4 ms·
If you want to tax cars more, up the gas tax which already affects people who drive SUVs more than small cars. Risking this level of abuse of the 5th amendment
by protomyth 14y ago
If you want to tax cars more, up the gas tax which already affects people who drive SUVs more than small cars. Risking this level of abuse of the 5th amendment is just not worth the cost.
This type of tax is also about as anti-poor people as you can get. Any big tax that hits all at once is a killer.
- marquis 14y agoThat was my thought exactly: are gas taxes nothing more than 'per mile' taxes? Just raise those, gas is already cheaper in California than many places. Of course, it would be nice if that money were to go directly into funding full cover public transport for those who will no longer be able to afford to get to their low-paid job 50 miles away.
- csense 14y agoOver the long term, the gas tax encourages a change in consumption patterns. Take a job closer to home, move closer to your work, or telecommute more. Per-mile tax does exactly the same thing, but with a ton of invasive technological monitoring.
- rogerbinns 14y agoThat is also a simple solution. It is trivial to change the "tax" rate, and even later it by area. About the only thing you can't do is take time of day into account. But other solutions solve that like the car pool lanes you can go into if you have a toll transponder and agree to the price shown which are already available in the area. I don't understand why they keep trying to come up with these complex technological solutions. Unless they are barring visitors not all cars will have whatever it is they want installed.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoSomething I find very strange. Many criticize Pigouvian taxes as being "anti-poor people", on the grounds that they will disproportionately affect the behavior of the poor. Yet it's quite uncommon for the same critics to levy their criticism at the poor for engaging in socially harmful behavior. Why is that?
- protomyth 14y agoWhat exactly are you considering "socially harmful behavior" in this situation?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe behavior that the pigouvian tax is designed to discourage. In this particular case the behavior is driving, which the government proposing the tax believes is socially harmful.
- protomyth 14y agoI am a little confused. The gas tax is supposed to be a use tax to pay for the roads, not discourage a behavior.
- yummyfajitas 14y ago"Proponents argue that a driving tax may be an effective way to curtail driving." "...one of five ideas it has to reduce the environmental impact of traffic in the San Francisco Bay Area."
- hannibalhorn 14y agoNot to mention, what about people that drive in from other cities/states, rental cars, etc.? You can't visit SF without getting a tracker installed? Imagine the effect on tourism revenue. A gas tax is pretty close to a tax on miles driven, and significantly less complicated.
- smsm42 14y agoIf they raise gas tax, people will notice immediately and scream. If they just add some new obscure tax they have reasonable chance people won't notice how much it is until that April 15th time, and it will be too late then. Or at least they think so.