3 ms·
> It’s space-inefficient as half of the CPUs are shutdown In practice is doesn't matter very much for a design like this. The size is already limited to a cert
by Aurornis 2y ago
> It’s space-inefficient as half of the CPUs are shutdown
In practice is doesn't matter very much for a design like this. The size is already limited to a certain minimum to provide enough perimeter area to provide wire bonding area for all of the pins, so they can fill up the middle with whatever they want.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoThey should have filled it with more SRAM instead - 520KB is far too little.
- Tharre 2y agoWhat difference would the extra 16KiB or whatever instead of the 2 RISC-V cores make? If 520KB is far too little for you, you're likely better off adding a 8 MiB PSRAM chip.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoJust 16KB? Couldn’t a lot more be fitted? PSRAM has huge latency.
- timschmidt 2y agoSRAM takes up a tremendous amount of space compared to logic. Usually at least six transistors per bit, plus passives, plus management logic.
- Lerc 2y agoSRAM is big in gate count. typically 6 transistors per bit. The i386, a 32 bit chip already dragging around a couple of generations of legacy architecture came in at 275,000. I would imagine the Hazard3 would be quite a bit more efficient in transistor usage due to architecture. 16K is 16384(bytes) *8(bits per byte) *6(transistors per bit) = 786, 432
- DrNosferatu 2y agoIt was the first CPU on my desk! 80386SX 25MHz. (this one, only 32bit internally)
- DrNosferatu 2y agoThanks for the explanations - was not aware. …vertically stack a slab of SRAM above or beneath the CPU die, does come to mind ;)
- murderfs 2y agoThis is way too expensive for something like a microcontroller. AMD calls this 3D V-Cache and uses it on their top end SKUs.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoBut doesn't the ESP32-S3-WROOM have some large on-chip RAM? For the Pico, say, something in the line of the approach taken by many smartphone SoCs that package memory and processor together.
- drrotmos 2y agoThe ESP32-S3 has 512 KB of SRAM, and the RP2350 has 520 KB of SRAM. The ESP32-S3-WROOM does indeed come in configurations with additional PSRAM, but that would be comparing apples and pears. The WROOM is an entire module complete with program flash, PSRAM, crystal oscillator etc. It comes in a much larger footprint than the actual ESP32-S3, and it is entirely conceivable that one could create a similar module with the same amount of PSRAM using the RP2350. Furthermore, the added RAM in both cases is indeed PSRAM. That being said, the ESP32-S3 supports octal PSRAM, not just quad PSRAM, which does make a difference for the throughput.
- DrNosferatu 2y ago> "some" And go cellphone style: Package-on-Package or Multi-Chip Module of some sort. Wouldn't the massive increase in capabilities from adding 8MB-16MB of closely-integrated, fast RAM far outweigh the modest price increase for many applications that are currently memory-constrained on the Pico?
- Tharre 2y ago
- DrNosferatu 2y agoWouldn't the massive increase in capabilities from adding 8MB-16MB of closely-integrated, fast RAM far outweigh the modest price increase for many applications that are currently memory-constrained on the Pico?