3 ms·
> White, from Canada, and even female: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/canadian-det https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/canadian-det
by account42 2y ago
> White, from Canada, and even female: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/canadian-det https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/canadian-det...
... who tried to enter from Mexico after being denied entry from Canada instead of resolving the issue with the embassy as she was told. Plus some more sketchy shit.
TFA is light on details about the circumstances of the three Germans' detention but considering that the German ministry is basically telling people to not violate their visas or lie on their application it doesn't sound like they just had bad luck without doing anything wrong.
- Tarsul 2y agogood points regarding the Canadian. For the Germans: I don't believe that the statements from the ministry are indicative of the three individual cases. Regarding one case, I read in an interview with him that he was detained because his English was poor: He said he "lived" in the USA when he actually meant to say he was just visiting there. That was enough to incarcerate him. Sure, he probably came across as a bit sketchy anyway because his fiancée is American and they have a long-distance relationship, but those are not valid reasons to treat him like that.
- netsharc 2y ago> ... who tried to enter from Mexico after being denied entry from Canada instead of resolving the issue with the embassy as she was told. Plus some more sketchy shit. Let's establish a timeline... - She applied for a visa, and was denied. - She applied again, went to the Mexican border because that's close to her immigration's lawyer office, and was allowed entry. - At some point, she tried to enter the country, and the border guard thinks the above was shady (and you're accepting this guard's judgement. A lawyer would ask "What law did she break?"). - A week or 2 ago, she applied again, she went to the Mexican border for the same reason as above. Why is that sketchy? Immigration checkpoints should work the same anywhere, they're all connected anyway. - At this point she's told she should've gone to a consulate to fix the problem. She's denied entry at the border and she looks for flights home. - A few moments later she's arrested for who knows what and detained for an inderteminate amount of time. - 3 days later, not knowing how long she'll be detained, someone tells her "be prepared for months.". I get that asking for accountability from a unaccountable bureaucrats working in a corrupt police state is a moot point, but what law did she break that justified her detainment? Not knowing she should've gone to a consulate? Thinking there's some exploit in the system that different borders have different rules instead of them being all connected, and should treat everyone equally? Oh, some "shady shit" is enough excuse for you? OK, maybe what she wrote isn't the whole thing. Maybe the corrupt police state will issue a statement to fill in the gaps. Would I believe that corrupt police state?
- vkou 2y agoThe way the TN visa works is you are supposed to go to the border with your papers, and get adjudicated there. Unless you aren't allowed to re-apply after one denial (which I don't believe to be the case), it doesn't matter which border control point she went to for her return visit. And unless the overton window has shifted into actual full fascism last week, being turned away at a border checkpoint is not grounds for a multi-week/month imprisonment. But I suppose you can excuse any barbarity with 'well the victim was probably sketchy'.