8 ms·
I've been having enormous trouble understanding the thinking behind the "We are proud to only accept Visa" marketing campaign. I simply can't understand how it
by simonw 14y ago
I've been having enormous trouble understanding the thinking behind the "We are proud to only accept Visa" marketing campaign. I simply can't understand how it could be viewed positively by any consumer - it's such an obviously anti-customer thing to do.
I've been trying really hard to understand why Visa would make such an obviously unfriendly and counter-productive decision. The only theory I can come up with is that their real customers are the banks, and this is their way of saying to them "We're so completely ruthless that you're better off doing deals with us than anyone else". Seems a bit far-fetched though.
- dangrossman 14y ago> I simply can't understand how it could be viewed positively by any consumer Visa's market research suggests a significant increase in Visa usage and Visa brand value among consumers aware of their Olympic sponsorship (which has been ongoing since 1986, and already committed through the next 4 Olympics games): > According to the U.S. Sponsorship Tracker, a Visa commissioned study following the Vancouver 2010 Olympic Winter Games conducted by Performance Research, an independent research company, Visa cardholders who were aware of Visa’s Olympic Games sponsorship claimed a 16 percent and nine percent increase in Visa card usage in Canada and the US respectively. The same report found Visa’s brand equity was 32 percent and 38 percent higher among consumers who were aware of Visa’s sponsorship in Canada and the US respectively. http://corporate.visa.com/_media/olympic-games-media-kit/visa-and-the-olympic-games.pdf http://corporate.visa.com/_media/olympic-games-media-kit/vis... > I've been trying really hard to understand why Visa would make such an obviously unfriendly and counter-productive decision The first Olympics game where Visa was exclusively accepted was Calgary 1988. This isn't a decision they just made.
- jacalata 14y agoHe wasn't asking 'why sponsor the olympics', he was asking 'why take the exclusive angle'. Saying 'they've been doing it for years' does not answer that.
- thebigshane 14y agoSaying "they've been doing it for years" implies that it probably works. That is the answer (well okay, it's his answer)
- Deestan 14y agoThat's basically a "Monkey Cage" answer. http://paws.kettering.edu/~jhuggins/humor/banana.html http://paws.kettering.edu/~jhuggins/humor/banana.html
- thebigshane 14y agoFunny but not very enlightening. This isn't a case of generations of companies still following the same pointless habits (wearing suits and ties, etc). If those monkeys were responsible for monitoring a return on a 700 million dollar investment, I think that one of monkeys would try to investigate the situation further. Also, I think science suggests humans are smarter than monkeys [citation needed].
- nopassrecover 14y ago> Visa's market research suggests a significant increase in Visa usage and Visa brand value among consumers aware of their Olympic sponsorship. Couldn't this be that heavy-Visa users notice the company's sponsorship and usage more generally? This doesn't really prove that Olympics sponsorship increases usage. > The same report found Visa’s brand equity was higher among consumers who were aware of Visa’s sponsorship. Again, couldn't it just be that the kinds of people who notice that Visa sponsors things are the kinds of people who already like Visa? This doesn't establish that sponsoring the Olympics helps Visa.
- roel_v 14y ago"Again, couldn't it just be that the kinds of people who notice that Visa sponsors things are the kinds of people who already like Visa?" Could be, but it's highly unlikely that a company who does surveys as its core business doesn't know this and tries to control for it, or at least explain it in they methodology section of the report they deliver.
- jellicle 14y ago>According to the U.S. Sponsorship Tracker, a Visa commissioned study following the Vancouver 2010 Olympic Winter Games conducted by Performance Research When a company is paying for research about its own decisions, the research always comes back that the decision was wonderful, or that research firm doesn't get hired again.
- pyre 14y agoJust depends on whether or not the results are meant to public consumption. I find it hard that no one at Visa would want an honest study from time to time, but I can also easily believe that sometimes studies are commissioned with the end-goal being to justify an already set-in-store decision.
- thebigshane 14y agoWouldn't they just be able to look at their own records to see any trends (or lack thereof)? Presumably Visa is investing multi-millions of dollars of into this, surely they expect to see a return on that investment. If the fail to see that return, surely they would stop. They haven't stopped. I'm thinking that the research firm was probably right.
- brazzy 14y agoVisa is not a person. The person who sponsored that campaign probably prioritizes his career over the RoI of the company.
- thebigshane 14y agoI doubt it was one person who decided, negotiated and implemented the sponsoring of this campaign. So what is your point? Does it really seem reasonable to you that no one would notice how entirely unprofitable (hypothetically) the investment is? Over the course of a dozen+ years!?
- brazzy 14y agoIt could quite easily be one high-ranking manager who decided and pushed through such a campaign, and now uses company money to pay for research that "proves" its success and enables him to brush off those who doubt it but lack similar clout. This kind of thing is par of the course for company politics. But probably unlikely to persist this long.
- apike 14y agoA lot of us in Vancouver really resented the "only accepts Visa" thing. It was particularly aggravating in Canada where most people pay with a bank debit card, not Visa or Mastercard. That said, it's not surprising that the overall effect of the sponsorship was positive since refusing MasterCard and debit was only one small aspect of Visa's campaign. Reading about this again in London made me all riled up again, but Morgan Freeman's soothing voice will likely undo the damage soon enough.
- thaumasiotes 14y agoMy bank debit card... IS Visa. I don't think I would have been able to get one that wasn't.
- apike 14y agoIn Canada, debit cards are run by a not-for-profit venture founded by the major banks called Interac. Everybody's standard ATM bank card is usable as a debit card. This is the most common method of payment in the country.
- linuxhansl 14y agoThat is completely besides the point. I'm sure people appreciate VISA's Olympic sponsorship, there is little question about this. Exclusive sponsorship if different from limiting the choices of vendors and customers. People do not like being limited in their choices, I do not think that benefited them.
- VigUi7vv8G2 14y agoRight, but being a Olympics sponsor is mainly something people find out about on TV, not by actually going to the games. Where is the evidence that actually preventing people from using mastercard helps?
- pbreit 14y agoI'm not sure I even understand what is being reported. I have little doubt that the opposite could be demonstrated with equally valid numbers. And did they also survey for spectator displeasure?
- dangrossman 14y agoIf spectator displeasure was a problem on the scale Visa could care about, then brand equity among those surveyed would have gone down instead of up. Why would they care to survey that directly? What matters is whether the sponsorship is a net gain for the Visa brand or not. The research says it is, big time.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoIn socialist Europe, banks own YOU! :-). But seriously, the banks screw with their customers so much over here that this is just another bump on the road. To me, "proud to only accept Visa" sounds like "F@#k you MasterCard and your users, too"...
- andrewfelix 14y ago>In socialist Europe, banks own YOU! Americans have a lot more personal debt than Europeans. 'In Free Market America, banks own YOU!' would be more appropriate.
- ktizo 14y agoHere's some nice charts on this theme. http://rwer.wordpress.com/2012/01/01/debt-britannia-with-16-graphs/ http://rwer.wordpress.com/2012/01/01/debt-britannia-with-16-... You aren't doing as badly as you think. [edit] I assumed you were based in america, but apparently you are in sydney, sorry for confusion and random assumptioness. However, this means that according to the first chart on the page I linked, you guys are doing worse than the americans on household debt. Not that I can point fingers from the uk, cos we are either screwed or up to something fiendishly smart. But if it is the latter, I have no idea what it is.
- einhverfr 14y agoReading that my first thought was "Wow, British banks are screwed." It would be interesting to see how that compares to Greece, Spain, Italy, and other more troubled EU countries. The EU situation suddenly seems a lot scarier to me financially. I should add that Steve Keen's writings on debt are absolutely must-reads for anyone interested in macroeconomic outlooks especially because he discards Neoclassical models in favor of debt-based models.
- ktizo 14y agoI've been following Real-World Economics Review - http://rwer.wordpress.com/ http://rwer.wordpress.com/ - since they were the movement for a Post-Autistic Economics - http://www.paecon.net/PAEmovementindex1.htm http://www.paecon.net/PAEmovementindex1.htm - Steve Keen seems to crop up there quite a bit.
- ktizo 14y agoIs probably research. First test what happens when you have exclusive payment areas for a limited time and see if anyone kicks off really badly and if the fallout from doing so costs more money than what you make. If not, roll out to more events to try and establish a new standard practice, while keeping a very close eye on social indicators and the bottom line.
- dangrossman 14y agoSince Visa's been doing this since 1986, that's an awfully long test. They do quantify the results, though: > According to the U.S. Sponsorship Tracker, a Visa commissioned study following the Vancouver 2010 Olympic Winter Games conducted by Performance Research, an independent research company, Visa cardholders who were aware of Visa’s Olympic Games sponsorship claimed a 16 percent and nine percent increase in Visa card usage in Canada and the US respectively. The same report found Visa’s brand equity was 32 percent and 38 percent higher among consumers who were aware of Visa’s sponsorship in Canada and the US respectively. http://corporate.visa.com/_media/olympic-games-media-kit/visa-and-the-olympic-games.pdf http://corporate.visa.com/_media/olympic-games-media-kit/vis...
- ktizo 14y agoIt's been enforcing these kind of competitor exclusion zones on card payments at major sporting events since 1986? Ah.. Just looked it up. - http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1996/Visa-Will-be-Only-Credit-Card-For-96-Olympics-After-All/id-5f6c4d167844c3b6bd6a142c785bbd56 http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1996/Visa-Will-be-Only-Credit-C... OK. Fair enough. They haven't just miraculously turned into complete bastards on this, they were just complete bastards all along and the press happens to be making a fuss about it at the moment, just cos it is news with the word 'olympics' in it.
- AJ007 14y agoJust because consumers accepted something in the past does not mean they will accept it in the future. For example, in the past when I found a flashy new b2b service I would grumble when I couldn't find a price list and continue my research. Now, when I visit a company's page and there are no listed prices, I immediately close the tab and forget about it. Saying "We only accept Visa" is like saying "We only serve white people." Exclusive, yes. A reminder of ethnic and class privilege, yes. Desirable by any progressively minded individuals? Absolutely not. A note about online payments when it comes to credit cards, I pretty much stopped using my Mastercards with the exception of Amazon because of that damn Securecode implementation. I think payment processors and providers who erect any restrictions or barriers will find them self quickly suffocated out by services who are going the other direction. (I'm one of the guys who believes within the next 5 years you'll just be able to walk out of most stores with a product and seamlessly be billed for it, uber style.)
- cs702 14y agoConsumers learn something crucial from this marketing campaign: that American Express and certain other credit cards are NOT accepted by some merchants, so it's a good idea to get and always carry a Visa card -- by implication, the only card accepted everywhere.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThe problem is that everyone know that other cards are accepted everywhere apart from the olympics, or at least Mastercard is. This is more like BMW deciding to sponsor the construction of a road and only allowing their cars to pass.
- hkolk 14y agoIn a rural town in the UK I tried to get some money of my Mastercard on a Visa-branded machine. Didn't work. A friend tried with a Visa card and that worked like a charm. It sounds more like a common practice in the UK. Denmark had something similar with Visa as well. Apparently it works since I am now very likely to get a Visa-card next to my Mastercard for those just-in-case situations.
- corin_ 14y agoI can't think of a time in the last decade when I've seen a card reader or cash machine that didn't accept Visa and Mastercard (I'm in the UK).
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThat story makes no sense. We don't have "visa branded" cash machines. They're all run by third party merchants and they universally support something called LINK which allows all the major card vendors to hook in. I'm sure your card failed to work but I doubt it had anything to do with a big Visa logo on the machine.
- cschmidt 14y agoWere you traveling to the UK? If so, then your card's fraud department probably just declined the card. They're super picky these days, you really need to call the card company now before you travel internationally.
- coffeegeek 14y ago"The only theory I can come up with is that their real customers are the banks" Unlike Visa in the US, Visa Europe is still owned by its 3000+ member banks. It's only responsibility is to make its shareholders happy.
- danweber 14y agothe thinking behind the "We are proud to only accept Visa" marketing campaign It's like "for your convenience." "For your convenience, all toilets have been closed."