4 ms·
I just turned two-factor authentication on and it forced me to set "program specific" passwords for like 10 different apps and seriously messed up my phone. I h
by Kiro 14y ago
I just turned two-factor authentication on and it forced me to set "program specific" passwords for like 10 different apps and seriously messed up my phone. I had to deactivate it. What's with the hassle?
- Semaphor 14y agoNot everything supports the 2-factor auth. And of course you have to set up specific passwords for those. ONCE! You wont have to do that again. What did you expect? That it magically made everything work? Some people -.- And I have no clue how you managed to mess up your phone… By entering new passwords??
- Kiro 14y agoWhy can't they just use my "old" password? I don't want to set up 10 new passwords. And yes, I was expecting it to magically work by just enabling it and enter the SMS code. This is too much hassle for something I don't really care about (I don't keep anything of value anywhere online or in my computer/phone).
- Semaphor 14y agoWhy? Maybe because that would defeat the whole purpose? And why use a (relatively, before someone calls me out) high security measure for something unimportant in the first place? You wouldn't use a full biometric security scanner setup for your pantry either, would you?
- maxerickson 14y agoFor the second factor to mean anything, all the apps that don't support it need a password that has less rights. Hopefully they figure out a nice way to make the rights more granular (so that a chat app can't mess with email or whatever).
- sp332 14y agoDo those passwords have less rights? I figured that if any of those passwords got compromised, you were screwed (until you found out which one and revoked it).
- maxerickson 14y agoA little less. They can't be combined with the 2nd step verification to make changes to settings that require 2 step verification. So instead of losing access to your account, you just lose all your email (yay!).
- sp332 14y agoThis has always been the part I don't like about Google's 2-factor auth. Right now, I have one strong password that would have to be compromised to access my email. If I enable 2-factor, suddenly I have (last time I tried it) about 20 new passwords, any one of which could yield access to my email. That does not really seem more secure.
- maxerickson 14y agoI think the more important question is whether it is less secure. It does make it harder to seize control of the account (which might be a lame consolation, but backups are a good idea either way), and it is (potentially) more convenient in the event that one device is lost or misplaced. Someone who previously always logged out might be exposing themselves to more risk by storing the app passwords, but I think that's about the only case where it is worse.
- sp332 14y agoIt decreases the severity of a breach but increases the likelihood. Per-app passwords can't be used to take over an account. But they can be used to read my email. I think just shifting the permissions a little so that I can "authenticate" without also giving out the creds to my email would be acceptable.