4 ms·
... wll eventually drive the price of music and movie down to $0. Yes, yes, I went to college, I know how free-market capitalism works. In a competitive market
by bediger4000 14y ago
... wll eventually drive the price of music and movie down to $0.
Yes, yes, I went to college, I know how free-market capitalism works. In a competitive marketplace, the price of a good should end up at its marginal cost of production. Technology has changed this cost from $19.99 (or whatever) to some fraction of a cent.
Ordinarily, we applaud this sort of thing. Laptop computers cost $300, and have more computing capability than a multi-million dollar mainframe did 20 years ago.
A decent car runs about $12,000, and gets mileage and performance that would stun consumers in 1950.
Why must we as a society treat movies and music differently? To do so distorts markets, and takes away civil liberties.
- com2kid 14y agoYou are forgetting that artists have to pay for equipment, eat, have a place to live, etc. And then there is the cost of a renting out a studio, a good sound mixer, additional musicians to play parts that your main band may not be capable of, etc. The cost of reproduction may be close to zero, but the cost of production is most certainly not dropping. Technology may allow some genres of music to be one man bands, but that is certainly not true for all music genres. Orchestras cost money.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think we can discuss that problem when it actually becomes anything other than a fantasy. There are solutions to the "artists are literally starving" problem, but there is really no sense considering them while artists are still flying around in private jets.
- com2kid 14y agoSure pop stars are, but there are hundreds of thousands of artists who aren't signed to big labels. I really don't care one way or the other about any artist who plays on the radio. I want to ensure the artists I listen to are able to continue making music, therefore I buy their music.
- jlgreco 14y agoDo you really think there are artists out there that would be paid a decent living wage, were it not for piracy?
- michaelt 14y agoThe marginal cost of the second ticket to see my favorite film (Scarface, Al Pacino) is a few cents. The marginal cost of the first ticket is $25 million. We could switch over to that system - it's not unprecedented, historically many rich people have been patrons of the arts and commissioned new works. You might find the art market shifts so it aims less at the man on the street and more at the millionaire in the boardroom. Whether that would be a good or a bad thing is a matter of opinion. What do you think?
- archgoon 14y agoI think the existence of kickstarter shows that people, if asked to fund a work of art, will be willing to do so.
- bediger4000 14y agoI think you should go back to college, or study free-market economics. Marginal cost of production: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_cost http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_cost
- michaelt 14y agoAccording to the page you linked to, in economics and finance marginal cost is the change in total cost that arises when the quantity produced changes by one unit. When production of Scarface movie tickets increases from zero units to one unit the film has to be made, increasing the total costs from zero to $25,000,000. Hence, the ∆Q is 1 unit and the ∆TC is $25,000,000 giving a marginal cost of ∆TC/∆Q = $25000000/1 = $25,000,000 Could you be more specific about why I need to go to college? Is there some error in my calculation?
- bediger4000 14y agoThere's an implicit assumption of "more than one unit" in a market. One of anything is a curiosity, not amenable to economic analysis. In this particular market, popular music, where the issue under discussion is massive copying, it's downright disingenuous to do the "sunk costs are marginal cost of the first unit" schtick. Marginal cost gets calculated without sunk costs.