3 ms·
Under $100K they're covering housing, food, and more: > Undergraduate students from families with annual incomes of $100,000 or less will not only have tuition
by Aurornis 2y ago
Under $100K they're covering housing, food, and more:
> Undergraduate students from families with annual incomes of $100,000 or less will not only have tuition covered but also housing, food, health services and other student services, the university said.
A very confusing aspect of the US college system is that very few students pay the full sticker price. Most universities have sliding scales for tuition through various grants and scholarships.
Strangely, even talking to college students reveals that most of them don't understand this situation. You'll frequently hear college students explain that they got "lucky" to get a lot of grants, discounts, and/or scholarships to attend, but in reality all but the most wealthy families get a lot of "tuition assistance".
The situation confuses foreigners and even US people to no end, but it allows universities to admit a much wider range of students than they normally would. It's not uncommon to look at their statistics and find a significant portion of their student body pays nearly nothing in tuition. Harvard is taking this to an extreme, but there are similar programs at all of the other big universities.
One critical exception: There are sleazy for-profit universities who take advantage of the fact that some people don't understand this game and use it to charge exorbitant rates to people who can't afford it. Avoid those, obviously, and do your part to discourage others from looking at them.
This sliding scale tuition structure explains the massive discrepancy between the $200K+ per year sticker price for a 4-year degree at private universities and the fact that most students graduate with nowhere near that much debt.
- paulpauper 2y agoThis is sorta why the hysterics by the punditry on Twitter and the media about student loan debt or about college degrees being worthless, are overblown or unfounded. The sticker price is seldom, if ever paid in full. Not only huge discounts on the tuition-side, but also tons of forbearance and payment plans after graduating. There are many people with homes, 6-figure jobs paying off loans slowly and gradually, while enjoying career success and a high standard of living compared to those who do not have degrees. It's not as daunting as the large figure of money would suggest when the returns from a degree are still largely positive compared to without a degree.
- lapcat 2y ago> the returns from a degree are still largely positive compared to without a degree. Keep in mind that people who do not complete a degree also accumulate student loans.
- m463 2y agoI also wonder if people who get loans might be different than the people who search for and get aid. It might be more frictionless to get into debt than get a scholarship, even if it would be possible.
- robertjpayne 2y agoThis is oversimplifying. The path to a good career after graduation is still fraught with many traps and pitfalls. Ask anyone who finished university in late 2008 to 2010 how their job prospects were compared to those that finished just two years earlier in 2006. Compounded by the fact that there is no way to discharge the debt if you get exploited into signing up to $100,000+ of debt for a degree that provides no good stable income afterwards.
- sarchertech 2y agoClose to 90% of all student loans are federal and qualify for income based repayment. The vast majority of students don’t have any private student loans, so if they can’t find a job they pay nothing. If they make money but not enough, they’ll pay 10% of any income above 1.5x the poverty level. Plus there are very generous forbearance terms if you’re temporarily struggling.
- paulpauper 2y agoThis is oversimplifying. The path to a good career after graduation is still fraught with many traps and pitfalls. same for people without degrees. having a degree increases odds of success and pay
- telchior 2y ago"There are many people" is a useless platitude to any number of people who fall through the cracks. Personally I had to wait until I was 25 to get some loans I needed to finally finish a degree, because my family was paper rich, wasn't paying anything, but was still on speaking / visiting terms with me. The system doesn't accept that as an answer; you have to show an extreme degree of alienation / separation (I can't remember the specifics, but a loan counsellor basically told me to give up).
- latentcall 2y agoCool, tuition should be taxpayer funded by the American people, namely the super wealthy.
- mcmcmc 2y agoThere are a lot of other things that money should go towards before college tuition. Maybe we start with our abysmal primary and secondary education.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoFun fact: if we taxed all income over $500,000 at a 100% tax rate it wouldn’t even cover our current budget deficit, let alone allow for such a massive spending increase.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- patrickthebold 2y agoSource?
- Aloisius 2y agoEm. People filing returns over $500K reported an aggregate AGI of $3.8 trillion for 2022. After subtracting out the $981 million in income taxes they paid, you'd still be left with about $2.8 trillion, about a trillion more than the deficit. Not that they wouldn't immediately shield their income if you tried. Still, I don't see any issue with maximizing our tax revenue from the top 1% by increasing their taxes until total revenue starts to drop, though I'd also be happy just dramatically increasing inheritance taxes and eliminating tax shields since billionaires still die regularly. Source: https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-individual-statistical-tables-by-size-of-adjusted-gross-income https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-individual-stat... (Table 1.1, row 57)
- WeylandYutani 2y agoThere are entire skyscrapers filled with people whose job it is to make sure rich people pay as little tax as possible.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoA very confusing aspect of the US college system is that very few students pay the full sticker price. At Harvard, that 'very few' is 45%. From the article: About 55% of Harvard undergraduates receive some type of financial aid, according to the university. You say: but it allows universities to admit a much wider range of students than they normally would. The high sticker prices combined with variable discounts aren't there to change the pool of students. Their purpose is to ensure that each student (or their family) pays close to the maximum they'd be willing to pay. Do you like it when you visit a SaaS product's pricing page and it says 'call for pricing'? Well, how about if it was totally normal that, before a SaaS provider was willing to quote you a price, you had to provide them with a list of your assets and a copy of your most recent tax return?
- sarchertech 2y agoIf they were maximizing for revenue, they’d just only admit people who could afford it. They could easily fill all of their slots with people who can afford to pay the full tuition.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoI didn't say they're trying to maximize total revenue. I said they're trying to maximize revenue from each student. Those two are not the same. They're not stupid. They're not going to destroy the university's reputation by admitting only people who can pay a lot. That would work for a couple of years, but eventually it would be known a party school.
- sarchertech 2y agoThey clearly also aren’t maximizing revenue from each student because it maxes out at only $60k a year. There are many students at Harvard whose families would pay more than that. On the lower end there’s no way that 25% of the students are willing to pay nothing at all. If they really wanted to maximize what each student pays they wouldn’t publicly disclose the formula. They’d let you in, look at your financials, and then give you an individualized quote that takes “you’re unique circumstances into account.” (They do that to some extent by offering additional scholarships to some people, but they wouldn’t give you a formula that defines the ceiling.)
- spit2wind 2y agoAs a contrast to the hand waving in the other posts which claims many don't pay full price, the degree I got cost $20k per semester for the 2 years I attended university after community college, paid in full each semeser. That's one data point, I know. And maybe it's an outlier. I'd be interested to know, of the people who got grants and other support, what percentage of their total tuition was it? And what percentage of people got support? It's also worth noting, that there's a difference between knowing you'll have support and the uncertainty of not knowing.