8 ms·
Tunneling Below Second Avenue (for New Subway)
- vinayan3 14y agoBuild it Bigger on the science / discovery channel had an episode about how they build the subways in NY. It was a cool episode. http://science.discovery.com/videos/build-it-bigger-season5-nyc-subway/ http://science.discovery.com/videos/build-it-bigger-season5-...
- theorique 14y agoThe East Side needs another subway badly - this will be a great benefit to a great city. Thanks for this link! New York Magazine has an article that fills in some more of the historical and political context: http://nymag.com/print/?/nymetro/news/features/n_10109/ http://nymag.com/print/?/nymetro/news/features/n_10109/ Slightly related: As a transport geek, I'm a fan of subways everywhere. I recommend London's excellent Transport Museum in Covent Garden for a great historical perspective on how tunnels and public transportation gets built. http://www.ltmuseum.co.uk/ http://www.ltmuseum.co.uk/
- melling 14y agoNJ<->NYC needs another "subway" tunnel pretty badly too. Ferrying people in and out with buses has reached its limit.
- _delirium 14y agoThere's a project currently in planning stages that is supposed to upgrade the 11-mile section of century-old infrastructure between Newark and NYC, improving both Amtrak and NJ Transit service. It'd add a new Hudson River tunnel, a faster modern routing through the Meadowlands, and expand Penn Station into the old James Farley Post Office. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gateway_Project http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gateway_Project
- melling 14y agoNone of that will move people off of buses to a subway or train. The proposal of extending the 7 line to NJ, for example, would certainly help.
- _delirium 14y agoIf I understand correctly, the NJ Transit trans-Hudson services have been at maximum capacity for years, so they could carry more riders if they were able to add more trains at peak times, but without a new tunnel (and probably more platforms) it's just not possible to run more trains.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe gateway tunnel has been postponed indefinitely. But no worries, apparently the only reason the Gateway Tunnel was necessary was because the MTA previously refused to run things efficiently. http://transportationnation.org/2012/06/14/ny-mta-chief-says-railroads-need-to-work-together-to-overcome-maxed-out-hudson-river-crossings/ http://transportationnation.org/2012/06/14/ny-mta-chief-says... Also interesting: "The Regional Plan Association, which held the conference at which Lhota spoke, and other advocacy groups have expressed support for through-running—at least until Gateway Tunnel gets built." I.e., they want to be more efficient, but only as a stopgap measure until the tunnel is built. (Also check out Market Urbanism's blog post on the topic: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:ycccmptVdFgJ:marketurbanism.com/2012/06/18/new-york-transit-officials-grudgingly-consider-using-existing-track-more-efficiency/+&cd=5&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:ycccmpt... )
- _delirium 14y agoInteresting. I suppose there are not high odds that these multiple systems will ever get integrated into one regional agency, the way the various NYC subways were eventually merged into the MTA and interconnected?
- iwejfweoifjweif 14y agoAs some comments say on that page, there are numerous technical details as to why it isn't nearly as simple as proposed. AFAIK you can't easily run LIRR trains to NJ because only a few engines support catenary operation, everything else requires a third rail to be built. So while this might get us a few percent increase in the number of trains for now, at the cost of a few hundred million to build out third rails in NJ (or catenaries in LIRR areas where NJ transit trains might be routed), it doesn't change the fundamental infrastructure issue given the growth of mass transit in the NYC metro area.
- ChrisLTD 14y agoThanks to Gov. Chris Christie it's not gonna happen anytime soon: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/08/nyregion/08tunnel.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/08/nyregion/08tunnel.html
- protomyth 14y agoIf you don't have the money, then you cannot go forward with this type of thing. Maybe after some years of getting back to balance on their budget, NJ can start big things again.
- melling 14y agoIn the meantime, hundreds of thousands of people pay every day for the inefficient mass transportation system. There are good ways to spend money in bad times. See: Great Depression.
- protomyth 14y agoAnd there are millions of children in NJ that need the government to not burden them with debt. NJ spends more than it takes in and needs to fix that first. Even if a family has another kid on the way, they still need to make sure they have budgeted properly before building an expansion on the house.
- natrius 14y agoA government with a rising tax base can spend more than its revenue in perpetuity. That doesn't mean it's always a good idea, but thinking about government spending the way a household manages its spending leads to incorrect conclusions. There are millions of children in New Jersey that need their parents to be employed. Counter-cyclical spending helps to accomplish that, and if done wisely, it also acts as an investment from which those children will reap the benefits. Discourse about government spending these days is sadly devoid of numbers that indicate the right choice one way or the other. We don't run our businesses this way.
- philjohn 14y agoI'll second the London Transport Museum suggestion - I was there with my children yesterday and had a great time. A ticket also lasts for one year, so you can revisit as many times as you wish, which makes it a great value day out.
- phon 14y agoI live and work in Manhattan. The blasting on the second avenue subway project is so regular that I recently caught myself unconsciously timing my work day by the shaking of the building.
- rocky1138 14y agoTwo things I wanted to know but couldn't find in the article (I thought they would be important): 1. How many metres down are they digging? 2. How many metres long will the tunnel be when it's complete?
- m_for_monkey 14y agoDepth: 15-30 m Length: 13.7 km https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Avenue_Subway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Avenue_Subway
- robspychala 14y agoEast Side Access is another amazing project in NYC. going to bring LIRR to Grand Central in 2019 ish. i've been somewhat documenting its progress at http://eastsideaccess.tumblr.com http://eastsideaccess.tumblr.com
- melling 14y agoThis was suppose to be done in 2014. For people who say that developers should be able to predict software development timelines like construction projects, just look at how long it takes to get construction projects done in the NYC area.
- Anechoic 14y agoThe TBM's finished digging tunnels for all three NY projects in July, now beings the cleanout and cut & cover work so they can start laying tracks and prepping the stations: http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20120725/long-island-city/mta-completes-digging-13-miles-of-new-tunnels-for-megaprojects http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20120725/long-island-city/mt... I worked briefly on the environmental side of this project at my last job in 2002 and something I don't hear that often is that there are completed cut-and-cover tunnel segments for the 2nd Avenue subway right now - the project initial began in the 1970's and some work was completed before the project ran out of money and it was shut down. I've been in the completed tunnel sections under 2nd Ave in the around 95th Street and under the Bowery. I think there is another section further north in Harlem but I haven't been in that one Tunnel section under 95th street: http://twitpic.com/afuoxv http://twitpic.com/afuoxv Tunnel section under the Bowery: http://twitpic.com/afupg0 http://twitpic.com/afupg0 The initial plan was to tie the new tunnels with the existing section, but last I heard (and this was admittedly 8 or 8 years ago) they abandoned the plan to tie into the Bowery section (they want to go under it) since the route has changed somewhat to tie in with other lines. The scale of the project still amazes me, I'm glad to see that it's proceeding.
- johnohara 14y agoAren't there major geologic fault lines near this project? http://nymag.com/news/articles/08/06/GeographyofDisaster/map.html http://nymag.com/news/articles/08/06/GeographyofDisaster/map...
- ablefire 14y agoMore mass transit is great and this will be a big upgrade for the east side. I would love to see some kind of modern link from NYC to JFK. The subway + airtrain thing is not up to par for a global capital. The Heathrow Express in London is a good example of what a decent link looks like. Before Heathrow Express it was possible to take the tube to Heathrow but it was an hour-long journey with stops every couple of minutes, not unlike the current NYC-JFK option. The Heathrow Express is leave every 15 minutes and takes 15 minutes. Getting to Heathrow used to be a real headache. Now it's simple and predictable and has cut the best part of an hour out of a door-to-door journey. NYC needs something similar or better.
- iwejfweoifjweif 14y agoI agree but going from JFK to Penn Station via the LIRR/Airtrain isn't too bad. From the Jamaica station I think its 1-2 stops? Ideally there would just be a train every hour from Penn Station and Grand Central directly to JFK and LaGuardia but I don't see that happening in the next 20-50 years.
- ablefire 14y agoThe Penn Station option is not bad but it's not good. For me the difference is that in NYC I always take a cab or car vs in London I always take the Express. There are bunch of factors including price (cab from Heathrow is a lot more expensive than the Express; tube is cheaper). The train from Penn would need to be a non-stop every 15 mins from the same 2 platforms so you can just head to Penn, know exactly where to go and know that you'll be at the airport within 30 mins (assuming 15 min travel time) no matter what. My understanding is that a new link to the airport was in play when they chose the 2nd Av. line. The 2nd Av. will obviously benefit many more people and is a good choise. I hope it won't take decades to sort out the airport connection. The cab ride to and from JFK is one of the most disheartening parts of living in NYC.
- gav 14y agoIt's about 40mins from Penn to JFK via the LIRR/Airtrain (to go maybe 20 miles). There's about 6 trains/hour. I really don't see how you'd get this journey down to 15 minutes without having to build a new tunnel all the way, it's never going to happen. The real annoyance is how hard it is to get to LGA and that you're reliant on buses. It's a shame that they ran out of money building the N/R and it stops at Ditmars instead of continuing on to the airport. I fly out of NYC biweekly, I generally fly out of JFK so I can take the E/Airtrain there (about 50 mins) and then fly back to LGA and take a towncar home, due to landing later and avoiding traffic. I'd never take a cab to JFK, it can be nearly 2 hours from midtown in traffic.
- wickedchicken 14y agoAnd one day, there will be 24 hour BART looping around the entire bay. Nope. :(
- theatrus2 14y agoThe bay is sufficiently less population dense, making lots of projects "bang for the buck" seem off.
- rayiner 14y agoPopulation density is certainly part of it. Manhattan has about 4x the population density of San Francisco. But 24 hour subway service can be practical with lower population density. E.g. Chicago has a lower population density than San Francisco, but has 24 hour service on the red line (along the lake shore) and a very robust commuter rail service. The key difference is commuting patterns. In the Bay area, people commute haphazardly between suburbs. In NYC and Chicago, everyone from the suburbs commutes downtown in the morning and back out to the suburbs in the evening. It's much easier to have an effective transportation system when everyone is going in the same direction.
- dredmorbius 14y agoMost suburban Chicago commute lines have much lower service frequency than BART. More comparable to CalTrain along the Penninsula, with some 1-2 hour midday gaps in service.
- rayiner 14y agoYes, Metra is to the "L" as Caltrain is to BART. But Metra has 488 miles of track versus Caltrain's 78 miles of track. It carries 300,000 riders per weekday versus Caltrain's 42,000 riders per weekday. Chicagoland is bigger than the SF Bay, but not dramatically so. 10 million people versus 7 million people, at roughly the same density. Caltrain map: http://www.caltrain.com/stations/systemmap.html http://www.caltrain.com/stations/systemmap.html Metra map: http://www.mrl.ucsb.edu/~yopopov/rrt/us/chicago/rr_chicago_metra.gif http://www.mrl.ucsb.edu/~yopopov/rrt/us/chicago/rr_chicago_m...
- rayiner 14y agoThe story highlights something I think anti-rail proponents always miss: the lifetime of this infrastructure is far beyond what ordinary businesses deal with. Parts of the NYC subway are a century old, and parts of the London subway are pushing 150 years old. Decisions like spending extra money to build express tracks on the Manhattan subway system are paying enormous dividends at a time when the people who made the decision have been long dead. Not only do these time scales lengthen the amortization period of these projects, but they dramatically influence peoples' choices. You can't just base your decision to build a subway line on present commuting patterns. People will adjust their lifestyle to take advantage of the new infrastructure, especially over the century-long timescales involved.
- anamax 14y ago> The story highlights something I think anti-rail proponents always miss: the lifetime of this infrastructure is far beyond what ordinary businesses deal with. Parts of the NYC subway are a century old, and parts of the London subway are pushing 150 years old. The part that rail proponents miss is that very little of the world is NYC/London/Japan. Rail, like freeways, can be a "tipping point" if other things are close. However, that isn't always true. Also, you basically have to decide between freight rail and passenger rail, and freight rail makes a lot more sense for much of the US. (Yes, I know that you folks insist that one can have both, but how about some examples....) High-speed rail is going to break CA financially.
- redwood 14y ago"High-speed rail is going to break CA financially." When I hear this, I wonder what the west would be like if people had said the same of all the infrastructure we rely on in the west today. The rail, the roads, the bridges, the dams. Everything. You say "very little of the world is NYC/London/Japan." Well you know what? The western US would have nearly no one living in it if it weren't for big infrastructure projects. It's naturally a very inhospitable place, too little water half the year, too spread out, etc. But we've turned it into a place millions can thrive in. High speed rail may not be as critical as water, but it's ridiculous to think we can't build a modern railroad today. If we can't build a modern railroad today then we're already broken. And if we're already broken, what do we have to lose?
- joering2 14y agoFor those who loves explosives and don't have time to watch it all: fast forward to 3:35 :)
- chimeracoder 14y agoNot to be a wet blanket, but let's not forget how far behind schedule this line is - it was originally supposed to be opened just a few years after World War II(!): http://secondavenuesagas.com/second-ave-subway-history/ http://secondavenuesagas.com/second-ave-subway-history/ The most ironic part is that the bulk of the line is already complete (or mostly there) - they just don't have enough to stretch below 42nd street, IIRC, which is the tipping point for when they can open it as a useable line. Also, last I heard, it was to be a single-track line (like the L). So after all those years, we'll still be stuck in the case of any breakdowns or delays - picture the L at rush hour, except worse, because of the passenger volume. And no chance of any express train. That is, if it ever even opens. A good rule of thumb for the MTA's estimates seems to be 'Time.now() + 5.years'. All that said, I love NYC's transit system - it couldn't be the city is without it. I just wish we had more than one single line on the east side!