3 ms·
I don't know what the latest is, but often judges are supposed to not allow "expert testimony" without checking that the person is an expert. However this is a
by bluGill 2y ago
I don't know what the latest is, but often judges are supposed to not allow "expert testimony" without checking that the person is an expert. However this is a really complex area. Judges don't want to be the one deciding a case, but not allowing some "expert" is in a way deciding the case.
- hiatus 2y agoIsn't it up to the opposing party, and not the judge, to impeach an expert?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ARandumGuy 2y agoIf it was solely up to the opposing party, then they'd strike down every single expert. The judge still is the ultimate decider on what evidence (including expert testimony) is admissible.
- SoftTalker 2y agoIt's the jury that ultimately decides whether the evidence is convincing, even if the judge allows it. The defense will try to cast doubt on the evidence when they make their arguments. This also reminds me of one of Norm Macdonald's bits. He says (very seriously) that if he were on a jury he would not convict someone on the basis of DNA evidence. "What do I know about DNA?" he says.
- zusammen 2y agoThere’s a built-in design paradox. How does a judge assess an expert in a field where he is not one? There’s probably some improvement that comes from experience but it’s not perfect.
- stogot 2y agoQualifications=academics usually & career experience. No way to know if they actually learned something and aren’t a fraud. Even corporations that do thousands of interviews get duped
- aziaziazi 2y agoSome thought - perhaps the judge make less experts interviews than the corporations, leading to less experience in that but also takes each of them more seriously. - one way to remove/add some credit to someone claim is to ask some of their peers opinion and see if there’s a strong majority. - the judge personal expertise may help him forge a precise opinion but that wouldn’t clear him of making a mistake. For important matters it’s always a good idea to ask for peers reviews. Academics knows that too.
- bluGill 2y agoOpposing lawyers have an incentive to help the judge. Of course the lawyers will lie, but they still will point out important details for the judge to look at.