4 ms·
> This is a direct-join union, meaning that workers can sign up on their own. This allows folks to bypass traditional unionization processes like elections and
by Aurornis 2y ago
> This is a direct-join union, meaning that workers can sign up on their own. This allows folks to bypass traditional unionization processes like elections and employer consent.
Good reminder that the word "union" is overloaded and doesn't always mean what you might assume.
People who join a union like this don't have union representation or union contracts with companies. They rely on individual members to take action in various forms within there own companies. In theory they could call for a strike and ask everyone who is a member to strike from their respective companies, but in practice it's more about raising awareness and making noise in hopes of driving change.
So while technically it's a union, it's not comparable to what most people think of as a union in the United States.
- deadbabe 2y ago[flagged]
- diggan 2y agoNot quite, this is what themselves say about the structure: > A direct-join union means that UVW-CWA does not represent a single workplace, but rather, anyone in the video game industry. This differs from other union models, which organize workers in a single company or even a specific department or office. This means UVW-CWA seeks to make change directly through worker power and public leverage against the companies of our industry without the limitations of traditional labor law and collective bargaining rights. > Historically, workers in the U.S. and Canada organized their unions this way until their efforts resulted in the codified labor law we know today in the United States. Other countries also utilize direct-join unionism! [...] By being direct-join, UVW-CWA is able to grow more easily, have a wider base of membership, and is not limited to the constraints of the certification process. https://uvw-cwa.org/faq https://uvw-cwa.org/faq So while it's true it doesn't have the typical benefits of another form of union, it doesn't seem useless at all. Biggest benefit is that exploited people get used to organizing together for a common cause, this will have a far wider impact than just in the video game industry.
- deadbabe 2y agoBecause nothing terrifies corporate executives more than a loosely organized group of scattered workers with no legal standing, no collective bargaining rights, and no strike protections. Truly, the next great labor revolution will be built on the unshakable foundation of good vibes and a mailing list. In practice, I don’t think things will be that easy.
- dwaltrip 2y agoYou are offering undiscerning nihilism. It’s both false and unhelpful. Maybe you just needed to vent, I get that. But I must say, HN comments aren’t the always the best place for venting.
- zvorygin 2y agoThey offered a number of good points, it doesn’t seem like undiscerning nihilism to me.
- deadbabe 2y agoUnhelpful I can see, but how is it in any way false what I said?
- dwaltrip 2y agoYou are saying that what they are doing is completely useless. Plenty of other comments have explained how it isn’t.
- int_19h 2y agoThe very first unions were exactly like that, and they terrified corporate executives enough to attempt to violently suppress them. And then, despite said suppression, they still managed to win legal standing, collective bargaining rights, strike protections etc.
- crooked-v 2y agoCollective lobbying and PR has plenty of power, which is why companies do it so much.
- throw9304040 2y agoI would be careful with assuming that. In some countries/industries you have to be a member of an union by the law. Just by working in industry, union is forced upon you by law, and you have to pay their fees. The only way out, is to form your own union, with all paperwork. It really sucks for self employed folks.
- billy99k 2y ago[flagged]
- ty6853 2y agoThere's a great video of a longshoreman union rep bragging about crushing America so 'his guys' could get by, all the while with totaly lost irony he said this on TV while wearing a gold chain, Rolex, and living in an absolutely lavish mansion. https://youtu.be/hr-isyMV1y8?si=6cHZ9Ey8hzJtSoFQ https://youtu.be/hr-isyMV1y8?si=6cHZ9Ey8hzJtSoFQ
- therouwboat 2y agoSo what? If workers don't get the money, it goes to company owners. I wonder what kinda mansions they have.
- jibe 2y agoBy company owners, did you mean my 401k? Or is it more that it causes higher prices, and everyday consumers pay for it?
- ty6853 2y agoGiven that particular strike was against in part automation it was that they wanted their port to become less competitive and eventually be destroyed by ports employing automation and not even jobs left for their kids to fix or engineer the machines.
- 2y ago
- lalaithion 2y agoHow do you think unions start? Yes, an entire workplace can just up and decide some day to unionize but more often unions start as non-bargaining unions and then at some point get enough support to bargain with the companies.
- 3acctforcom 2y agouhhh you should really look into how that works. The union playbook is to organize in secret because retaliation is in the HR playbook. All sorts of fun and completely (not)illegal retaliation like firing organizers.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> more often unions start as non-bargaining unions Source? I'd guess most unions start as collective-bargaining unions because if they can't colletively bargain I'm struggling to see their point over, like, a conference or subreddit.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoMost people in the united states think of unions as some kind of entrenched bureaucratic entity that's not capable of effecting change. Typically we say "the union" as if there can only be one, and once it's corrupt, there's no recourse. Often our laws reflect this, striking as part of a "wildcat" union can be illegal. It leads to this feeling that you have to know the right people to unionize. It's a problematic perspective. "The" union might be an impotent lost cause, but "A" union can appear suddenly, strike hard, and dissipate once the need for it has gone. This seems more like the latter.
- atoav 2y agoAs you correctly point out on a fundamental level unions are just workers of a particular skill organizing to address issues these workers want to see adressed, and by them bekng many they strengthen their bargaining position. Unions can devolve into dysfunctional bureaucratic entities, but so can literally everything else where people come together for a cause — so that is no argument against unions. Every employee is replaceable, banding together with others that might replace you instead of letting them play you like a fool is a power move.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoI feel like focusing on "workers of a particular skill" is a bit too narrow. A strike could be like... > These people have disabled a critical part of your supply chain and they will restore it if you improve the working conditions for these other people. ...where both groups of people are part of the same union despite having very different jobs. If you can achieve solidarity across sectors, you can strike much more effectively than by merely refusing to work.