4 ms·
The reason that keeps me on Windows, is that you left out of your list gaming and 3D graphics on laptops. Metal isn't really on pair with Vulkan and DirectX in
by pjmlp 2y ago
The reason that keeps me on Windows, is that you left out of your list gaming and 3D graphics on laptops.
Metal isn't really on pair with Vulkan and DirectX in terms of relevance for graphics programming, the M chips aren't up to NVidia ecosystem, SYCL, the two major compute APIs for any kind of relevant GPGPU workloads, and thus don't really matter.
And gaming, well, even though all major engines support Metal, there is a reason DirectX porting kit is now a thing.
So why pay more for a lesser experience, and then there is the whole issue macOS doesn't have native support for containers, like Windows does (their own ones), and WSL is better integrated and easier to use than Virtualization Framework.
- WD-42 2y agoGaming is pretty great on Linux now. I just finished a little Elden ring session and it still blows my mind that when I close the game my Linux desktop is there behind it. No more dual booting, hopefully will never need windows for anything ever again.
- pjmlp 2y agoYou mean translating Windows and DirectX APIs is great, there is hardly a Linux gaming ecosystem. Proton is the acknowledgment of Valve's failure to entice game studios, already targeting Vulkan/OpenGL ES/OpenSL on Android NDK, Switch (which has OpenGL 4.6/Vulkan support), or on PlayStation (Orbis OS being a FreeBSD fork) to target GNU/Linux. I rather have the real deal, not translations.
- ubercow13 2y agoWhen I was gaming on Linux, every game with a native version worked better using the Windows version in proton. I think the only exception was Factorio.
- WD-42 2y agoStrange take. Proton is an acknowledgment that the windows apis are the de facto for gaming. Not sure why the runtime matters. Some games ever run better. Not sure why that’s not the ”real deal” but whatever I’m glad you’re happy with your spyware gaming OS.
- pjmlp 2y agoNot really, I rather play on the platform they were designed for in first place.
- nottorp 2y agoDo you own a Playstation? :) If you're playing the likes of Fromsoft/Resident Evil/Kojima games on a PC, be it Windows or Linux, you're not playing on the platform those games were designed for.
- pjmlp 2y agoThe problem with your reasoning is that Windows/PC doesn't need to emulate Orbit OS and LibGNM, Sony also supports Direct X and Win32 directly on their engines.
- dijit 2y agoAs an actual dyed in the wool game developer. There’s no such thing as “native”, all the things you’re talking about are translation layers for hardware instructions themselves, and the overhead for doing software based translation is significantly less than hardware accelerated virtual machines- and we as an industry love those. The reason for this is because the translations are very cache friendly and happen in userland, so the performance impact is negligible, and the scheduler on Windows is so poor compared to Linux ones that it’s even common for games to perform better on Linux than on Windows.. Which is crazy when you consider the difference in quality of the GPU drivers. I understand that you want it to “just work”, but that tends to be the experience anyway. You can do what you want, it’s your life, but this is not a terribly good excuse. Valves “failure” is essentially rectified. I will add though, that it’s actually Stadia that made linux gaming the most feasible, many game engines (all of the ones I worked on) were ported to Linux to run Stadia, those ports changed essential elements of the engine that would have been slow or difficult to translate; so when Proton came around quite a lot of heavy lifting had gone away. I only say this because Valve gets some credit for a lot of work our Engine programmers did to make Linux viable.
- pjmlp 2y agoSo how many of those ported game engines are actually making a different on GNU/Linux gaming today? There is certainly such thing as native, one thing is the platform where the APIs were originally designed for and battled tested, and the other is other platform emulating / translating them, by reverse engineering their behaviours with various degrees of success. Valve's luck is that so far Microsoft/XBox Gaming has decided to close an eye on Proton, and it will run out when Microsoft decides it has gone long enough.
- dijit 2y ago> So how many of those ported game engines are actually making a different on GNU/Linux gaming today? Not sure, Unreal Engine is pretty popular though and Snowdrop is increasingly common for Ubisoft titles. https://www.protondb.com/app/2842040 https://www.protondb.com/app/2842040 https://www.protondb.com/app/2840770/ https://www.protondb.com/app/2840770/ https://www.protondb.com/app/365590 https://www.protondb.com/app/365590
- sph 2y agoI'd rather use Linux and game with an imperfect translation layer, than put up with Windows. Proton is a lesser implementation of Windows API, sure, but Windows itself is a lesser implementation of an operating system for power users.
- boudin 2y agoIt's not really a failure. Linux distribution and diverse ecosystem brings a level of complexity. The only way to support it long term is to either having your team continuously update and release builds of the game to cater for that which is an impossible task to ask for a lot of studios. The initial approach of runtimes did help but it's still has its limitation. If now a studio just need to test their game under a runtime+proton the same way they would test a version of Windows to ensure it's working under Linux it's a win/win situation. Proton becomes the abstraction of the complex and diverse ecosystem of Linux which is both its strength and weakness. Another solution would have been everybody using the exact same distribution which would have been way worse in my opinion. And who knows, maybe one day Proton/Wine would be the Windows userland reference and Windows would just be an implementation of it :D
- pjmlp 2y agoSo it is not really a failure when the solution is to adopt Windows and Direct X translation API? I thought only Apple had a distortion field.
- troupo 2y agoIt's a complete failure across the board to create any compelling graphics APIs for desktop platforms (both Linux and Mac) beyond DirectX.
- octopoc 2y agoThat’s not the goal though. The goal is to play games on Linux. If Valve’s goal was to end up with a Linux-specific graphics api for most games that run on Linux then they provably would have tried to do so.
- nottorp 2y agoIs it a failure when everyone writes javascript/html/css instead of doing native applications for non gaming? Most of HN seems to think using a web browser as a translation layer is a good idea, yet they complain when games use a translation layer.
- mythz 2y agoGaming/WSL kept me on Windows for a lot of the last decade, however after Windows 10 became EOL'd and Windows started turning into ad/spyware I finally gave it up over a year ago after 25+ years on Windows Desktops. Anyway Linux is liberating, Fedora Desktop is great, no ads in the OS, a Software Store/Installer I actually like to use, curated by usefulness instead of scam Apps. All my Windows Steam Games I frequently use just worked, I have to login to X11 for 1 title (MK11), but everything else runs in the default Wayland desktop. Although I'll still check protondb.com before purchasing new games to make sure there'll be no issues. Thanks to Docker, JetBrains IDEs and most Daily Apps I use are cross-platform Desktop Web Apps (e.g. VS Code, Discord, Obsidian, etc) I was able to run everything I wanted to. The command-line is also super charged in Linux starting with a GPU-accelerated Gnome terminal/ptyxis and Ghostty running Oh My Zsh that's enhanced with productivity tools like fzf, eza, bat, zoxide and starship. There's also awesome tools like lazydocker, lazygit, btop and neovim pushing the limits of what's possible in a terminal UI and distrobox which lets me easily run Ubuntu VMs to install experimental software without impacting my Fedora Desktop. Image editors is the one area still lacking in Linux. On Windows I used Affinity Designer/Photo and Paint.NET for quick edits. On macOS I use Affinity & Pixelmator. On Linux we have to chose between Pinta (Paint.NET port), Krita and GIMP which are weaker and less intuitive alternatives. But with the new major release of GIMP 3 and having just discovered photopea.com things are starting to look up.
- pjmlp 2y agoI hardly find anything interesting about command-line, I grew up in a time where the command line was the only way to interact with home computers, it fails on me the interest on staying stuck in up to early 1980's computing model. Xerox PARC is the future many of us want to be in, not PDP-11 clones.
- mythz 2y agoWeird flex, most commands, utilities, server software and remote tools are going to be run are going to be from the command-line. All our System Administration of remote servers uses the command-line as well since exclusively deploying to Linux for 10+ years. Sure you can happily avoid the command-line with a Linux Desktop and GUI Apps, although as a developer I don't see how I could avoid using the terminal. Even on Windows I was using WSL a lot, it's just uncanny valley and slow compared to a real Linux terminal.
- troupo 2y ago> Metal isn't really on pair with Vulkan and DirectX in terms of relevance for graphics programming As if Vulkan had relevance to graphics programming. > and WSL is better integrated and easier to use than Virtualization Framework. you don't need WSL on MacOS because, well, MacOS is already a *nix environment.
- regularfry 2y ago> you don't need WSL on MacOS because, well, MacOS is already a *nix environment. Right up until you need Linux syscalls. If you're doing anything with containers it's an annoyance.
- pjmlp 2y ago> As if Vulkan had relevance to graphics programming. It surely has on 80% of a mobile platform, and on a small handset from this little japanese games company. > troupo 3 hours ago | parent | context | flag | on: Apple needs a Snow Sequoia > Metal isn't really on pair with Vulkan and DirectX in terms of relevance for graphics programming As if Vulkan had relevance to graphics programming. > you don't need WSL on MacOS because, well, MacOS is already a *nix environment. Agree if everything one wants out of it is classical UNIX experience, that breaks down when having to work with containers and kubernetes locally.
- troupo 2y ago> It surely has on 80% of a mobile platform, And which platform brings in more money? > and on a small handset from this little japanese games company. And not on PS, not on XBox, not on PC (that is, no first-party support).
- jamespo 2y agoGaming on windows is fine, but there's no reason to use windows for anything else. Dual boot to linux for a better desktop and none of the crud that Windows 11 has in it.
- timeon 2y agoI haven't been gaming since when there was huge gap between graphical possibilities and actual design (that is beginning of 3d era) - so I do not miss that. However I can see the decline in macOS, like pushing for 'apple intelligence', more and more restricting gatekeeper, iOS-ification of desktop (ie.: mentioned system settings), constant connections to AWS, etc. But since I'm not gaming I cannot imagine going back to Windows. On the other hand I'm quite enjoying Linux... > So why pay more for a lesser experience ...however, with few exceptions, I haven't used mouse in decade... and I haven't found anything like MBP's touchpad yet. Maybe I just need to do better research.