4 ms·

Thing is... UX is terrible everywhere in the 3D editing space. That's not even criticism of Blender as far as I can tell!

ardupper 2y ago
Perhaps it’s high time to admit that nobody has a great solution for 3D editing quite yet :P
CyberDildonics 2y ago
This could not be further from the truth. Different programs have interfaces that are better for certain tasks, but Houdini, Maya and Softimage XSI have all had fantastic interfaces for the most part. Software like that should be used as the benchmark other UIs are compared to. I don't know anything other software that comes close.
- nonchalantsui 2y ago
  I wouldn’t go that far to say that they have fantastic interfaces. Tolerable? Better than what free options existed at the time? Either way, there is a lot of room for improvement but it’s also an extremely challenging environment to get interfaces right. We are still in what is effectively the skeuomorphism for the music production industry phase (where everyone is just replicating real life tooling because that’s the expectation and with that comes a lot of unchecked baggage — except for Maya, Blender, etc it’s mostly about making assumptions based on past tooling and polishing that a tiny bit), eventually there will be a Logic to change those bad habits!
  - CyberDildonics 2y ago
    except for Maya, Blender, etc it’s mostly about making assumptions based on past tooling I think you're mistaking the necessity of not straying too much from the actual math going on underneath with an attachment of old tools. eventually there will be a Logic to change those bad habits! Go ahead and give an example of 'a Logic' so you can show some evidence for this.
- SunlitCat 2y ago
  Nah. It's a problem many creative tools have (and an interesting one!). You can't squeeze one creative workflow (suitable for everyone) into a general UI.
  - CyberDildonics 2y ago
    Nah, what you are saying is vague and dismissive but doesn't hold up to the reality of fast flexible tools like these. Have you used maya, XSI, nuke and houdini?
    - SunlitCat 2y ago
      No, I haven't, CyberDildonics!
emkoemko 2y ago
no i think that award goes to zbrush... the most backwards non intuitive UX/UI ever made

ardupper 2y ago

Perhaps it’s high time to admit that nobody has a great solution for 3D editing quite yet :P

CyberDildonics 2y ago

This could not be further from the truth. Different programs have interfaces that are better for certain tasks, but Houdini, Maya and Softimage XSI have all had fantastic interfaces for the most part. Software like that should be used as the benchmark other UIs are compared to. I don't know anything other software that comes close.

nonchalantsui 2y ago
I wouldn’t go that far to say that they have fantastic interfaces. Tolerable? Better than what free options existed at the time? Either way, there is a lot of room for improvement but it’s also an extremely challenging environment to get interfaces right. We are still in what is effectively the skeuomorphism for the music production industry phase (where everyone is just replicating real life tooling because that’s the expectation and with that comes a lot of unchecked baggage — except for Maya, Blender, etc it’s mostly about making assumptions based on past tooling and polishing that a tiny bit), eventually there will be a Logic to change those bad habits!
- CyberDildonics 2y ago
  except for Maya, Blender, etc it’s mostly about making assumptions based on past tooling I think you're mistaking the necessity of not straying too much from the actual math going on underneath with an attachment of old tools. eventually there will be a Logic to change those bad habits! Go ahead and give an example of 'a Logic' so you can show some evidence for this.
SunlitCat 2y ago
Nah. It's a problem many creative tools have (and an interesting one!). You can't squeeze one creative workflow (suitable for everyone) into a general UI.
- CyberDildonics 2y ago
  Nah, what you are saying is vague and dismissive but doesn't hold up to the reality of fast flexible tools like these. Have you used maya, XSI, nuke and houdini?
  - SunlitCat 2y ago
    No, I haven't, CyberDildonics!

emkoemko 2y ago

no i think that award goes to zbrush... the most backwards non intuitive UX/UI ever made