6 ms·
This is worthless. It's a copy and paste of this question on Stack Exchange: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/155488/ive-inherited-200k-lines-of-
by Groxx 14y ago
This is worthless.
It's a copy and paste of this question on Stack Exchange: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/155488/ive-inherited-200k-lines-of-spaghetti-code-what-now http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/155488/ive-in... but with broken formatting, and nothing else.
- falling 14y agoNo it’s not. The article gave the question visibility outside Stack Exchange, where I (and I’m sure many others) would have never seen it. Also, it’s by Stack Exchange, as stated in the byline and right at the top of the article. Edit: cool, I was wondering why I hadn’t been getting any reactions to my comments in the past weeks. Today I realized I’ve been hellbanned, most likely for this http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4208283 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4208283 This is bullshit.
- vineet 14y agoYeah. There is no value being added beyond just copying Stack Exchange. Is Ars Technica in trouble these days that they are just copying content?
- mattdeboard 14y agoI think every news wire service in the world would disagree with the perspective that you and the GP are espousing. edit: I have made the mistake of using an analogy on the internet. I realize it's not exactly the same, ok?
- Groxx 14y agoHah! You're probably right. I'd be interested in the thoughts of the people running this show, if they'd drop in :| It would be an interesting debate, in any case. I'm really having trouble seeing how this (particular instance, not necessarily in general) is a good idea, or at all in line with SE's design.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoThey think these reprinted pieces are worthwhile content. They also reprint Wired articles sometimes. If you think it's worthless, complain to them.
- Groxx 14y ago@falling: not sure why you're hellbanned either, but without some kind of introductory text or summary or anything it's just blog-spam at it's absolute minimum amount of effort. They're clearly not even proof-reading before posting, given the broken formatting (edit: apparently this has been fixed). If you want to argue that increased visibility is reason enough for its existence, then you're arguing in favor of every single copy and paste job on the internet. If so, that's your opinion - there are definite benefits for increasing quantity. But I wholeheartedly disagree that it is good. To be painfully specific why, it's making a static copy of something from a site which was built because static answers were deemed bad, and it's splitting the feedback for little or no gain (note how there are more possibly-valuable responses in Ars' comments, but they're not on SE). That it was apparently done by Stack Exchange is even weirder - they're willfully contributing to data-rot, when one of their major reasons for existence is to prevent it. It has already fallen behind the original answer, which has some significant edits since this was posted.
- vineet 14y agoI don't know if this is really done by Stack Exchange. If you look at the user 'Stack Exchange' it has an arstechnica e-mail associated with it.
- Groxx 14y agoIt's a possibility. But it's being done under their name - that's almost the same thing in practice. And I would hope it's not an unapproved use of their name, so they're implicitly approving of what is done with it. edit: unless you meant something like them having a SE 'user' to categorize posts? I think all Q&As are under CC, so they're legally capable of doing that, but it certainly looks to me like it's SE doing the posting, since that's how they display authors too. I think the spreading of good SE Q&As is great. There are problems with it that essentially can't be resolved (stale data), but it does spread good information to people who may not have seen it otherwise. But this is sheer laziness, and ends up with something significantly less valuable than if they had just embedded the question in an iframe.