3 ms·
Many are commenting on why they don't like jobs, but the article has a very good analysis of the other side of this trope: People fantasize about homesteading o
by Aurornis 2y ago
Many are commenting on why they don't like jobs, but the article has a very good analysis of the other side of this trope: People fantasize about homesteading or farming because they don't know how much work it really is. To many, homesteading is an escapist fantasy:
> so few Americans are familiar with the actual work behind jobs in the agricultural sector or related ones, I would argue that for many Americans the reality of this type of work is almost indistinguishable from fables or myth in their psychological context, due to lack of exposure. Due to that seeming separation from their mental context of what work is, it enhances the feeling of escapism which this work-fantasy provides
These fantasies always seem perplexing to those of us who grew up with exposure to actual farming life. Running a modern farm is hard work. Taking it a step further to the idea of homesteading would bring unthinkable amounts of labor, difficulty, and a realization that the old office job wasn't so bad after all.
Of the few people who actually pursue these fantasies, it usually takes the form of a hobby farm or some backyard gardening with ample injections of cash to keep things moving.
- gosub100 2y agoAdding to this: the enormous amounts of knowledge required. How do you know how far apart (or deep) to plant the seeds? Or when? Or how much fertilizer, or water, or how often to water? Or when? Sure you can use common sense or look it up. But once you get to a certain scale, the stakes are high enough that the risk of ruin is too high. Sure you save money by milking your cow, but how much is one vet visit? Unless it's in your blood, trying to go from techies to farmers is just stupid. Edit to add: one of the principal differences between software and farming is we are one "git checkout" away from having another chance to fix it. In agriculture, you get another chance... next year.
- morleytj 2y agoRunning a farm is a ton of work, exactly. The difference of having the ample injections of cash and not having them is pretty huge, especially when it comes to how common the issues that pop up when trying to run a modern farm are, and how expensive they can be. I think when you're someone who grew up with exposure to the lifestyle of farming, it gets easier to see that the escapism is possible because of how rare it is for people to interact with people whose main employment is farming on a regular basis. It is honestly pretty interesting from a historical perspective to think about what this means as a shift in the populace's opinion towards certain kinds of work, because we're really entering unforeseen territory in US history where no one will even really understand first-hand what a version of the US where the vast majority of humans living there are engaged in agricultural labor on a regular basis lookd like, if that makes sense.