3 ms·
Thinner Films Conduct Better Than Copper
- sopchi 2y agoThe research described was done at Stanford by Profs Eric Pop and Krishna Saraswat. Paper in Science: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adq7096 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adq7096
- sbierwagen 2y agoAlso posted on arxiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.17337 https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.17337
- bee_rider 2y agoThe title here is sort of confusing-thinner films? Thinner than what? And what are these thin films made of? Maybe something like “thin film semi metals conduct better than copper” would be better?
- motorest 2y ago> The title here is sort of confusing-thinner films? Thinner than what? And what are these thin films made of? You answer all your questions if you read the first paragraph of the article. The second paragraph even specified the exact material and thickness.
- themaninthedark 2y agoThe only thing I think that the title could make clearer is that this is at or below nm scale, but that too is in the first paragraph.
- NikkiA 2y ago"New niobium thin film conducts better than copper" would have been my choice, but it would probably get butchered by the autofilter to something as useless as the current title anyway, because 'new' is probably elided, as would 'than'.
- jonasenordin 2y agoConductivity: Film at Eleven
- infogulch 2y agoCool! Or lukewarm. Or both since they tested from 5K to 300K. And found that the thin films (5-18nm) 'behaved like' metals wrt temperature dependence of resistivity, where thicker films of the same material (80nm) 'behaved like' insulators. I wonder how traditional superconductor materials would fare in a super thin film regime like this.
- larkost 2y agoThe linked article does not go into many details about what they are measuring. So I have to wonder: could this property be used to make thinner wires for conducting electricity in bulk (e.g.: hosing wires, or transmission lines) by stacking lots of very thin layers into a cable. I imagine there would be a good amount of development work to make manufacturing such a layered cable, so it would not be right around the corner. But is there any physical barrier to such a development?
- lawlessone 2y agoheat might be an issue
- croemer 2y agoCorrect title is "New Films Conduct Better the Thinner They Get"
- deepsun 2y agoI wonder if that's only about direct current. The higher frequency is AC, the more it conducts on sides of the wire (hence insulated strands). So I wouldn't be surprised by their discovery if we talked about very high frequency AC. But since it all reversed here it might by opposite for AC in their case. UPDATE: paper says something about RF (radio frequency), but I'm not sure I understand what it means, looks more like manufacturing process.
- adrian_b 2y agoBecause copper is no longer a good enough conductor when it it is used in very thin layers, the latest and densest CMOS fabrication processes have begun to replace copper with other metals for the first 2 metal layers, which are the thinnest. It is not known with certainty what metals are currently used by Intel or TSMC, though cobalt and ruthenium have been considered as the most promising choices. There has been a lot of speculation about whether the choice of cobalt for the thinnest metal layers has been an important cause of Intel's woes with their "10 nm" CMOS fabrication process. While there were chances for this hypothesis to be true, the actual reasons for Intel's failure to achieve the predicted clock frequencies and fabrication yields with their "10 nm" processes remain unknown, because Intel has never published any information about this. Whichever was the reason, eventually Intel has succeeded to fix this fabrication process, even if only around 5 years later than in their initial plan, after rebranding it in "Intel 7", at least from the point of view of the achievable performances, which have culminated in Raptor Lake Refresh, though perhaps Intel's incapacity of predicting accurately the reliability behavior as a function of the supply voltage, as demonstrated in many failures of Raptor Lake/Alder Lake CPUs, may indicate that they have never succeeded to understand the exact characteristics of this fabrication process.
- q3k 2y ago> It is not known with certainty what metals are currently used by Intel or TSMC, though cobalt and ruthenium have been considered as the most promising choices. Wait, shouldn't that be easy to find out? Section/delayer a chip and throw it under a SEM-EDX system?
- hnuser123456 2y agoAlright, who here has the delidding tools and SEM? Let's crack this egg
- q3k 2y agoI mean I have access to SEM with EDX [1] and I can (poorly) crack open chips [2], 'just' need to get some LN to run the EDX... I just can't believe this isn't something that another lab has already done and published! [1] - https://wiki.fa-fo.de/equipment:zeiss-dsm-962 https://wiki.fa-fo.de/equipment:zeiss-dsm-962 ; it's still not 100% restored [2] - Here's what I believe to be metal1 on a RP2350: https://object.ceph-eu.hswaw.net/q3k-personal/c98c23b8db73df4f523c5d6f601e8062bc1d3c3dbe68460a93e80d40f1bc2057.png https://object.ceph-eu.hswaw.net/q3k-personal/c98c23b8db73df...
- dieselerator 2y agoThe research looks detailed and interesting. However, I don't follow this summary article. Digital circuits dissipate most of the energy charging and discharging capacitance. It must necessarily dissipate that as heat (except for a minor amount of electro-magnetic radiation). The interconnect resistance hardly matters. Of course RC relay can be a factor for some circuits. We can hope this reasearch leads to improvement there. Power supply bus resistance can lead to voltage drops, but this research apparently studies layers much too thin for that application. Did I missing something?
- mystified5016 2y agoThe interconnect resistance does matter as resistance is a function of cross-sectional area. It's related to the physical size of the conductor. Lower resistance conductors can be physically smaller while carrying the same amount of current. But the real trick is if you can increase your switching speed, you lose less energy in the transistor. All the time in between 0 and 1, the transistor is burning energy as heat rather than conducting current. Lower R in your interconnect means your RC time constant goes down and your switching speed goes up. Your transistor spends less time in the linear region and wastes less energy. But yes, these are pretty small effects on the whole. That's really just where the industry is at: incremental improvements until the Next Big Thing comes along. Additional nit: up to 50% of the energy put into gate capacitance could be recovered. It's not necessary to waste 100%, it's just dramatically cheaper and easier. Honestly I doubt there's any practical benefit as the chip would become quite a lot larger.
- rbanffy 2y ago> Honestly I doubt there's any practical benefit as the chip would become quite a lot larger. There will be at some point when area becomes too small to accommodate the heating and the added complexity becomes a way to shrink the entire chip to sizes that wouldn’t be possible otherwise.