2 ms·
> Imprisonment is indeed a newer development. Ancient Greece and Rome are "newer"? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mamertine_Prison https://en.wikipedia.org/wik
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> Imprisonment is indeed a newer development.
Ancient Greece and Rome are "newer"?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mamertine_Prison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mamertine_Prison was built in the 7th century BC.
- geodel 2y agoI mean those were just centers for vigorous debates on natural philosophy :-)
- milesrout 2y agoThe linked article says: >Imprisonment was not a sentence under Roman statutory law,[2] though detention is mentioned in the Twelve Tables and throughout the Digest.[3] "Detention", however, includes debt bondage in the early Republic;[4] the wearing of chains (vincula publica), mainly for slaves; and during the Imperial era a sentence of hard labor at the mills, mines or quarries.[5] Slaves or lower-status citizens sentenced to hard labor were held in prison camps.[6] >Incarceration (publica custodia) in facilities such as the Tullianum was intended to be a temporary measure prior to trial or execution; abuses of this principle occurred but were officially censured.[7] Located near the law courts, the Tullianum was used as a jail or holding cell for short periods before executions and as a site for executions. So yes, as I said, imprisonment is a newer development. Holding people temporarily is jailing. Imprisonment, in the "sentenced to prison for a period of time or indefinitely" is a modern idea. It was considered barbaric by some cultures historically, but it also was just not viable. There was a small surplus of food, which was for the aristocracy to siphon off the top (ostensibly to fund the defence of the realm), not for feeding common criminals.
- ceejayoz 2y agoThe article goes on to say: > In general, long-term incarceration was more widely practiced in the later Empire, and from the 4th century, under Christian rule... I don't consider that recent, either. (Nor do I really think "prison camp", "sentenced to hard labor", and "debt bondage" are all that meaningfully different from imprisonment.)
- jMyles 2y agoPlease - and I ask this with calmness and a sincere urging: Stop trying to make incarceration seem like a long-running historical phenomenon. It is profit-driven propaganda, the promulgation of which began promptly in 1865. Incarceration, in the Western legal tradition, is very new in relative terms, and its growth has been overwhelmingly the result of the experience of the USA transforming slavery into something marginally more politically acceptable. You probably already know this, given your knowledge of the history, but some plantations, such as Angola, never even bothered closing down; they just transformed into penitentiaries and continued business as usual. The 13th amendment to the constitution, against the better judgment of many objectors, is specifically worded to facilitate this transformation. Incarceration is not a legal tradition. It is a way to shoehorn slavery economics into one.
- ceejayoz 2y agoThe UK’s Bloody Codes and transportation, the French Bastille, etc. all long predate 1865. American post-Civil War incarceration is absolutely squicky in its often clear continuation of the slavery system it replaced, but prisons and incarceration aren’t new.