4 ms·
I'm wondering if it may be more impactful (and mutually beneficial) if everyone outside the US lowers the tariffs they have with each other? If the US doesn't
by ben_w 2y ago
I'm wondering if it may be more impactful (and mutually beneficial) if everyone outside the US lowers the tariffs they have with each other?
If the US doesn't want to buy Chinese or EU or Canadian etc., make it cheaper for China, the EU, Canada, etc. to replace the US with each other.
- pjc50 2y agoThe EU would already prefer that people buy European. The problem with anti-import schemes is that they inevitably hit exports. Trade has to have something in both directions, eventually.
- superzamp 2y agoIf that's the goal, one might wonder why are tariffs implemented in such a static way. Why not having your own tariffs importing from XYZ be updated on a monthly basis based on what XYZ imported from you last month.
- pjc50 2y agoUncertainty has a cost. The stupid daily changing trade war with Canada is causing a lot of Canadian companies to make medium or long term decisions to decouple from the US.
- superzamp 2y agoOh I definitely agree with that. I’m just wondering here if having something mechanical, predictable, deterministic (instead of whatever the hell that is that we have right now) wouldn’t be an interesting way to align incentives.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago> is causing a lot of Canadian companies to make medium or long term decisions to decouple from the US. Like which? Because recently Canadian investment firm Brookfield Asset Management moved their head office from Toronto to New York. So it seems it's only strengthening the US and weakening Canada. Large corporations don't care about nationalism/patriotism, they just go where the money is. They'll say they support Canadians to save face and get public support, while through the back door moving their assets and jobs to the US, or any other jurisdiction that makes them more money.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> recently Canadian investment firm Brookfield Asset Management moved their head office from Toronto to New York That sounds like the kind of decision that would take way more turnaround time to implement than the month or two of uncertainty we've had. > Large corporations don't care about nationalism/patriotism, they just go where the money is. And it's not about nationalism, it's about certainty as was claimed above. Long term that's a necessity for profit.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago>That sounds like the kind of decision that would take way more turnaround time to implement than the month or two of uncertainty we've had. Maybe, but the end result is still Canada loosing and US winning. >And it's not about nationalism, it's about certainty as was claimed above. Long term that's a necessity for profit. Good democracy and certainty don't go together very well most of the time. It's a feature of democracy, not a bug. The best regimes for certainty are autocratic ones like the CCP, Saudi Arabia, etc where citizens don't have a say. I for one value democracy more then the quarterly profits of soulless corporations who would gladly make the world burn for profit.
- AlecSchueler 2y ago> Maybe, but the end result is still Canada loosing and US winning. It is but when the discussion is about businesses racing a certain way to decisions made by a government that's only been in power for two months then it's misleading to focus on a decision made before that time. > Good democracy and certainty don't go together very well most of the time. It's a feature of democracy, not a bug. Good democracy? I'm not sure how loaded that phrase is but, regardless, doing business with the US has seemed a lot more certain for at least the past 20 election cycles than it does today. The current government, whether or not its behaviour is indicative (for you) of a "good democracy," is an outlier in terms of looking friendly to businesses or other investors looking to trade there.
- 2y ago
- tokioyoyo 2y agoI’m guessing multiple governments are trying to come up with some sort of a deal that resembles it. It just feels like China is going to be the sole winner in the end, as that’s they’re the only partner that is strong enough against US when it comes to trade.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoThe US trade more with the EU (both exports and imports) than with China, and it is fairly balanced. So actually this is the trade war nobody wants. On the other hand the US import a lot from China but export much less so they can hurt China more (but balanced with the fact that this would probably hurt US consumers more as well). Hence we've seen that the Chinese response to Trump has been minimal.
- watwut 2y agoSomebody wants that trade war and started it.
- ben_w 2y agoThe EU, the US, and China are all similar sized GDPs, and which one is on top depends if you measure with nominal or PPP dollars. From Wikipedia: EU: $20T nominal, $29T PPP China: $19.5T nominal, $39.4T PPP US: $30.3T (nominal == PPP by definition)
- 3D30497420 2y agoI've thought about that too, but of course reality is a bit more complicated. For example, the EU has a pretty large (and somewhat struggling) automotive industry that could be pretty negatively impacted by Chinese imports. I'd wager there are other areas though that could be mutually beneficial though.
- mike_hearn 2y agoThat would seriously undermine the existence of the EU as a whole. Bear in mind, it justifies the very steep membership fees (for the countries that have high enough GDP to pay) by tying membership to free trade. The EU keeps quite high external tariffs on a lot of things, especially in order to protect French agriculture. Thus the primary argument Remainers presented for staying in the EU was that if Britain left the EU would levy new trade barriers and tariffs on its exports. The EU has many members who are in it primarily for the transactional benefits. If the EU eliminated external tariffs not only would the French be out on the streets again immediately, but one of the primary motivations for membership would evaporate and the EU would lose a lot of leverage over member states.
- ben_w 2y agoThe EU is a lot broader than just a tariff agreement; even just the "four freedoms" of the EU are goods, capital, labour, and services, and keeping with the Brexit theme, the trade barriers that Remain was talking about also included "no you can't just do your trade across the border now, we no longer recognise your qualifications" and "we need to inspect the goods crossing this border to make sure they're complying with our legal requirements; yes, we know you didn't change your own, but now there's nothing stopping you from having imported something from somewhere else that didn't follow our rules, and we need to check". (Also, I said "lower" not "eliminate"; I was thinking more of Chinese PV, and perhaps cars, though cars would have a different group protesting).
- mike_hearn 2y agoYes, there are lots of trade barriers beyond tariffs, nonetheless the EU does impose plenty of them. See my other reply. And if your goal is to simply have closer trading relations then tariffs vs other kinds of regulatory barriers isn't an important difference. This is why Trump talks about things like VAT, and others in his camp talk about the fines levied on tech companies. From their perspective it's all financially equivalent to tariffs.
- ben_w 2y ago
- LordHeini 2y agoI think that is basically the case indirectly. Here an example with my limited understanding: Chinese steel is super expensive in the US now, so US manufacturers buy less of it raising the cost of US products. This makes Chinese steel more available on the world market and it becomes cheaper for everyone else. Due to the increased cost of steel US stuff made out of said steel, is generally more expensive while everyone else's become cheaper. So products not made in the US become cheaper in comparison and thus sell better for more profit. Oddly enough the EU imposed counter Tariffs on some weird stuff like Alcohol and Motorcycles... Europeans can easily replace Jim Beam in their Cola. And Harley Davidson is insanely expensive anyway with the usual customers being by MC-Members or dentist in their midlife crisis.
- pjc50 2y ago> Oddly enough the EU imposed counter Tariffs on some weird stuff like Alcohol and Motorcycles... Red state tariffs. NB the US tariffs apply to EU steel and steel products, not just Chinese ones, which is why this whole thing is happening.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago>Red state tariffs. How does that help? That will only make red states hate the EU more, not Trump. The EU already had tariffs against red state as retaliation back in his first term and it didn't affect him. I don't know if you know but MAGA crowd already doesn't like the EU because they see them as ungrateful freeloaders in term of trade deficit and receiving free defense and would very much like to see the US pull out of NATO and leave them to the Russians. EU targeting them specifically will only prove their point not turn them against Trump. IMHO, if you wann get to trump target Elon Musk's businesses and the likes of Big Tech who kissed his ring, Meta, etc.
- StayTrue 2y agoYou could be right. There are stories about Trump voters being hurt by his cuts and still feel it’s for the greater good. On the other hand some of these elections are won by narrow margins. Most Trump voters didn’t sign up for pain (not personally, they only voted to harm others). Pain may influence their votes in the future or motivate their legislators to contain the executive branch.