8 ms·
Last time HN discussed this story, I said "turn on 2-factor authentication for your Google account". Unsurprisingly, I got the exact reaction I'm seeing here w
by nl 14y ago
Last time HN discussed this story, I said "turn on 2-factor authentication for your Google account".
Unsurprisingly, I got the exact reaction I'm seeing here when it has been suggested: lots of questions about how it works, people who think their situation is unique so it won't work for them, and people complaining than SMS is insecure.
1) Don't ask anymore questions. Try it out, if you hate it turn it off.
2) Your situation almost certainly isn't unique. You get 10 codes to print out, you can have (revokable) application-specific passwords that don't require the token. Try it!!
3) Use the smartphone application.
Don't ask any more questions - just try it out!
- LVB 14y agoDefinitely print the codes! As a newbie I didn't, and as luck (or a 1/30 chance) would have it, I forgot my phone at home the same day my 30-day login window expired at work. Not a huge deal but a bit of a PITA, and there really was no way to log in until after I got home (which is obviously the point). Now I have some codes squirreled away in a couple key locations.
- draven 14y agoSame here, I changed my phone provider and the details on how to activate my new subscription were sent to my gmail account. When I connected to my GMail account the session had timed out. This was some kind of cyclic dependency: I needed my phone to get the details on how to make the phone working. I felt incredibly stupid. So... print the codes! (I managed to get the information by visiting GMail from my Linux box where the login didn't expire, but still)
- pooriaazimi 14y agoPrint 2 copies of the the codes and take a screenshot of that page. Then type "gpg -c sensitive.png" and use the same password as your gmail account to secure it. Then put "sensitive.png.gpg" in "~/.ssh" or another place out of the way and forget about it, until the day comes that you'll need it.
- smackfu 14y agoThis seems like poor advice. If people have questions, they should be addressed, not "oh don't worry your pretty little head, smart people came up with this." Like the discussion about app-specific passwords above was very informative to me... all it takes is one of those getting sniffed or read off disk and someone can suck down all your email. Not exactly "fire and forget" security.
- nl 14y agoI'm not arguing that it is perfect. I'm saying that people should turn it on, and try it. Most of the questions are the kind of things that would be solved by just trying it!
- cbs 14y ago>Don't ask any more questions - just try it out! Not even these question: Aren't we as tech people completely and utterly failing the world at large when the best possible response to this story is to turn on 2 factor auth on one of the many accounts a person has? Is a very slight reduction to the attack surface really the best we can do? Seriously?
- nl 14y agoIs a very slight reduction to the attack surface really the best we can do? At the moment, yes, I think it is. At some point in the future perhaps this may improve (although I wouldn't count on it).