3 ms·
> Start doing mass studies on cognitive problems created by instagram and TikTok. Publish them in big journals This has already happened. We didn't kick Big To
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Start doing mass studies on cognitive problems created by instagram and TikTok. Publish them in big journals
This has already happened. We didn't kick Big Tobacco by publishing research and just talking about it. We got them with bans. I don't see America doing it. But now would be a good time for e.g. the EU to start regulating social media like a utility.
- VectorLock 2y agoWe almost got there with TikTok. Almost...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> We almost got there with TikTok. Almost... Not really. The TikTok ban was rooted in national security concerns. The coalition that brought it forward would not be useful for regulating social media as the drug analog it is. I don't see a brilliant move in America. (There is an a brilliant opportunity in the EU, Canada and Mexico to recapitulate the TikTok bill's rhetoric and structure, aiming it at both China and America.)
- kelseydh 2y agoThe TikTok ban was motivated primarily by the Israel lobby wanting to crack down on pro-Palestinian content.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> TikTok ban was motivated primarily by the Israel lobby wanting to crack down on pro-Palestinian content It really wasn't. But I agree that this was a popular take. (Funnily enough, the rumor helped shore up the bill's polling among Republican-leaning voters. And once it was up, like, yes, rule number one of politics is you generally don't say no to votes.) The EU going after Instagram and Twitter would find its own stable of bizarre conspiracy theories.
- Nextgrid 2y ago> the EU to start regulating social media like a utility. They could just actually enforce the existing GDPR which already makes most of these addiction-based models unsustainable.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> could just actually enforce the existing GDPR which already makes most of these addiction-based models unsustainable It would be ill advised without a popular mandate. Remember the conspiracy theories the TikTok ban prompted? You don't want to yank the neo-Nazis' Twitters on a bureaucratic point.
- Nextgrid 2y agoThat's the key - a ban on social media will be endlessly argued (what counts as social media?) and would raise suspicions. A ban on non-consensual data collection (or rather, the enforcement of existing rules) is not only much easier to define (the laws are already written in fact) but also very straightforward to understand. Social media is welcome to continue to exist at a loss, but the removal of the financial incentive for greater "engagement" should make it much less toxic.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> ban on non-consensual data collection (or rather, the enforcement of existing rules) is not only much easier to define (the laws are already written in fact) but also very straightforward to understand I worked on the TikTok bill. Nobody reads the details when you threaten to take their toys. Like, play it out. EU says Twitter, quit it. Elon says fuck off. Now what? You fine him. Great. Elon says fuck off. You start, what, raiding the Ireland office? Seizing bank accounts? If he takes Twitter dark, do you think its users will be differentiating between non-consensual data collection and a ban? We haven't even geopoliticised it yet! The same suspicions that would animate a ban (or regulation) will animate starting to enforce GDPR now. For this to work, it has to be bottom up. The only way I see that happening is a rally to the flag move by European leaders and a show of force with a targeted new bill.
- cscurmudgeon 2y agoThe analogies are all over the place lol. Is social media pure evil like tobacco OR is it a necessity like a utility? How can it be both? EU pretends it is both while getting backdoor access. https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/economy/2024/6/20/orwellian-eus-push-to-mass-scan-private-messages-on-whatsapp-signal https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/economy/2024/6/20/orwellian-eu...
- 6stringmerc 2y agoWe made smoking heavily taxed and socially unacceptable as well - watch Die Hard 2. John McClain is smoking in public spaces like the AIRPORT. People still do cocaine regularly, but in secret or in bathrooms. The problem with social media is the legal SUPPORT in the US, it’s far worse than tobacco ever dreamed of accomplishing. Banning social media in public spaces is something I would support, but HOW?