3 ms·
So the author claims that if Surface is as good a device as the iPad, even if it has the same price point, that is too high a price point. But I don't agree tha
by danso 14y ago
So the author claims that if Surface is as good a device as the iPad, even if it has the same price point, that is too high a price point. But I don't agree that the dilemma is so similar to iPod vs Zune.
The iPod/Zune content environment was music. Yes, iTunes was (to the general public) a pretty good music service that locked you into the iPod ecosystem. But in general, people already had/could get digitial music. They just needed a great portable device. The Zune was not a better device than the iPod, but even if it were equivalent by some objective standard, people will gravitate toward the leader, all other things being equal. And unless they were locked into the iTunes music system (and if they were, then they're already an ipod owner, so not really relevant to the question), consumers could port their music to either iPod or Zune and get roughly the same listening experience.
So without a financial incentive, why go Zune?
But in the Surface vs. iPad debate...Tablets are still a relative niche market compared to the number of people who own/use a regular desktop/laptop. iPads absolutely own the tablet market, but there's still plenty of room among regular computer users who have been waiting. Moreover, there are people who are still hesitant to live Mac/PC dual lifestyles (even though that's not an issue for any experienced computer user).
And most importantly, there is software that is entirely exclusive to Windows systems, not least of which is Office.
If it were possible to only play Beatles and Lady Gaga MP3s exclusively on Zune, isn't it feasible that Zune would've gained a greater foothold? In the tablet wars, Microsoft has the power to choose which platforms its popular software will run. And considering the market penetration of Word/Excel/etc., even as Google Docs and other alternatives grow, that ecosystem is much more prevalent a feature than it was when it was Zune vs iPod
- jhatax 14y agoHi, I am the author of the post. Your opinion might differ, but the Zune v2 had a number of features that the iPod lacked: Wireless Sync, built-in radio, and Social/sharing are three that immediately come to mind. From a services standpoint, the Zune pass was a great music discovery service, and the Zune web service, circa 2008, was a cool way to share music with your friends (and way better than Ping). The public perception might not have been the same, but I am speaking on the basis of pure technical merit. The marketing team strongly believed that these features would push customers towards the technologically better product, and did not think that providing a financial incentive was necessary. We all know how that played out - they had to eat humble pie and drop the price before finally dropping the product. Tablets are a niche product, but the category, as it stands today, has been entirely defined by the iPad. This is not very different from how the iPod defined the music player market. AFAIK, application developers continue to target iPad first, and Android next; developing for Windows devices is not even in the rear-view mirror of developers. Microsoft is hoping that developers will re-prioritize once the Surface launches, but what if the device is a dud? My research into user behavior does not reveal a hesitation on the part of users to live a Mac/PC dual lifestyle. In fact, Windows users that own iPads do not believe the iPad to be a part of the Mac ecosystem. iPad apps stand on their own, and most of them do not have Windows or Mac counterparts. This said, please send analysis that indicates the duopoly is confusing my way. I wrote a post last year about Microsoft releasing Office for the iPad. If it continues to overlook the iPad in an effort to drive sales of the Surface, it will be the biggest loser, IMO. Office is Microsoft's cash cow; sales of the suite exceeded Windows last year, and show no signs of abating. In my non-scientific interviews of iPad users, I am yet to meet a user - business users and college students in particular - who will think twice before paying between 5 and 10 dollars for a la carte Office apps. Other than Office, I cannot conjure up a long enough list of applications that are Windows only. Remember that the entry-level surface is Windows RT only, and will not run traditional x86 applications.
- TheHegemon 14y agoI got to say, I have a 30GB Zune and a 120GB Zune and I still use the 120GB daily. The 30GB one fell out of my car three times and had so much abuse that I'm really surprised and amazed of the quality and durability of it. As you probably don't hear this enough whoever was on the Zune team are geniuses and I love it. It's going to be a sad day when my 120GB dies and especially considering it's almost impossible to find a new Zune under $300 nowadays. Once again thanks for all the work you guys did on it, and I'm extremely sorry that it did not get as much traction as it should have.
- greedo 14y agoTablets aren't a niche anymore; Apple sold 17 million iPads last quarter, greater than the number of computers that #2 PC vendor HP sold.
- icefox 14y ago"I am yet to meet a user - business users and college students in particular - who will think twice before paying between 5 and 10 dollars for a la carte Office apps" Hi! Nice to meet you. I don't feel like I need office apps in my life and wouldn't pay 5-10 dollars for them. Between the web and ios apps I realized I don't need them like I did in the 90's.
- barista 14y agoYou probably are in the minority, but I feel frustrated that there are no decent office like apps available on the tablets. There is a reason why, apple wants iPad to primarily be a consumption device. Office apps are not on top of their list. Microsoft looks at tablets as a productivity device so they are bundling the office apps in.
- glhaynes 14y agoThe iWork apps are well-reviewed and have been heavily pushed by Apple so I don't really understand much of your post. :)
- greedo 14y ago"And most importantly, there is software that is entirely exclusive to Windows systems, not least of which is Office." MS is porting Office to iOS (probably after first releasing it on WinRT.
- rbanffy 14y ago> Tablets are still a relative niche market 2 years after the iPad was introduced and with 84 million sold, this is arguable. > iPads absolutely own the tablet market Android owns the tablet market. Apple owns the iPad market, which happens to be much larger. If Microsoft wants to compete in the tablet market with the RT, they'd better have something for under US$250, which would be a credible point in the non-iPad tablet market, assuming they can bring substantially better functionality to the table. If they want to compete in the iPad market, they'd better make an iPad better than Apple's. The same reasoning about substantially better functionality remains. > And most importantly, there is software that is entirely exclusive to Windows systems Which is software that has no compelling use case for the tablet format. Do you feel sudden urges to use spreadsheets on tablets? Are you frustrated not to be able to compile that Visual Studio project on your tablet? Most important than that, the vast majority of Windows-only software will only run on the high-end x86 surface (and only on W7-like mode). Even assuming Microsoft is eager to destroy their relationship with their OEMs in the ARM tablet space, I can only imagine the damage directly competing with their x86 PC partners would do to their relationships and what would happen if those partners started pushing non-Windows PCs to their users (who really couldn't care less what the machine is running and will be very happy with whatever the manufacturer installs as long as it works). Putting the Microsoft brand on a device doesn't make it automatically desirable. I think this is the lesson Microsoft has to learn before they succeed. edit: downvote for disagreement... How mature.
- pooriaazimi 14y ago> Android owns the tablet market. I haven't seen anyone who owns an Android tablet. And I know 40-50 people with iPads. I don't know about it, but Android 4.1 might be very good on tablets and Nexus 7 might (hopefully) sell millions, and I'm happy about it because it makes Apple try harder on iPad, but "Android owns the tablet market" is far from the reality I'm living in. I agree with the rest of your comment. I wanted to upvote it, but my mouse slipped (I'm used to trackpads) and accidentally downvoted you. sorry about that.
- rbanffy 14y ago> I haven't seen anyone who owns an Android tablet. And I know 40-50 people with iPads. That's why there is no "tablet" market where the iPad is a high-end player. There is an iPad market, which is huge and where US$499 is a reasonable price, and then there is a tablet market, where you'll find the Nexus 7, Kindle Fire, Nooks and others fight each other (but not the iPad) for a lower price point. In this second market, an entrant above the US$ 300 range is doomed to fail because it won't compete with the iPad. Microsoft has some great people working for them, but they have no product that can compete with the iPad.