2 ms·
I'm not all the way through the paper, but two questions I have from the jump: The core finding of the paper is that income growth predicts housing price growt
by tptacek 2y ago
I'm not all the way through the paper, but two questions I have from the jump:
The core finding of the paper is that income growth predicts housing price growth reliable regardless of how elastic each local housing market is (say, Austin vs. SFBA). It also uses the "work-from-home" shock during the pandemic as an example of the same kind of measurement.
I don't understand the mechanism the authors are suggesting. The WFH shock occurred over a span of 1-2 dozen months. Housing starts are measured over years and years. Regardless of relative differences in elasticity between markets, all housing markets have bounded elasticity as a result of how long it takes to site and construct houses. In a desirable landlocked community, it can take forever just to find current residents willing to sell and thus open up land for denser development (not something this report appears to study).
I'm also confused at how they're looking at permitting. It appears like they're using it as a metric of housing growth between regions. But permitting rates also define much of the supply constraint within a region. Highly elastic housing markets issue lots of permits. If everyone's issuing comparable numbers of permits, aren't the just observing that (for whatever reason) different regions are just converging on similar constraints and elasticity?