4 ms·
> I don't see why not. It doesn't even seem like that onerous of a task It’s a hugely onerous task because it requires mapping every listing to a known product
by Aurornis 2y ago
> I don't see why not. It doesn't even seem like that onerous of a task
It’s a hugely onerous task because it requires mapping every listing to a known product.
If someone sells a “green couch” then how do you track recalls for that?
You either force everyone selling anything to look it up in a big database you maintain and disallow generic sales, or everyone is just going to list things generically anyway to avoid the hassle.
It’s an idea that sounds easy when you assume everyone’s making perfectly formed listing, but sounds like a waste of time when you look at real listings.
EDIT: Replaced high chair example with a couch because people were pointing out that a high chair listing would be deleted. Though that proves my point, that any item covered by regulations wouldn’t be allowed on the platform, so if you extend regulations to cover every product ever made then you can forget about being able to buy things second hand. I’m guessing Amazon would actually love that, but you wouldn’t.
- ty6853 2y agoIirc Facebook has dealt with this for lots of children's stuff by banning it's sale. Certain items (forgot which, maybe car seats etc) you have to look up creative misnamings to find them, although maybe Ai has crushed that by now. What will actually happen is this stuff just becomes less accessible to poor people and now their child had no safety equipment at all instead of a 1/100 chance of a recalled item that probably still would be better than nothing.
- danorama 2y agoBut without the CPSC that safety equipment might not be safe at all. And elimination what Amazon is arguing for.
- Aurornis 2y agoExactly. If you make the regulations cover a wider range of products, the only response is to ban those products from sale. If the regulations cover everything, well then either the marketplaces all shut down or they cost $10 per listing and require you to agree to a lot of legal consequences if you provide wrong info in your listing. Ideas like this only sound good to people who imagine no consequences will ever reach them, just billion dollar corporations.
- danorama 2y agoBy that argument the regulations shouldn’t cover anything? It would make a lot more products available to more people, after all. And maybe cheaper?
- ty6853 2y agoThe regulation has to be cheaper than the value add of the service. Nobody wants to get sued for a gazillion because one time in 100 million a child flies out the recalled car seat and gets chopped up by a telephone pole, which of course will be all the fault of Facebook with deep pockets and not the drunk or exhausted parent that is driving. They're just going to say no thanks we will ban this item.
- viraptor 2y agoCar seats and breast pumps - they're pretty much immediately deleted.
- Aurornis 2y agoExactly - Extend that mentality to everything and then you won’t be able to list any of those products either.
- viraptor 2y agoOr a random person gets a post-crash or faulty child seat on an offer, even though they would buy a new one instead if they were aware. The issue goes both ways and we don't seem to have enough information to post anything better than a random 1% guess.
- ty6853 2y agoThe main value add of buying a brand new seat has always been that unless someone repackaged and returned one (which does happen), there is 0% chance it is post crash. That is the whole point of used car seats, if you are too broke to buy a new one it is almost always better than nothing and the proposition is you assume some risk but less risk than before.
- consteval 2y agoI'm not sure this is true. I buy used stuff all the time, even though I can afford new stuff. All my clothes are second-hand. The reason I do that is because I can ascertain the quality of the clothing and determine that, despite them being cheaper and used, they are just as good if not better. I'm sure there's a lot of parents who assume, incorrectly, that a used and relatively clean car seat is just as good as a new one. So, they save a few bucks because why not?
- ty6853 2y agoI think the number of people oblivious to the fact that stuff like helmets and car seats have the hazard of being compromised from a crash is low enough to not distort the market much. That's part of why these items have such a discount used. Meanwhile you can sell stuff like durable name brand tools commonly for near new price. Unfortunately when a new child arrives finances tend to be at a minimum and this deep discount works out as a almost always better than nothing and for super cheap.
- consteval 2y agoClose to all used car seats have never been in a crash. I think you're underestimating how ignorant to this the average person is.
- eloisius 2y agoIn other words, it would make the business model of running a marketplace that sells dangerous junk from alibaba less profitable. Say more.
- ty6853 2y agoHard to say. Raising risk and lowering supply might make it more profitable to do fly by night grey market operations that disappear before enforcement.
- _dark_matter_ 2y agoEntity matching is way easier in the age of LLMs. Not like Amazon is lacking the compute or abilities. So yes, do that, find out who is selling what.
- Aurornis 2y agoI used Craigslist and FB marketplace and equivalents for a while for a lot of things. The average listing is garbage. Devoid of useful information. You have to know exactly what you’re looking for and search broadly because people don’t make an effort to describe things. LLMs absolutely will not solve this. If the only details are “table saw” and a dimly lit picture of a dust-covered table saw that looks like any number of generic table saws, AI isn’t helping you.
- cortesoft 2y agoOk, so how do you think it should be done? If a product is sold and it turns out it is dangerous, there has to be some way to reach the people who have bought it. Amazon is the company that has that data and can reach the consumer.
- Aurornis 2y agoThis comment thread was about eBay and FB marketplace. Platforms where the product information isn’t even accurately known.
- Zigurd 2y agoEbayy has a program for that. https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/selling-tools/ebay-authenticity-guarantee?id=4644 https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/selling-tools/ebay-authent... That goes straight at the "product information isn’t even accurately known" problem.
- mlhpdx 2y agoIt’s an interesting question. The bar would be the least they could possibly do, obviously (as it is now), so is there a case for raising that bar at all?
- xvokcarts 2y agoWhat's wrong with how normal stores do it? They publish recalls publicly, people check the site, media promotes it, whoever bought it can replace it.
- hexaga 2y agoWell, no. In an ideal world yes. But that's not our world. There doesn't have to be some way to reach everyone that has ever purchased a product. For the vast majority of the history of things being sold that has not been the case. It wasn't even in the realm of possibility. It would be nice. It would save lives and avoid tragedy. It is not required, and failure is an option. We've been failing for a long time already. If we have to do it, it's a simple matter of finding who has the capability to do so and force them to, as you say. But we don't. Forcing someone to do only because they can is a tricky proposition.
- mindslight 2y agoYou do realize there is a difference between cooperating with the CPSC on data that one has, and implementing a centralized top-down tracking regime and forcing individuals to conform to it, right? You also do realize that there is a difference between a business selling many copies of the same item repeatedly, and individuals selling things one off, right? If you don't, then maybe you need to learn about these things in the context of existing regulations before spouting off nonsense comments bashing strawmen. Another big one that should make this whole topic moot: A corpo is a government created liability shield. The tradeoff of getting that liability shield is extra regulation to prevent easily-knowable liabilities. And remember, the sine qua non of a corpo is itself compelled speech.