27 ms·
> The question "Who invented this?" is most often pointless, I’m having flashbacks to a corporate environment where several people would rush into any successf
by Aurornis 2y ago
> The question "Who invented this?" is most often pointless,
I’m having flashbacks to a corporate environment where several people would rush into any successful project, contribute something small, and then start telling everyone they created the entire initiative.
Our conflict-averse CTO would then declare that it doesn’t matter because we all created it together.
Then the other party would take that as permission to say they created the thing in meeting, presentations, and politicking. If anyone tried to argue the accurate history of who created it, they’d invoke the CTO’s proclamation that we all created it together.
Thus the collectivism became a way to rewrite history and take credit in contexts where they could get away with it, with a safe fallback to claiming we all created it together whenever someone objected.
I get the same feeling whenever there’s debate about order of historical events and someone tries to tell me it doesn’t matter. Clearly it does matter, because some people think it matters enough to try to rewrite history in their favor.
- akie 2y agoWho created the world's first working programmable, fully automatic digital computer? And why does everyone think it's an American, 4 years later? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z3_(computer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z3_(computer) History is not a collection of objective records.
- necovek 2y agoEven that Wikipedia page has this snippet: In 1937, Claude Shannon introduced the idea of mapping Boolean algebra onto electronic relays in a seminal work on digital circuit design. Zuse, however, did not know of Shannon's work and developed the groundwork independently[11]: 149 for his first computer Z1, which he designed and built from 1935 to 1938.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoI believe that invention was a bit controversial, for some reason...
- oytis 2y agoA lot of modern Germans seem to be very proud of it for some reason. Also Zuse's company existed long after the WWII.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoI saw the replica of this in Berlin in the museum of technology a few months ago. Worth visiting if you are in town.
- hvs 2y agoBecause every computer record has a host of qualifiers on it (like "programmable", "fully automatic").
- spogbiper 2y ago"The Z3 was demonstrated in 1998 to be, in principle, Turing-complete. However, because it lacked conditional branching, the Z3 only meets this definition by speculatively computing all possible outcomes of a calculation." this is the one factor that makes me question whether it should be considered first.. conditional branching is pretty significant to what we consider a computer. better informed people than myself have come up with a variety of takes on this, i read all that i see because i find Zuse fascinating but i still am not sure if its fair to call one system or the other "first". the advent of computing podcast has some interesting well researched episodes, scroll down a little to 145 and 146: https://adventofcomputing.com/ https://adventofcomputing.com/
- cpach 2y agoI guess that’s why the saying is that “history is written by the victors”.