5 ms·

PWM. This is widely used method for dimming.

• hunter2_ 2y ago
  How could the same modulation achieve "dimming" and "fully bright" simultaneously?
  • jfim 2y ago
    The apparent brightness is caused by the ratio of on/off and is called the duty cycle. 50% brightness would mean that half the time the light is on, and half the time the light is off. If the cycling of the light on and off is done at say 10kHz it's perceived as a dim light.
  • gizmo686 2y ago
    For traditional lightbulbs, a PWM signal actually makes the light noticeably dimmer, and has a very simmilar effect to simply reducing the current. This is because the mechanism for them is heating up the filement, which happens on a much slower time scale then the PWM duty cycle. In practice, traditional dimmers are not quite PWM as they do not generate a square wave. Instead they generate a sin wave with portions of each cycle clamped to 0. LEDs already need driver circutry to condition the relativly high AC voltage into a stable lower voltage DC. Dimmable LEDs create a stable DC power supply from the chopped up AC power, then use the width of the active portions of the AC as a signal to drive their own dimmer logic.
    • fc417fc802 2y ago
      That's a good PWM explanation but I think GP was asking a different question. Walter claimed that if the PWM was high enough frequency you would perceive it as full brightness while using less power. It obviously wouldn't work that way when lighting a room, but what about for an LED indicator light that you look at directly? I don't know enough to form an opinion.
      • MadnessASAP 2y ago
        Without any more information on frequencies and measurements it's impossible to know. My guess is either A) They did not perceive the dimming, and/or B) The frequency was high enough that the inductive and capacitive effects of the circuitry became relevant and was filtering the PWM signal to DC signal that still drew the same amount of power as it did when fed the full voltage DC signal
  • mrheosuper 2y ago
    you dont. But your eyes perceive brightness non-linear, which means to your eye, 80% of brightness is very close to 100%
    • deleted 2y ago
      [deleted]
  • codebje 2y ago
    The measurable brightness of the LED is a straightforward sum of the times it's on and the times it's off. Shift the ratio so it's off more than it's on and it gets dimmer. The "fully bright" part is a consequence of human vision. Your brain is making sense of limited, noisy information coming from your eyes. A flickering light appears brighter than the light in steady state, lots of still images shown in rapid succession look like they're moving, as far as you can tell you can perceive the full range of colour out of the corner of your eyes, and the dress could be either colour.
    • CorrectHorseBat 2y ago
      Also (and I think more important, but I might be wrong), we don't perceive light intensity linear but logarithmic. A 50% duty cycle does appear brighter than half as bright. A 90% duty cycle might be only barely perceptible.
• notfed 2y ago
  It's also widely known to cause headaches. I swapped out all my PWM bulbs and couldn't be happier. More info here: https://flickeralliance.org/ https://flickeralliance.org/
  • WalterBright 2y ago
    I have a video projector, and if I flick my eyes across the screen I can perceive the separate R G B frames. But just watching it, it's fine.
    • KennyBlanken 2y ago
      That's DLP and it's because DLP uses a color wheel at 3x the frame rate.
      • WalterBright 2y ago
        I know. I was just pointing out that flicker doesn't affect me, for which I'm glad. I was a bit concerned before I bought it, due to the complaints about the flicker.
      • toast0 2y ago
        Not only DLP. Some laser projectors use a color wheel to get the same effect; other laser projectors use multiple lasers, but pulse the colors individually and you get a similar effect; probably there are some laser projectors that do all colors simultaneously too, just as there are some DLP projectors with 3 DLP surfaces and prisms/etc to split and combine the light. My laser projector does the pulsing, I find it slightly less distracting than I remember color wheels being, but it's very similar; thankfully the family has gotten used to it; I only notice it on content that encourages a lot of fast eye movement.
        • CarVac 2y ago
          Scanning displays like a laser projector or a CRT will flash any individual spot but the illumination is almost continuous, so people have less issues with them.
• metaphor 2y ago
  Perhaps less widely known is that if you market a commercial product that actually uses PWM to modulate LED intensity, you're liable to be litigated against by Philips for patent infringement? Wild...yeah, I know. Heard that from a buddy in Austin over a decade ago. Vaguely recall that he had to redesign using some sort of current driver instead to avoid the legal encumbrance.
  • oasisaimlessly 2y ago
    Probably no longer true; patents only last 20 years.
    • metaphor 2y ago
      To be fair, it's probably naive to blindly assume that a company like Philips, with a long history of litigious behavior, isn't playing patent continuation games.