7 ms·
Having someone born in the country they are looking to lead seems silly to you? With that restriction, it has taken quite some time for a foreign adversary to
by dylan604 2y ago
Having someone born in the country they are looking to lead seems silly to you?
With that restriction, it has taken quite some time for a foreign adversary to have a puppet elected vs just shipping in some carpet bagger.
Having a minimum age also allows for some decent life experience. After all, 35 years old is not that old.
- gunian 2y agoSingapore seems to be doing fine without that requirement is what that comment said i think talking about different things
- eru 2y agoSingapore has lots of other crazy requirements, though.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoFor me "botn in the country" or "born a citizen of the country" does not mean much. This is like assuming that your birth status makes the person. Think minarchy, castes, ... You can be a naturalized citizen in live with your country, or a born citizen plain stupid and with worst interests in mind.
- dylan604 2y agoBorn in the country lessens the likelihood that you are beholden to more than one master. Born in another country then naturalized still does not rule out sleeper agent situations. Seems pretty obvious to me. I'm one that questions the whole pledge of allegiance forced to be recited by children that have no wherewithal to understand what allegiance even means or the ramifications of that pledge. Yet, I'm okay with born in country and of a minimum age.
- kennysoona 2y ago> Born in the country lessens the likelihood that you are beholden to more than one master. Not in the modern world it doesn't.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoAnd yet when you look at the great espionnage stories, the perpetrators were citizens of the country. When you look at people who were "almost born" (came to the country as toddlers) or naturalized because of the love of their new country, purple claiming that they are second category citizens are hard to listen to.
- dylan604 2y agoMaybe because the policy exists that people have not so easily been able to get to the top position. Remove that policy and Putin himself could run for the office. It's an idiotic comment for an idiotic misunderstanding of why the policy exists
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoYou seem to put people in the category of "born here, so good" and "birn elsewhere, less good". Fair enough. If you are a supporter of, say, Trump you therefore say that Biden or Harris are much better than any other, naturalized citizen, as presidents? It's hard to see the logic here, probably because I am an idiot, but if where you were birn defines the man for you then fine - everyone has their opinion.
- dylan604 2y agoit's so unamerican it is part of the constitution that defines america and deliberately placed there by the founding fathers. i'm sure they were concerned that the king would try to undermine the new country the first chance he got by placing someone loyal to the crown to undo all of the work that led to the constitution. it's not a good better best situation like you seem to think. at this point, i really think the unwilling to see how attempting to limit the new nation from being led by a foreign operative would be so important to the survival of the new nation. only, new is now 200+ years old (yet still a babe in the woods to other national histories) so the "threat" seems lessened by people like you. i also started the entire thread by stating we have a foreign operative in place now, so if you can't read between those lines in who i didn't vote for then you're really just being deliberately obtuse about the situation is the only logical explanation i can see.
- the_clarence 2y agoAnd yet elon musk an immigrant is currently the president
- eru 2y agoAt least he's an African American.
- eru 2y ago> Born in another country then naturalized still does not rule out sleeper agent situations. Seems pretty obvious to me. Voters can take these things into consideration when casting their ballots. No need to make these choices for them.
- kelnos 2y agoI think recent events in the US make it quite clear that voters don't really consider the things that actually matter when electing a president.
- eru 2y agoSure, that's a defensible position, too. In that case, I suggest finding some obscure German house of nobles and putting them on the throne. Works reasonably ok for the UK.
- Lanolderen 2y agoChoose your evil: Elect a dynasty to rule forever Limit voting rights of group X,Y and Z to get "better" votes Remain with the rule of the majority system Elect ChatGPT to rule forever with a "be nice pls" prompt
- eru 2y agoWell, you could at least move to Approval voting instead of first past the post. Or you could try sortition, which you haven't even considered at all.
- Lanolderen 2y agoThe dream is probably dynamic voting through some login system where it's not done every X years but whenever you decide to change your vote maybe using ATMs as physical voting terminals for accessibility. Then voters can change their mind at any time and cause a change in leadership should the vote not be corrected over Y time. Then on top of that you can add multiple parties, individual person voting, etc. It probably won't happen in my lifetime since governments aren't built to be flexible\agile but one can dream.
- n4r9 2y agoThe UK's recent prime minister Boris Johnson was born in the US two British parents who happened to be studying in Manhatten at the time. They all moved back here a few months later. The idea that he could be some sort of US sleeper agent is hilarious, though.
- eru 2y agoWell, formally the Prime Minister is just some random bloke appointed by king to help him run the country. The PM doesn't even need to be a member of parliament! Now the king, that guy can't even be catholic! And until recently, couldn't even be female with living brothers.
- n4r9 2y agoTradition does dictate that the PM is an MP, and tradition in UK parliament is pretty binding. However, an MP does not even need to be a British citizen: an Irish or a Commonwealth citizen can become an MP and go on to command the confidence of the house.
- eru 2y ago> Tradition does dictate that the PM is an MP, and tradition in UK parliament is pretty binding. I hope it stays that way. The US had pretty strong traditions in politics, too, but they are increasingly being eroded. To give an example that's hopefully far enough in the past to be non-controversial: when they banned alcohol in the early 1920s, they felt that their constitution did not already explicitly give their federal government the power to do so. So they passed the 18th amendment to give the feds that power to specifically ban alcohol. Decades later, in the context of the war on drugs, everybody seems to take it for granted that the federal government can obviously ban arbitrary substances.
- vkou 2y ago> Born in the country lessens the likelihood that you are beholden to more than one master. This may have held true sometime in the 17th century, but it really doesn't in the 21st.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoIt is silly. What if a twin is born in Canadian airspace and the other on American soil? How big of a difference is it if an infant is born on Monday and their parents immigrate to the US legally on Friday? Irrelevant.
- eru 2y ago> How big of a difference is it if an infant is born on Monday and their parents immigrate to the US legally on Friday? I don't think your parents even have to be legally in the US for you to become an American. You just have to be born in the US, legally or illegally.
- toyg 2y agoAnd we should celebrate it for the civilisational advance that it is, promoting it all over the world, instead of continuously attacking its legitimacy. We have long rejected the idea that blood should dictate your social position in the tribe; but somehow we cling to the idea that it should dictate whether you belong to the tribe at all. Why? It's not with this mindset that we will reach the stars.
- eru 2y ago> And we should celebrate it for the civilisational advance that it is, [...] Well, as far as I can tell, it's only in your constitution sort-of by accident. They didn't put this 'advance' in original, it was just the simplest and most face saving way to free the slaves without directly mentioning slaves in the text. (Compare the 3/5 compromise for 'other persons', which also avoids mentioning slaves by that term.)
- lazyasciiart 2y agoYes, it seems silly. Which countries have had a foreign puppet elected because they lack this provision?
- jibe 2y agoHitler?
- hackandthink 2y agoHitler was stateless from 1925 until 1932. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalization_of_Adolf_Hitler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalization_of_Adolf_Hitler
- eru 2y agoMaybe. Though probably not: by German law Hitler could already not have been in power, because he wasn't properly a German citizen at the time. (It's all very murky.) Hitler was already in power illegally. The law we are discussing here would have just made it 'even more illegal'. (I'm using the weasel wording 'in power' here, because I forgot whether he needed to be a citizen to be a member of the Reichstag at all, or only to become chancellor.)
- MaxPock 2y agoNatenyahu ?
- smcl 2y agoHitler was a "foreign puppet"? This is news to me, can you tell us who the puppet master was? Because it seems to me that person should be as widely reviled as the man himself.
- eru 2y agoHitler was a foreigner who caused trouble in Germany, to put it mildly. You are right however, that he wasn't a puppet.
- Quarrel 2y ago> Having someone born in the country they are looking to lead seems silly to you? Whether it is silly or not, I'm not sure, but it certainly doesn't seem very democratic. IMO Arnold Schwarzenegger, to pick a random foreign born politician, should be able to stand for President. People can choose not to vote for him if they've bothered by him being foreign born. FWIW, in Australia, no member of Federal Parliament (so Congress equivalent) can be a dual citizen (and they must be Australian citizens), so an equivalent to Arnie in Australia would need to renounce their foreign citizenship before standing for election. This seems like a better middle ground than "must be born in the country" to me.
- echelon 2y ago> IMO Arnold Schwarzenegger, to pick a random foreign born politician, should be able to stand for President. The reservoir of potential candidates is vast. The risk this mitigates seems important enough to give up on additional potential candidates. It's not like other countries aren't protective. Have you looked at trying to even just immigrate to Japan? Regardless of how you feel, a country should be able to set its own policies.
- JambalayaJimbo 2y agoWell the American born presidential policy is just strange because it seems so un-American. You’d think the country would have had at least one range to riches president who was a refugee from some war torn country by now, it’s just such a fundamental part of the nation’s mythos.
- herewulf 2y agoNo, the mythos is more like a couple hundred years of WASP gentry dominance and then occasionally they let a Catholic get elected. Quite a big deal when JFK was the first. Look it up.
- throwaway2037 2y ago> Have you looked at trying to even just immigrate to Japan? Here I am again to dispel this HN myth about immigration and Japan. Ignoring that the Japanese economy is currently weaker than the US economy (which affects your chances of getting an offer in both places as a foreigner), in terms of paperwork and bureaucracy, Japan is much easier to get (and keep) a skilled work visa compared to the US. If you are not looking for a skilled work visa, there is a long term tourist visa (6mo+6mo) that is also easy to get, but you need to have about 200K EUR in liquid assets. Again, the US doesn't have anything as low friction.
- the_clarence 2y agoYes it is silly
- eru 2y ago> Having a minimum age also allows for some decent life experience. After all, 35 years old is not that old. Shouldn't that be for voters to decide?
- smcl 2y ago> Having someone born in the country they are looking to lead seems silly to you? Yes and it looks especially silly for a country which used to pride itself on being composed primarily of immigrants. In fact the current president is one of the people who was pushing conspiracy theories about a previous president not being eligible - the "birther" movement around Barack Obama. At the time that movement was small enough and the far right was distant enough from the levers of power that people could laugh it off. But it would not surprise me whatsoever if in the future the US right pulled something similar to what Turkey did here, stripping a rival candidate or a portion of the electorate of their status to strengthen their own bid.
- daemin 2y agoHaving a minimum age to get some life experience is fine, and 35 I would consider a good age, however the minimum age in the USA these days seems like 70. As for being born in the country, I'm sure with the challenge to birthright citizenship that will get changed in short order to both being born in the country and having your parents and ancestors also be citizens. Maybe it will change to more of a hereditary system where people had records to prove their ancestry was noble.