6 ms·
Jumping the gap between a US and UK high school education
- jonsen 14y agoIt makes me sad that this modern world with so much progress elsewhere still can't get education right for our children.
- rdtsc 14y agoBecause schools are not the first in line for funding. Wars are. Elderly health-care and pensions benefits are. Other stuff as well. Why are schools tied to local property taxes? I could never understand that. That is all kinds of messed up. Schools funds should be first in line in the federal budget, alongside with the new "surgical strike weapons" and the new "aircraft carriers". Also, the politicians who are can vote and effect changes are sending their kids to private schools so they really don't care what everyone else does. As a society we allegedly claim that children are the most precious things we have and yet when it comes to education, our actions seem to betray our words.
- waqf 14y agoNot to disagree with anything you say, but it's not just funding. There's also an immense, yawning lack of consensus on what and how children should be taught. For example, I would expect much, much more science to be recommended by the typical HN commentator than by the typical teachers' union. The consequence is that the "traditional" high-school curriculum, which was invented well over a century ago, has barely changed since because nobody can get all the stakeholders to agree.
- rdtsc 14y agoStart with funding. Pay teachers well. Make being a teacher the same as being a lawyer or a good engineer. > For example, I would expect much, much more science to be recommended by the typical HN commentator than by the typical teachers' union. Great point. I understand that some teachers wouldn't really understand a bad science text book/curriculum vs a good one, because they are not that good at it. Associate schools with local universities. Ask university math and physics professors to rate a curriculum., don't just rely on English majors being influenced by book publishers to determine how science should be taught Fundamentally education is so far down the list after wars spending, elderly care and other issues that it just gets the short end of the stick. If they approached it with the same budget and interest as they approach a new aircraft carrier fleet we'd have a world-class education system.
- droithomme 14y agoIf the goal is science literacy wouldn't it make sense to use a scientific approach to determining whether there is a correlation between spending and achievement in schools?
- apendleton 14y agoEveryone always blames it on money. It's more complicated than that. My city (Washington, DC), spent $29,000 per pupil on public schools last year. By that metric, it's one of the best-funded school systems in the country. Test scores here are mediocre at best, to the point that most families with the means to do so move out to the suburbs once they have kids. There are a wide variety of reasons for this phenomenon, and they'll vary depending on who you ask (urban schools are generally expensive to run, special-needs students are disproportionately expensive to educate, teachers' unions have a lot of clout, etc.).
- aidenn0 14y agoWhere I live, there is a school district with exactly 1 elementary school, in the richest part of town that is funded at a rate of nearly 2x the dollars per student as the other school district (where the rest of the schools are).
- archon 14y agoThe writer seems to be generalizing the entire US system based on his daughter's experience in one US high school, which he admits is "overcrowded, under-resourced [and] doesn’t think much of science". Is this really a problem of the US system as a whole or is it this particular school? Seems like a bit of a "the grass is always greener on the other side" thing.
- TimGebhardt 14y agoMost school systems are underfunded right now because our state governments are still recovering from the 2008 financial crash.
- yardie 14y agoMany have been underfunded for much longer than that. It's only after the GFC that we realized how bad it has gotten. When it was only the schools in the poor districts the middle class didn't complain (and didn't care) but as the crisis spread to even upper-middle class districts it was hard to ignore. Now, overworked parents are blaming overworked school teachers about their underperforming kids.
- droithomme 14y agoDoes funding correlate with academic results? Many studies say it is not correlated or is negatively correlated. http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/The-Adam-Smith-Institute-Blog/2010/0428/No-correlation-between-education-funding-and-student-performance http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/The-Adam-Smith-Institute-B... http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2008/09/does-spending-more-on-education-improve-academic-achievement http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2008/09/does-spendi... http://www.amstat.org/publications/jse/secure/v7n2/datasets.guber.cfm http://www.amstat.org/publications/jse/secure/v7n2/datasets.... Some say they are positively correlated. http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=EJ575184&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=EJ575184 http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/search/detailmini.jsp?_...
- saraid216 14y agoThe thing is that this is an extremely common sentiment that's echoed by virtually everyone. You will occasionally get someone who says they turned out fine, or that they had this one great teacher... but they also tend to be the exception that proves the rule.
- binarymax 14y agoI also wonder why I didn't start to learn physics until 12th grade (this was back in 1995). I hate to post an xkcd but I think this is appropriate: http://xkcd.com/435/ http://xkcd.com/435/ Starting them all at once is a great way to go about it too. But I wonder if 13 is too late? Why not start at 8 or 9, or even earlier? Do they still think that young children wont get it? Education is a success when students are engaged and want to learn. Let them see how amazing this stuff is as early as possible and they will get hooked! --EDIT-- I came back to add that teaching mathematics in the context of science as early as possible should help a great deal. Mathematics as an isolated subject can be foreign to students. In the context of early science it has applications. Want to apply Ohms law? Get moles in a solution? Understand cellular division rates? etc.
- archon 14y ago> I came back to add that teaching mathematics in the context of science as early as possible should help a great deal I think this hits the nail on the head. The first time I realized that science == math, I was in late high school. I wonder how my absorption of the material would have changed had I made that connection earlier. I know that being able to apply math to chemistry and physics made it much easier for me to learn algebra and calculus, if only because it now had an applicable purpose beyond being its own abstract set of concepts.
- wiredfool 14y agoYeah, for me that was physics. 11th grade. In my highschool, (to graduate) everyone had to take calculus, normally in 12th grade. Unfortunately, physics (required in 11th grade) makes a hell of a lot more sense if you have some basic calculus first. All the kinematic equations are just random terms until you see that they're all derivatives/integrals of each other. On the other hand, My wife went through the british school system, and didn't have any math or science after age 13. It was all languages and such. The american system delays specialization for a long time, generally till the second half of college. (or even into grad school). The UK specializes way earlier, and you can get away with a small handful of related subjects after A levels.
- 14y ago
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoSorry to hear about that daughter's experience. My sons attended a well-funded high school with a splendid chemistry lab, did many fine experiments and wrote lab reports. All chose science and engineering in college. I'm a little tired of some snooty British guy claiming their bad inner-city experience is typically American, then holding up their Public School (which in Britain means Private School here) experience as proof of the superiority of something or other. My British friend in Computer Science at Iowa got his degree, then went on to study at Manchester (England) because nobody in England would respect his American degree. Once he got there the profs shook their heads, poor guy got an American degree, he'll have to repeat almost everything. They wrote a study plan for him (without his being consulted at all). Long story short, he didn't attend any class, do any homework, ever really attend anything except his exams. He was top student that year, of course. Of course he was! He'd already been well educated and had work experience. So, there's my counter-story. And to avoid hypocrisy, I won't claim its typical of anybody, except maybe good Iowa students going to study at Manchester.
- timthorn 14y agoThe author explicitly calls out his school was a comprehensive (i.e. a state run school) - no public school experience in sight. Why the flight to class warfare when this is a discussion about the merits of approaches to education?
- zbuc 14y agoThe real question is why do the British call it "public school" when it's not run by the public? Sounds like they need better English education...
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoSo did I, so did my sons. State schools in America vary, sure. Maybe we were lucky. But the author's conclusion is, British schools are all better than American schools. I call BS.
- timthorn 14y ago
- randallu 14y agoMaybe science just isn't the thing his daughter wants to do. I hope that the problem isn't really him forcing his daugher to be someone she isn't (like the stereotypical "you can be any kind of doctor you want" parents...).
- gpvos 14y agoApparently this school has an emphasis on sports and the arts. Couldn't he have chosen a different school? (I know next to nothing about the U.S. system, and Wikipedia doesn't help me.)
- jauer 14y agoThat is actually a large controversy right now. Generally speaking you have to attend the government school in the same tax district as your residence. Unless of course you have enough money to go to a religious or independent school but those can cost $20,000+ per year. There is a push for "school vouchers" that allow you to move between government schools or use government funds to pay for tuition at a non-government school. This is opposed by the teacher's union as it will "drain funds from schools that need most" (schools are funded by property tax with per-student funds from the state and federal government). Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_choice#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_choice#United_States
- aidenn0 14y agoIt's complicated. Government funded schools (they are funded by a combination of local, state, and federal funds) are tied to a district. Some districts have multiple schools, in which case you have a school based upon your address that you are supposed to go to (typically based upon highly gerrymandered boundaries since school quality has a large affect on housing prices), but you can usually apply to go to a different school within the district, for which there are various rules that decide which requests are approved assuming there are more transfer requests than the school can accommodate. Where I grew up, things weren't quite so bad, since the school-system was county wide, but you still got things where parents "in the know" would have their kids transfer from less desirable "school A" to more desirable "school B" based upon manufactured reasons like "My kid wants to take Japanese, and school A doesn't offer it. Where I live now, things are much worse. For example: 1) The wealthiest part of town has a school district with exactly one school in it. As a large fraction of school funding comes from local property taxes (split among the district), the budget for that single school is much larger than all other schools in the town 2) The boundaries for determining your school in the main school district are badly gerrymandered. There are many cases in which people living in traditionally hispanic parts of the town will have to cross-through a the region for a more desirable school in order to get to the school to which they are assigned.
- roel_v 14y agoFor some reason I end up in a lot of debates on relative school quality between countries across the world (presumably because I live in another country than I was born in, and because I work with academics a lot...) Many have an opinion on country X's school system being better than country Y's. Most of the time, this opinion isn't based on results, it seems (from my off-the-cuff analysis) that school are generally considered 'better' if they are 'stricter' (i.e., place more emphasis on discipline and respect, for example school who let people eat in class must be horrible), and the amount of hard science they teach everyone from a young age on (e.g., teaching everyone hard science more than the basics is better than just teaching those with an affinity for it, and teaching it starting at 6 is better than teaching at 12). However, people can seldom back that up with evidence. For example, using artificial metrics such as scores in the various Olympiads (math, physics) or more 'utilitarian' metrics such as GDP (because people do use the prosperity of a country, for which GDP is a rough proxy, to justify their preferences, or rather they use it as a driving factor in the optimization function that use to determine which country's school system is 'best'). I get into a bitter argument with my mother, of all people, over this, with her unmovable stance being that in my home country, education is better because schools are strict, pupils address teachers with an honorific, etc; while in the country that I live in, that is much less important. (I'm not Asian and this is not an East vs West debate :) ) Yet in my current country, GDP is higher than in my home country, with many other things being similar; while I have no hard proof that the school system is the only or even a major driver of this difference, wouldn't it make sense that I'd send my daughter to a school in a system that has proven its real-world effectiveness, even if aspects of it go against the common wisdom or 'cultural intuitions' that I was brought up in, and that many in my old country still adhere to? While I guess it would be hard for many to admit that they've believed in things that turned out to be wrong for decades (I personally had that problem less because I never quite identified with the ethos of my old country that much), I'd say rationally that it's more likely that that part of the culture is wrong, rather than there being some extreme coincidence in which, despite having a substandard schooling system, many of the effects of that schooling system in my new country turned out better than those of the old country. Sorry that this turned into such a long post - I just find it frustrating that, in this debate just like in so many others ;), it's common for people to ignore any evidence-based analysis of this question, or restrict themselves to that evidence that is favorable to their standpoint; and I do think that general prosperity is a direct consequence of a well-performing educational system.
- grandalf 14y agoThe public school in question is likely one of these: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huron_High_School_(Ann_Arbor,_Michigan) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huron_High_School_(Ann_Arbor,_M... or http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_High_School_(Ann_Arbor,_Michigan) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_High_School_(Ann_Arbor,...
- tworats 14y agoI went to public school in Iran until the age of 12, private school in the UK from 12 to 15, and spent my final year in public school in the US. Observations: Math: what I was learning as a junior or senior in the UK/US was what I'd already covered as an 11-12 year old in Iran. The only new subject we covered was calculus. That really sucks and is a big concern for me since my kids go to public school in the US. Science: was very hands-on in the UK (lots of experiments and labs). Much better for learning than the text book approach in Iran. I only had 1 year in the US, but it was much less hands on as well.
- tgrem 14y agoThis post struck a nerve with me as I'm agonizing over the decision of moving to the US while my daughter is about to enter her final year of GCSEs at a great school. I really worry that moving her will seriously damage her chances of going to university in the UK, but the thought of leaving her here while the rest of her family move to the US is just too heart breaking to contemplate. The area around San Francisco we're looking to move to has great schools but the final 2 years of the US high school curriculum is totally different to the UKs A-Levels and I fear she will struggle to adapt.