2 ms·
> But there needs to be some mechanism for protecting the privacy and security of users That sounds like an implementation issue that can be solved by Apple se
by bigyabai 2y ago
> But there needs to be some mechanism for protecting the privacy and security of users
That sounds like an implementation issue that can be solved by Apple securing their runtime and APIs.
- threeseed 2y agoThis has nothing to do with the security of APIs. Meta has been requesting things like access to all Messages, Photos, Call Logs etc under the guise of interoperability but which would be an unprecedented gift of private data.
- bigyabai 2y agoMeta already profiles and molests the data of iOS users in Safari. Apple can try to play superhero net-nanny for their userbase, but the choice to give a company your data is a deliberate choice. After all, you can't use either MacOS or iOS without agreeing to Apple's own EULA. It's facetious to pretend that Facebook users aren't aware of what they're getting into post Cambridge Analytica. Apple has no right to moderate what iPhone users run on their hardware any more than they can on Mac. That includes borderline malware like Avast Antivirus and the Facebook app.
- threeseed 2y agoPlease enlighten me how Meta has access to my call logs, messages etc. They don't. These are entirely new datasets.
- bigyabai 2y agoThey buy it from your telecom provider for pennies on the dollar, then connect your phone number to the shadow profile associated with your identity scraped from your friend's posts, photos and uploaded contact info. Very common in regulatory derelict-states like the US. The solution is consumer protections, not begging for a stronger corporate nanny.
- threeseed 2y agoa) We are talking about EU not US. b) No telecom provider has access to my photos, messages etc.
- ziddoap 2y agoSecurity and privacy are two different concepts. Securing an API has no impact on whether the data being provided via that API is private or not.
- bigyabai 2y agoThat's how APIs should be. Apple doesn't treat HTML as an endpoint that needs discriminatory features to prevent users from sending private information. That's how all of their software should work, as it already does on Mac.
- ziddoap 2y agoYou said: >That sounds like an implementation issue that can be solved by Apple securing their runtime and APIs. In response to someone saying privacy of users needs to be protected. Privacy isn't solved by implementing a secure API.
- bigyabai 2y agoPrivacy is not solved by trusting one corporation's service over another, either. Apple cannot exercise private entitlements to deny competitors fair access to their features. Therefore, the current entitlements they use need to be secured for them to be ready for third-party users. I am not saying this is a panacea. I am acknowledging that Apple has to reconsider what their security model looks like in the face of new demands.
- ziddoap 2y ago>Privacy is not solved by trusting one corporation's service over another, either. I didn't say it was. >Apple cannot exercise private entitlements to deny competitors fair access to their features. I didn't say they could. I just don't like the conflation of privacy and security. They are distinct.
- bigyabai 2y ago