3 ms·
It became a test case of whether there is a limit to punishments for crimes. Is a life sentence for littering constitutionally legal if there is a valid statute
by qingcharles 2y ago
It became a test case of whether there is a limit to punishments for crimes. Is a life sentence for littering constitutionally legal if there is a valid statute that says it is?
The courts eventually up-ended the person's sentence somewhat and reduced it to the minimum available, 6 years. I don't know whether the person had already served over that time before his sentence was adjusted, but I would hazard a guess that he had.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> It became a test case of whether there is a limit to punishments for crimes. Is a life sentence for littering constitutionally legal if there is a valid statute that says it is? This can't be a correct description; a statute can't influence whether something is or isn't constitutional. They're different levels. I tend to suspect that you're intentionally omitting whatever the case was actually about.
- qingcharles 2y agoIt definitely can. The sentence was decided as disproportionate to the crime. Illinois has a "proportional penalties" clause. This is found in the Illinois Constitution, Article I, Section 11, which states: "All penalties shall be proportioned to the offense."