21 ms·
> If you were at a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy and somebody used one of these on you, what would you do? Leave. The moment it turns into a rio
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> If you were at a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy and somebody used one of these on you, what would you do?
Leave. The moment it turns into a riot you’re doing damage to your cause. (If you’re in a protest and see hooligans, restrain them.)
- pclmulqdq 2y agoYou might enjoy reading Rules for Radicals if you haven't already. If your riot can provoke a worse response from the authority, it can help your cause. The reaction is the action. It may be that this protest in Serbia got a bit rowdy and riotous (see "diversity of tactics") and now the headline is about the government's use of a disproportionate weapon against protestors, not about a riot.
- tptacek 2y agoRules for Radicals is one of my favorite books and I don't think this an accurate summary of what Alinsky says, at all. It's a short book, you can get it for free online, people should just read it.
- krainboltgreene 2y agoThis tracks so much with what you’ve said before.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> You might enjoy reading Rules for Radicals if you haven't already. If your riot can provoke a worse response from the authority One motif of Allinsky's message is the importance of organisation. Triggering tear gas against your peaceful protest is one thing. Losing control of it such that stores start getting looted is not. > It may be that this protest in Serbia got a bit rowdy and riotous (see "diversity of tactics") and now the headline is about the government's use of a disproportionate weapon against protestors This is the first-order effect. They got a tweet. (Not a headline.) I'm sceptical they'll get a second because this isn't a clear case of a nonlethal weapon being used against a peaceful crowd, it's something more muddled, and as a result there are zero comments in this thread discussing what the protesters are protesting.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoJust for the sake of the thread, these are "anti-corruption" protests. It is essentially a mass vote of no confidence in the government. The immediate inciting incident was the collapse of a railway station in Novi Sad that killed a bunch of people, but it has turned into much more. It's been going since November. I wouldn't be surprised if this is the prelude to a civil war.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y ago> They got a tweet. (Not a headline.) They got a headline https://apnews.com/article/serbia-protest-sonic-weapon-8502587e5849997175a5ea02f98d2e19 https://apnews.com/article/serbia-protest-sonic-weapon-85025... > Serbian officials deny illegal sonic weapon attack on peaceful protesters
- Kostic 2y agoThis happened during 15 minutes of silence for 15 persons that died in the collapse. Everyone was silent and mourning.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThat's good advice, but I mean what do you do when you get home? Now that your right to assemble has been effectively revoked, what's your next step?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoPlan a legal assembly, an economic protest, and write your legislator. Right to assemble is not a blank check for violent action, or even to assemble wherever and whenever your want.
- int_19h 2y agoThe reason why these are legal is precisely because they are so ineffective.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoCome back the next day?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> what do you do when you get home? Now that your right to assemble has been effectively revoked Your right to assembly remains. You just made a risk-adjustment decision about not participating in a riot. The correct thing to do is go home, regroup and join the protest leadership to help plan another protest where the hooliganism is kept in check.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoWhen deciding whether to pull the trigger on such a thing, what matters is whether it will make things worse, regardless of whether that worsening counts as correct behavior or not. Also, not being in Serbia myself I'm reluctant to make judgements from afar about what degree of hooliganism is justified in this case.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- hellotomyrars 2y agoWho defines what counts as a riot? The people who have the state-sanctioned monopoly on violence are the ones who get to decide when a protest becomes a riot or unlawful assembly. I’m not saying they’re always wrong but when only one group gets to pull the card that allows them to shut down protest it creates perverse incentives.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Who defines what counts as a riot? Practically, the media and the public at large. I forgot the source, but you can pretty much directly see the negative effect of e.g. bridge blocking on public sympathy for a cause.
- hippari2 2y agoI think it's pretty much a useless protest if everyone leaves the moment it become "a bit rowdy". Not to mention that if you meditate for long enough of time ( which is like the most peaceful kind of protest ) the Police will Spray / LDAR you anyway.
- consteval 2y agoI don’t think this is true. In order for the media to consider something a riot there has to be some violence. Gone are the days of print media, we expect videos now. But it’s trivial for police to incite violence. We saw it all the time in the US during BLM protests. A protest starts peacefully, then the protesters are pushed by riot control, then rubber bullets are fired into the peaceful protest, and now it’s not peaceful. Sometimes the protesters would even get surrounded and flanked so they can’t escape the descent into a riot.
- ty6853 2y agoYep, if you are depending on perception by media you have already lost. They will manipulate it to look however they like, trivially and convincingly. If change does occur, what will happen is they will repaint history to make it seem as if the most cowish placid of the protests brought the change, to fool the public. And people actually believe it.
- int_19h 2y agoUkrainians didn't leave, and they ended up taking their country back. Twice.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Ukrainians didn't leave, and they ended up taking their country back I'm struggling to remember any rioting in the Maidan.
- int_19h 2y agoI mean, they have literally built a catapult on Maidan to throw molotov cocktails at the police. And used said molotovs to set fire to an APC.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> they have literally built a catapult on Maidan to throw molotov cocktails at the police. And used said molotovs to set fire to an APC I guess I wouldn't characterise such focussed use of violence as "starting to get a bit rowdy." Rowdiness specifically implies unruliness, a lack of discipline. I'd also say that escalating from peaceful to violent protest is not a decision one should take in the moment--catapults and molotov cocktails imply preparation.
- martin-t 2y agoThis thinking is dangerous and wrong. You cannot fight against violence without violence. Violence is most effective when it's implied/threatened, before it is materialized. The goal of protests are: 1) To serve as a show of force (they are literally called demonstrations in some languages because you demonstrate your ability to organize and act - large numbers of people are capable of large amounts of violence). 2) To paint your side as the victim by provoking an overreaction. Westerners often think that 2 is sufficient because they live in democracies where a large part of the government is also unwilling to use violence and become the aggressor. But against a dictator who is willing to use as much violence against the people as is available to him, 2 alone is worthless. Goal 2 only serves to maximize the number of people willing to rise up but the real goal is to break the enemy's will to fight. Either to make the dictator lose his nerve and flee or to kill him because corpses don't have a will. The point is it's a delicate balancing act to paint yourself as victim/weak to get more support and angry/strong to make the dictator back down. Westerners focus on the first part because it works against their governments but against greater oppression, you will not get anywhere without actual will to fight and kill.
- vkou 2y agoSo, the moment a single cop lobs a tear gas can at a peaceful protest, is the moment when the protest starts doing damage to its cause? That would explain why they seem to be so eager to employ violence against peaceful protestors.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the moment a single cop lobs a tear gas can at a peaceful protest, is the moment when the protest starts doing damage to its cause? No. The trigger was "a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy." Not a peaceful protest that gets gassed. The latter is extremely effective at generating public sympathy.
- immibis 2y agoSo all the cops have to do is send one of them undercover to throw a couple of bricks, and then they have casus belli to gas the whole protest. Ever wondered why protests always turn violent very shortly after the government decides it's time to disperse them?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]