson 18y agoReplying to comment with "Good Idea." serves no purpose. That user's account is nearly 2 years old, they know better than to post that. Pointless comments should be discouraged just as much as trolling should be.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davi 18y agoCurrently, just clicking on a username and then clicking on the comments link in the user profile gives me a pretty good sense of what that user is like. My highest rated comment so far occurred yesterday, when I got 30 points for saying something reasonably good early on in a popular post. I think other people agreed with what I said, and so (appropriately) just upvoted the comment rather than repeating it. If your proposed feature just ended up displaying lots of comments like these, it might not be that great. A somewhat related idea might be to let longstanding/high karma users add a 'top N favorite comments' list to their profile. When you looked at a user's profile, you could click through to see their favorites, and the comments by them favorited by others. (Users could add their own comments to their favorites list, if they wanted to.) I can think of several users right now whose favorites would be interesting to me.
- wensing 18y agoMy highest rated comment so far occurred yesterday, when I got 30 points for saying something reasonably good early on in a popular post. I think other people agreed with what I said, and so (appropriately) just upvoted the comment rather than repeating it. This is why some indication of a user's median karma per comment would be at least as insightful as his or her total.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- spydez 18y agoSearchYC.com can do some sorting of user's comments. e.g. http://searchyc.com/user/Alex3917 http://searchyc.com/user/Alex3917
- dkasper 18y agoYikes, link appears to be broken!