You are right, https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2382/ https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2382/ and https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht

You are right, https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2382/ https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2382/ and https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2612/ https://www.kultboy.com/testbericht-uebersicht/2612/ suggests that the games were around equally well received (in the german gaming press at least, which is a good mark for RPGs). I believed the article there, but it's mistaken as far as I can tell.