4 ms·
And I wonder if they end up finding something (or think they do) will you be in more trouble for "resisting search" ?
by grecy 14y ago
And I wonder if they end up finding something (or think they do) will you be in more trouble for "resisting search" ?
- tptacek 14y ago"Resisting search"? I'm not sure that means anything. You have absolutely no right to "resist" a search. If the cops demand to unlawfully search your vehicle, let them. Even if their search is unlawful, you will be charged if you in any way attempt to physically prevent them from conducting the search. Your protections against unlawful searches come later in the legal process, when evidence obtained from those searches is thrown out of court. Meanwhile, you can (if you are an idiot) bellow your refusal to consent to search at the top of your lungs, laced with expletives, and (apart from whatever comes from gratuitously pissing off the cops) you haven't committed any crime I'm aware of.
- grecy 14y agoSorry, that's not exactly what I was talking about. I meant to say if you simply say "I'm sorry officer, I don't consent to this search", then they bring a dog, find a "hit", search, find something and arrest you. I wonder if the fact you denied them permission to search you in the first place can be used to make things look worse later on in court?
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not sure how. Refusing to consent to a search isn't evidence. Officers will tell you that by consenting to a search, they'll look kindly on you when it's time to use their discretion. Maybe if you just consent, they'll suggest, they'll only book you for a misdemeanor. That is, as they say, one of the oldest tricks in the book. Once you're arrested, it's up to the prosecutor to charge you, and their overriding prerogative is finding the optimal balance of "maximal penalty" and "minimal prosecutorial effort".
- grecy 14y agoThanks. > That is, as they say, one of the oldest tricks in the book. I'm naive when it comes to dealing with Police, so my natural tendency is to cooperate now in the hope it causes less trouble later. Thanks for the info, I need to adjust my approach.