6 ms·
How one of the world’s major money laundering networks operates
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/1f2mL https://archive.ph/1f2mL
- lazyant 2y agoor you can just bring a bag of cash to buy a condo in NYC https://theweek.com/articles/736313/how-foreign-investors-launder-money-new-york-real-estate https://theweek.com/articles/736313/how-foreign-investors-la...
- nikanj 2y agoVancouver is also more than happy to help you out https://www.sanctions.io/blog/the-vancouver-model-of-money-laundering https://www.sanctions.io/blog/the-vancouver-model-of-money-l...
- lurk2 2y agoThere have been changes in recent years that complicate this model because you are now required to register the beneficial (meaning the de facto, not de jure) owner of real property in BC. There was also an investigation into the casinos which culminated in the Dirty Money report [0]. Quite a few reforms came about as a result of that, chief among them that a source of funds declaration is required on buy-ins of $10,000 or more and mandatory identity verification is required on transactions of $3,000 or more. > At B.C. casinos, BCLC requires anyone buying-in with cash, a bank draft, or a certified cheque of $10,000 or more in a 24-hour period to complete a source of funds declaration and provide proof of where the money came from. Suspicious transactions in B.C. casinos have declined since this policy was introduced. Additionally, BCLC requires casinos to verify people’s identities for all buy-ins of $3,000 or more in a single transaction. [1] [0]: https://news.gov.bc.ca/files/Gaming_Final_Report.pdf https://news.gov.bc.ca/files/Gaming_Final_Report.pdf [1]: https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/justice/anti-money-laundering/gambling https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/justice/anti-money-launde...
- msie 2y agoSpreading misinformation hurts everyone.
- mentalgear 2y agoAt least Germany recently changed their laws (initiated by the Green Party) that prevents buying real estate with cash. But this has been a money laundering practice for the mob for decades.
- comrade1234 2y agoYou’re forced to take out a bank loan in Germany if you want to buy property?
- 9dev 2y agoNope, but you can’t buy property with literal cash, crypto, or precious metals anymore. In Germany people use SEPA payments as the primary means to transfer money, and that is the intended way to handle big transactions.
- NikolaNovak 2y agoI believe there are numerous ways to transfer money without using physical bills; disallowing cash for large purchases doesn't imply a loan. Personal or certified Cheque, money order , wire, interac / email transfer are some of the options, I'm sure there are others. Note, all other criticisms about privacy still apply, thisbis where cash is king of course. But it's not forcing loans :-)
- Gigachad 2y agoAustralia just implemented laws where you have to show where the money came from when buying property, gold, and some other stuff with cash.
- ajxs 2y agoAre you referring to Australia's AML/CTF Tranche 2 reforms? If so, these actually come into effect on 1 July 2026.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- facorreia 2y agoThe Brazilian media reported that the Bolsonaro family bought at least 51 properties with cash. https://noticias.uol.com.br/politica/ultimas-noticias/2022/09/09/como-rastreamos-que-o-cla-bolsonaro-pagou-com-dinheiro-vivo-51-imoveis.htm https://noticias.uol.com.br/politica/ultimas-noticias/2022/0...
- pabs3 2y agoPaying for things in cash is banned over a certain price (usually $10k) in some parts of the world.
- alexpotato 2y agoIt used to be that you only had to declare the actual owner of a LLC purchasing a property if the value at sale was over, IIRC, $1.5 million. In NYC that's a typical 1-2 bedroom apartment. They (Treasury Dept?) recently lowered that to $300K. Reminds me of the line from an old NPR podcast: "If you are not a US citizen, the US is one of the best countries for money laundering due to our strong privacy and banking laws."
- storf45 2y agoThis is the plot of the movie, ‘The Beekeeper’.
- LargoLasskhyfv 2y agoOnly partially. This is Scambodia. The plot of The Beekeeper is US-based, and the head of that operation is the son of the President (or candidate? can't remember exactly anymore).
- earnesti 2y agoSo... I started scimming through the artcle, and they basically convert the money to cryptocurrency? Don't know if the article really contained anything other interesting details.
- decimalenough 2y agoThe interesting bits are before that happens. You need money mules, you need brokers to find the mules for you, you need escrow companies to stop the brokers from running away with your money, etc.
- paulpauper 2y agoSo much work. makes me wonder why not just earn it legit. It's like cheaters in school who use AI software and other tools. It would be less work to just study. I guess it does work or esle it the scams would not persist.
- LoganDark 2y ago> It's like cheaters in school who use AI software and other tools. It would be less work to just study. It's not about the amount of work. If it were about the amount of work then ADHD would hardly exist.
- luckylion 2y ago> So much work. makes me wonder why not just earn it legit. Because they make orders of magnitude more money than they otherwise would. The regional drug lord wouldn't be the next fortune 500 CEO if only he chose to not break the law.
- oortoo 2y agoNot sure if I fully agree on that. Using AI as a tool can usually reduce the total time it takes to complete an assignment or project by like 50%, not to mention it also reduces the amount of time spent pulling your hair out feeling stuck by like 80-90%. Of course, you lose out on most of the learning experience but it's not like the old days of smuggling in rolled up papers or writing inside a water bottle -- "cheating" (if you can even call it that) has basically never been easier.
- paulpauper 2y agoThe F.B.I., China’s Ministry of Public Security, Interpol and others have tried to combat scammers, who often lurk on social media and dating apps, luring people into bogus financial schemes or other ruses. It's the IRS and FBI that does the overwhelming bulk of the investigative work and also opens the investigations. Interpol hardly does anything by comparison and have much less doggedness (it was the US who found Bin Laden for example). It typically helps the US, not actually initiates the investigation. At best its like a sidekick. The question is, does the US get involved. If not, then laundering will work, because the vast majority of countries have neither the inclination or resources to do much. Otherwise, all bets are off. Because the US is unrivaled at this sort of stuff. The article in typical clickbait fashion overplays its claim in the headline and then walks it back in the content. It's not that effective if accounts are constantly being tracked and frozen and if the scammers' profits are heavily diluted in an attempt to launder the money. if anything ,this is a success by imposing a huge cost on scammers and reducing the profitability of said scam.
- Jgrace 2y agoyou realise that something's not just clickbait because you don't understand it? Huione is a behemoth in the laundering-sphere; it's intrinsically linked to Cambodian scam compounds, as well as handling every single step of the wash process in-house. These guys don't just receive the stolen funds, but they link international clients with mules across literally thousands of Telegram groups before converting said currency into the Hui-one coin and then onto Tether. All of this is done within Hui-one's infrastructure. If you'd bothered to do just one iota of research into any of the topics covered in the article, you may have stumbled across chainanalysis' report on them from last year. Elliptic, also mentioned, have done comprehensive reports on them. Lazarus Group, who recently stole around a billion from Bybit, frequently move funds through these guys, so did Conti, and many of the other big cyber-threat groups. To your point around it being a huge cost to the scammers, that's a given. Effective laundering is expensive because organised crime groups are most vulnerable at this particular stage of the fraud. A massive decentralised network of groups that can match criminals to a steady flow of international bank accounts that can handle fraudulent funds is pricless.
- mentalgear 2y agoSeems like the easiest way to launder or bribe someone is still crypto. Might not be an investor's paradise, but certainly a launderer's.
- lazyeye 2y agoI wonder how much of these kinds of issues that we are told are "complex" and "multi-faceted", "no easy solution" etc could be significantly reduced if there was actual political will to do so. I think a lot.
- daveguy 2y agoAgreed. It seems like billionaires are buying more and more of our means of communication. Makes it easier to control the narrative.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoIts harder today than it was. It used to be you had most of america watching Walter Cronkite or otherwise on three channels and a smattering of radio. You control those few levers you have the country. And indeed the country was remarkably well controlled without even being aware of its tight leash up until we saw counter culture emerge, through production of their own media and materials and grassroots distribution outside this existing national system in the 1960s. Many people are captured today by mass media but there are many more people in this space trying to cultivate their own cash crop of passive content cows. Makes it less efficient to break trough with more players to pay off for a unified narrative.
- daveguy 2y agoAt least mass media isn't a clown show like the Rogans and twitters. You can pretend that journalistic integrity doesn't exist (or didn't exist) with professional journalists. But it's obvious you're pushing a narrative. So have fun with your algorithmically designed opinions.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoWhat narrative am I pushing if it is so obvious? If anything it is mere media literacy I am espousing. Is that so controversial a position these days? Scary times if so.
- TacticalCoder 2y ago[dead]
- xyzzy9563 2y agoBuy crypto, convert it to Monero, transfer it around a bit, convert it to your destination currency. Done.
- Etheryte 2y agoThis is missing the most important step though, which is to actually launder the money. Concealing the source of the money is only half of the ordeal, making the money seem legitimate is the second, usually considerably trickier bit. If you suddenly receive $100k from a crypto exchange with no trace of how you came to own it, your bank is going to ask you some questions.
- xyzzy9563 2y agoIf it's a one-time $100k you can just slowly withdraw small portions of it and probably nobody would notice. It depends how much you're trying to launder.
- your_drunk_dad 2y agoYou really think that alerts in banks are that stupid? It doesn't matter if you are sending 100k at once or below some treshold. It will get alerted and spotted anyway. You just need to make transaction look plausible.
- xyzzy9563 2y agoI have transferred tons of stuff to my bank over the years (all legal), none of it ever got "alerted" or something I had to describe.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoEasy these days with fantasy football being advertised every 30 seconds. There are probably very sophisticated methods already out there running on those frameworks.
- 486sx33 2y agoUnfortunately, outlawing cash transactions really isn’t good for people. I know the cause sounds good here but the method isn’t wonderful.
- mrtesthah 2y agoCash transactions are vital under authoritarian regimes that would otherwise have potentially total surveillance and control over financial transactions, or for people who may be unable to open a bank account for whatever reason.
- weitendorf 2y agoIn most developed countries cash is too inconvenient for regular people to bother with it anymore except when they have to - it is just simpler to pay for things digitally or with a card. But even “free” governments already have total surveillance over digital transactions. So as the remaining legitimate uses (and users, since I think most regular people who would be legitimately harmed by going cashless are very very elderly people who would struggle to adapt) for cash die off pretty much the only remaining reason to use cash is to commit crime - the vast majority of which is tax fraud, which effectively harms every citizen who isn’t committing tax fraud. Basically, eventually cash will basically become the “crime mode” for its respective currency. I don’t see why it makes sense to continue to allow cash at that point. FWIW I do think privacy for transactions is important but I think we should be trying to make digital transactions more private rather than clinging to a mostly obsolete (in 20 years will anyone be unbanked or transacting in places with no internet?) technology.
- southernplaces7 2y ago>Basically, eventually cash will basically become the “crime mode” for its respective currency. I don’t see why it makes sense to continue to allow cash at that point. Well, it depends on what the government in question defines as criminal activity. Just because something's made illegal doesn't mean it's immoral, wrong or in any way bad. Many regimes have in the past made all kinds of transactions illegal specifically for the sake of their own criminal persecution of targeted minority groups. This is why argument about "only criminal activity" are both idiotic and naive.
- bentobean 2y agoWhere I live, there is a chain of "vacuum repair" shops. There are like 4 - 5 of them in an area no bigger than 60 square miles. I've always assumed they were a money laundering front. Are that many people repairing their vacuums?
- Terr_ 2y agoSome of it might be a competition thing, where clustering is a Nash Equilibrium to prevent the other guy from taking unclaimed territory/customers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jILgxeNBK_8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jILgxeNBK_8
- clown_strike 2y agoDoubtful, yet they'd probably rebuild your vacuum if you brought it to them. There are a glut of hyper-specialized businesses around here. Russians run all of the appliance repair shops. Israelis ran all cell phone repair places until COVID (now we have few at all). These all took digital payments. Iranians/Turks around here run a bunch of rug shops that never get any customers yet linger for decades. I don't know a single person that owns a rug. The Chinese run donut shops that are cash only, never see any foot traffic, sell terrible stale donuts, and don't even have seating. Vietnamese run all the nail salons and both change owners and personnel every few years. Disney race-swaps protagonists of old movies that predictably flop instead of creating the next Frozen, and Concord burned $400m on a game that only 25k people wanted ($1m revenue). How is this sustainable? It could be money laundering, but some of these businesses look like they're intended to fail. I'd sooner suspect some other financial engineering going on. H1-B fraud or SBA loans-for-foreigners schemes.
- renewiltord 2y ago170 firewalk studios employees collectively burning $400mm to get H1-Bs. What next? Are they going to buy the nation of Mexico so that they can cross the border illegally? They could all have EB-1c in if they wanted to at those rates haha.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoA little kink in the logic: prop 13 in california. If your folks bought a vacuum shop in 1970 you might be paying no mortgage and that 1970 tax rate today. Making all sorts of otherwise seemingly impossible businesses possible due to severely underpriced overhead relative to other areas.
- hattmall 2y agoThis doesn't really detail any money laundering scheme. This is just how to access scammed money. Simply cashing out a large deposit of tether isn't laundering money. You still need a legitimate way to explain how you earned the money for it to be considered laundered. Although I'm not sure it matters in Cambodia, for 3rd world country scammers the challenge is just getting the money at all. In my area people launder through AirBnb. Put a nice listing up, then have a 3rd party "rent" it with cash purchased AirBnB gift cards. You get a very clean 10-99. AirBnb does minimal validation on guests, and their gift cards are "closed loop" so no AML / KYC regulations at the grocery store. Not much incentive to stop it, AirBnB and state / local governments all get a nice cut.
- fc417fc802 2y agoThe obvious potential issue is that the data on the AirBnB side looks sketchy as hell if anyone ever actually looks at it. Nearly all guests via gift card, nearly all those gift cards purchased locally (presumably) at only a few locations (presumably). But I guess they don't have any incentive to be proactive.
- hattmall 2y agoYeah the other easy one is "recording studio". It's $1500 an hour to rent our laptop and midi keyboard. And also, the music you recorded here is pretty good so we will sign you and advance you back 80% of your studio fee. Now you can show income to finance a Dodge charger.
- SideburnsOfDoom 2y ago> This doesn't really detail any money laundering scheme Yes, there are reasons to avoid providing a detailed manual on the exact workings of a successful large-scale money-laundering scheme. For the same reason why an article wouldn't explain exactly how to e.g. make explosives or cook meth at scale. You can always find out if you try, of course. But NYTimes level journalism does hesitate to explain those details.
- 2y ago
- busyant 2y agoMoney Laundering Story Time: - In the early 1970s, my father (Italian immigrant to the US) was coach / manager of a semi-pro soccer team in Massachusetts. - His team had a game in Worcester, Mass and one of his players introduced my father to a "friend" who was actually part of the New England Mafia. - After some polite conversation, mafia-guy says, "I could pay for your team's uniforms, pay your league dues. I could even give your players a little travel money for games ..." - My father says, "what do we have to do...?" - Mafia guy says, "We'd like you to apply to the State of Massachusetts and declare your team to be a non-profit organization. Once you're a non-profit, Massachusetts will allow you to run a 'las vegas gambling night' fundraiser twice per year. I would run those fundraisers for you." - My father didn't exactly understand the scam, but he politely declined and that was that. In retrospect, it was pretty obvious that the guy wanted to launder money through the soccer team and the Las Vegas Night fundraiser was the 'vehicle' to cleanse the dirty money.