5 ms·
I am confused; did the hacker guess the security questions or obviate them? If the former it's not Apple's fault. If the latter; that's inexcusable.
by shawndumas 14y ago
I am confused; did the hacker guess the security questions or obviate them?
If the former it's not Apple's fault. If the latter; that's inexcusable.
- sp332 14y agoIf the Apple-chosen security questions are reasonably guessable, that's still Apple's fault.
- shawndumas 14y agoHere is the list; You tell me. Keep in mind though; you can answer anything you want. Use a 1password generated string for each and store the answers redundantly. That's what I did. --------------------------------- What was the first car you owned? Who was your first teacher? What was the first album you owned? Where was your first job? In which city were you first kissed? --- Which of the cars you’ve owned has been your favorite? Who was your favourite teacher? What was the first concert you attended? Where was your favourite job? Who was your best childhood friend? --- Which of the cars you’ve owned has been your least favorite? Who was your least favourite teacher? Where was your least favourite job? In which city did your mother and father meet? Where were you on January 1, 2000?
- RexRollman 14y agoThat's why I always give a ten character random string as answers to those questions.
- cschneid 14y agoI use the 1password pronounceable strings. Still plenty random, but you can say it over the phone to a customer service person if you ever do need.
- shawndumas 14y agoGreat idea: Updating my questions now...
- tjoff 14y agoI can barely answer half of those for myself and out of those that I can answer I'm either not sure I'd answer the same thing a few years later or it will probably be something a lot of people know. Those questions are terrible. Answering with a random string is the only sensible solution. But it is just as mindbogglingly bad. Because then you could just as well write down the password - and bam, you'd never lose it (well, if you did lose it you would have lost the answers to these questions as well so either way you are screwed).
- bobbles 14y agoJust keep in mind that the ACTUAL answer to the security questions doesnt matter, just whatever you type into the box the first time. What was your first car? "spaceship" is perfectly acceptable response, and its not discoverable by public means. it does however mean you need to know what you would have typed in for each of the questions.
- PeterisP 14y agoFor every single of these questions, my wife, mother and sister would know the answer as well. Ergo, they are not acceptable as a "secret" that can be used to grant access to my account; Apple should provide reasonable privacy also from my in-laws. The whole concept of "security questions" is stupid and useless, and shouldn't be used ever and anywhere.
- riobard 14y agoActually, it appears to me that almost 100% of “security questions” used during support phone calls are completely insecure. Usually they'll ask a few (2~3 is normal) questions like your full name, date of birth, address with zipcode, email address, etc. Notice the problem of these? All of them, I mean, ALL, are PUBLIC INFORMATION THAT ANYONE KNOWS SOMETHING ABOUT YOU WILL HAVE. This is almost as silly as credit cards, where you are supposed to give the card number, card holder's name (not required most of the time), expire date, and the 3-digit PIN. Anyone who touches your card will have that information, once and forever. Yes, ANYONE, that includes your grocery store cashiers, your favorite bar tenders, your mobile phone billing representatives, etc. The list could go on very, very long. And I'm totally amazed that both systems persist as a fallback plan in this digital world with countless attacking vectors.
- shawndumas 14y agoAs I've said elsewhere: "Keep in mind though; you can answer anything you want. Use a 1password generated string for each and store the answers redundantly. That's what I did."
- riobard 14y agoBased on my experience, that's not how it works at all in practice. They will ask these info about your real identity as recorded in their CRM systems. I doubt you can list your name as BLAH BLAH BLAH there and still receive your package delivered correctly.
- r00fus 14y agoIf a human is in the loop and you need to call in to verify - this could get quite difficult unless you use the "pronounceable" option in password generation.
- pja 14y agoThe thing to remember here is that where the liability lies matters. The banks effectively take on all the liability for financial losses due to credit card fraud & they're free to setup their systems to constrain losses to a level that they're happy with. Yes, arguably not all the losses fall on the banks, particularly the hassle and time of recovering from a particular instance of fraud but the majority of them probably do and that's what matters because the interests of those who bear the losses and those who run the system are aligned. The trouble with cloud systems is that all the losses fall on the end user who has no influence over the security systems put in place to protect their data. (Except with Google where you can at least choose to use 2-factor authentication.)
- makomk 14y agoAccording to the guy's comments on Twitter, the hacker didn't have to answer the security questions.