3 ms·
There's some important nuance here: All commands (after trigger/wake word) were sent to the cloud in the past anyway. The option to do some on-device processin
by Aurornis 2y ago
There's some important nuance here: All commands (after trigger/wake word) were sent to the cloud in the past anyway.
The option to do some on-device processing came on later devices and, as I understand it, wasn't even enabled by default. Furthermore, on-device processing would still send the parsed commands to the cloud.
The headline is vague, but it's misleading a lot of people into thinking that only now Amazon will start sending commands to the cloud. It's actually always been that way. I suspect the number of people who enabled on-device processing was very, very small.
- luma 2y agoI'm shocked that not one single article I've found mentioned this incredibly obvious fact. This has ALWAYS been the case and only a few select models ever offered the option to turn it off. This change puts all devices on equal footing and behavior with the launch device. I don't love Amazon, but I love ginned up outrage over tech the author never bothered to understand even less.
- wilg 2y agoOnline news articles are not really a workable medium for real journalism or reporting
- jasonfarnon 2y ago"I don't love Amazon, but I love ginned up outrage over tech the author never bothered to understand even less." And 99% of Echo owners disagree with this. No one cares if a reporter mixed up "amazon is starting to spy on you tomorrow" vs "amazon has been spying on you since the first echo was launched". Only amazon would make an argument like "yeah but we've been doing this for years now and no one made a big deal about it..."
- jvanderbot 2y agoRight. But you have to admit this sounds a bit like labelling Cereal "arsenic free". Really helpful to know but the sudden announcement hides that it's always been that way and implies others aren't. In truth this is probably how they all work and always have, but such a headline wouldn't ding Amazon sales.
- Sophira 2y agoI don't have anything of substance to say, but I wanted to mention that I appreciate your subtle xkcd reference[0]! [0] https://xkcd.com/641/ https://xkcd.com/641/
- drpossum 2y ago> I don't have anything of substance to say Thanks for saying something anyways. I wish more people would follow your example.
- Sophira 2y agoI genuinely can't tell whether you're being sarcastic or whether you're saying that you appreciated the link to the XKCD. If the former, then I apologise.
- smallmancontrov 2y ago> ginned up The Sauron's Eye of public sentiment can only pay attention to one thing at a time. If you justify today on the basis that it wasn't paying attention yesterday, you can rationalize anything.
- thomasjudge 2y agoThe Register in particular is a pretty garbagey source
- hardlianotion 2y agoI disagree.
- hodgesrm 2y agoSome of us like the tabloid-style IT reporting. The more salient criticism for me is that it's way less entertaining than a few years ago.
- hulitu 2y ago> I'm shocked that not one single article I've found mentioned this incredibly obvious fact. The search engines are crap. There was a story some years ago where Amazon employees from an Eastern European country were actually listening to your Alexa and sent the relevant commands back to the device.
- btown 2y agoWhile the headlines may be exaggerated, it's worth comparing https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=G4X4X8C26Z73P8SQ https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=... - "You will be able to review and delete those transcripts in your Voice History" - with https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2025/01/our-longstanding-privacy-commitment-with-siri/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2025/01/our-longstanding-priv... - "Siri searches and requests are not associated with your Apple Account." I'm not disappointed that this "non-event" is drawing attention to this comparison. Even if it's farfetched to dream that bringing privacy more to the forefront of the news zeitgeist will result in a shift of the status quo for our industry - heaven knows that if privacy stories don't get mindshare, the status quo could get far worse.