5 ms·
This comment section is a fascinating mix of people who use WebUSB talking about how great it is and people who don’t use WebUSB being confused about why anyone
by Aurornis 2y ago
This comment section is a fascinating mix of people who use WebUSB talking about how great it is and people who don’t use WebUSB being confused about why anyone would want it.
In my experience it’s been great. Most of the WebUSB utilities I use are also available as self-installed apps, but I use them so infrequently that it’s much easier to use the web version than to go through the process of installing an update and using the app. It’s also one less app I have to install.
I would have expected this to be popular with the people who are tired of having an app for every different thing.
- wazoox 2y agoYeah, except that someday the site that provide that useful app may be gone once and for all, while the app would remain just fine until you uninstall it. So it's a double-edged sword.
- diggernet 2y ago> may be gone once and for all ...and the domain taken over by a scammer who puts up a fake app that does unspeakable things to your USB device.
- SunlitCat 2y ago> does unspeakable things to your USB device Taken out of context (and meaning), this sounds kinda naughty! :D
- anon7000 2y agoThe app they make would probably be Internet enabled with electron so… prolly also won’t work
- xiconfjs 2y agoEverything is a double-edged sword - even a single-edged sword.
- croes 2y agoI‘m more concerned about security by giving a webbrowser too much access to local resources. Convenience and security don’t fit together
- moffkalast 2y agoAlmost as if we've got some kind of notification that asks you if you want to give a browser access to a certain device huh?
- croes 2y agoBecause browser never have bugs.
- OneDeuxTriSeiGo 2y agoIf a web browser has a sufficient bug to allow access to webusb without permission in an exploitable way, it's probably also exploitable enough that even without webusb you'd have hardware access via RCE.
- kccqzy 2y agoYeah but if I need to talk to a local device, I trust browser's security far more than a random vendor's native app. I recently bought a keyboard that allows remapping keys; the vendor has both a native app and a web app to do it: I trusted the web app far more.
- croes 2y agoSo you don’t trust the vendor. Maybe using their hardware isn’t a good idea in the first place. I think browsers are the bigger target and they provide the much bigger attack vector given that the purpose is being connected to the internet. Using an internet tool to access local resources is using the wrong tool for the job.
- lukan 2y ago
- paulddraper 2y agoExample: Purchasing shipping labels, and using a scale to weigh the physical items. (Technically that's HID not USB, but similar idea.)
- cedws 2y agoI've used WebUSB to flash an Android device before. Yes, it's useful and easy, but it's also ripe for vulnerabilities. Web bloat needs to stop growing. The browser should not be a kitchen sink for anything anybody in tech wants. Installing a native application is not that hard.