4 ms·
> he would've had a legal basis to prosecute Hillary Clinton for felonies America is currently ann argument against popular democracy. Before we concede that e
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> he would've had a legal basis to prosecute Hillary Clinton for felonies
America is currently ann argument against popular democracy. Before we concede that electoral politics don’t work in a world with social media, maybe we can give increased prosecutorial discretion a chance. The alternative, after all, is just more authoritarian.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoAre you prepared to give several Trump appointed judges prosecutorial discretion over who can run in the midterms and 2028? The problem that prosecutorial discretion will have to overcome is selective enforcement, or the perception thereof. The right wing European media is claiming this was common practice across parties. Now I don't know the truth of it, but it is a hard thought to get out of ones head, and a hard negative to prove. wrt Le Pen, I find it noteworthy that evey English news article I have read avoids describing the actual crime [1], Which does seem more substantial than 99% of the Trump cases. https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2024/09/30/why-le-pen-and-26-other-far-right-party-members-are-standing-trial-in-paris-in-fake-eu-parliament-jobs-case_6727729_8.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2024/09/30/w...
- jonathanstrange 2y agoThis works differently in France. Americans need to stop comparing everything to their own country, your country not as great a democracy as you might think.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI'm mostly talking about the US, and not claiming it is great. That said, in what ways do you think France is different?
- jonathanstrange 2y agoAccounting politicians for crimes is not a problem as long as the judicial system is sufficiently independent from the executive. It is my impression that the French justice system is more independent and better protected against the executive branch than the US justice system, but I admit that I'm not an expert on comparing the two systems and could be wrong. It's really just a hunch aggregated from what I've heard over the years.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI don't know about France, but in the US, the prosecution falls under the executive, while the judges are independent. This means the POTUS can decide who gets investigated and charged for a crime, and who doesn't get investigated and who gets charges dropped. The executive can investigate its enemies, and ignore or drop charges for its friends.
- guizmo 2y agoIt is looks very similar in France and in the US to some extent. I copy a post I made somewhere in this thread as I think it can help here: Prosecutors are formally under executive control but since 2013 the justice minister should not give orders on individual cases. France has an additional layer of independence compared to the U.S. because of the juge d’instruction (investigating judge), who is supposed to be independent from the executive like the courts judges, unlike prosecutors. I say in principle because judges are appointed in France and not elected (similarly to federal judge in the US from what I understood). The executive as some control through appointments and career advancements but they are not supposed to use it to sanction or reward the judges. The effectiveness of these independence mechanisms remains a subject of active debate, as evidenced by the relatively recent changes made to them.
- a_dabbler 2y agoThe voting system (FPTP) in the US results in a two party system which isn't representative of a good democratic system imo. Considering all of the different political divides I don't think two parties sufficiently cover the spectrum of opinions/stances.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> voting system (FPTP) in the US results in a two party system which isn't representative of a good democratic system imo We have non-FPTP jurisdictions. They still default to partisanship. (The problem is probably too many elections, not enough reliance on appointment and selection by lot.)
- rayiner 2y agoQuite the opposite! Democracy is working in America, whereas it’s in jeopardy in (some parts of) Europe. You’re confusing “democracy” with “liberalism.” Democracy is not about free trade, or protecting immigrants, or the like. It’s about people being able to vote to live in the kind of society they want. If people want to pull back on liberalism in certain areas that’s democratic. What’s undemocratic is saying that “you can vote for anything you want as long as it’s liberalism.” There’s a reaction throughout the entire west to free trade and immigration. In America, a plurality of voters supported the guy who promised mass deportations and tariffs, and now they’re getting exactly what they voted for. Maybe they won’t like the results, maybe they’ll be thrilled with them. The results will simply inform the next vote. What’s deeply broken are european systems that are trying to maintain liberalism at the expense of democracy. But not all the european countries. Denmark and Sweden have retrenched on liberalism in the area of immigration—Denmark’s youngest generation is now more Danish than the population as a whole—and have largely solved the political polarization over the issue. That’s democracy working very well.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> It’s about people being able to vote to live in the kind of society they want. If people want to pull back on liberalism in certain areas that’s democratic. Sure. And when the Athenians recalled Alcibiades [1] or put Socrates to death, that was democratic. I’m not arguing it’s not democratic. I’m arguing those were self-destructive acts that show the system didn’t work. Note that I’m making a distinctly illiberal argument. In that, I dovetail with Trump’s supporters. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcibiades https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcibiades
- rayiner 2y agoBut the system worked! Immigration and the economy consistently rank as voters’ two key issues. On immigration, the decades-long elite consensus was for more immigration, including illegal immigration. But voters successfully defeated that elite consensus. They voted for mass deportations, got a guy who has started doing mass deportations, and as of the latest Yougov/CBS polling, overwhelmingly approve of Trump’s deportation program (58% approve, 42% oppose): https://www.cbsnews.com/news/opinion-poll-trump-economy-tariffs-deportation-immigration/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/opinion-poll-trump-economy-tari.... Voters being able to override elite consensus to effectuate change to make the country more like what they want is the system working!
- mmooss 2y agoMaybe we just need to stop quitting and capitulating, and commit to our liberty and self-determination. Prior generations committed their 'lives, fortunes, and honor'. We just need to fix social media, which will take an activated society.
- MonkeyClub 2y ago> Prior generations committed their 'lives, fortunes, and honor'. I think you hit the nail on the head with this. We don't have honor as a social parameter any longer, so lives and fortunes lack the oomph of honor. Granted, we also avoid the historically evinced drawbacks of honor-based societies, but we seem to have thrown the baby out with the bathwater.