3 ms·

Is this simply using a stock full body estimator (like mediapipe pose estimator[0]), or do you actually have custom ML systems trained on proper form? I ask, s

Is this simply using a stock full body estimator (like mediapipe pose estimator[0]), or do you actually have custom ML systems trained on proper form? I ask, since I don't think a general body pose estimator is fit, and an app potentially giving improper pose advice for exercise might do more worse than good. If you have something substantial, please provide credible evidence, research and benchmarks. [0] https://mediapipe-studio.webapps.google.com/home https://mediapipe-studio.webapps.google.com/home

AC101101 2y ago
Oh yeah! Thanks for asking cause this was the dilemma that we were experiencing at first. When starting out, think we were using mediapipe from ML Kit (Google) and CoreML. If you want a visual example of our first version, here it is: https://www.swivi.app/ https://www.swivi.app/. We started out on Android but switched to iOS because everyone in our area had iPhones lol. In short, the skeleton (the white lines) kept flickering a lot so we made our own implementation. Feel free to check out our iOS version history too! You can see our tracking capabilities from this stupid short: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/cGJs9pJW_nE https://www.youtube.com/shorts/cGJs9pJW_nE (Skip to the last part where I wave my arms around quickly) You're very right, the general body pose estimators are laggy and doesn't track very well. We worked full-time to implement our own solution that took YEARS XD. So this isn't smth that we just made. Admittedly, we were focused on building which I know isn't the best approach. But..at least, we got this tho ahaha For our full iterative building process, you can view it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5CAK40wTwo&t=17s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5CAK40wTwo&t=17s But the most important aspect that you pointed out which I liked is safety. Like all AI, you shouldn't completely trust it 100%. The app is good at what it does, but it's just a tool that can assist your needs. I tried to keep it brief, so I hope this is answered your points. Appreciate you!
- mentalgear 2y ago
  I appreciate the detailed answer! I saw your iterative process from the video and how long a way you have come. The UI is also nicely done, especially the small animated icons and looping videos. Yet, what could really place you apart in an already crowded market is objective benchmarks, where we can really see that your solution is more accurate than others.

AC101101 2y ago

Oh yeah! Thanks for asking cause this was the dilemma that we were experiencing at first. When starting out, think we were using mediapipe from ML Kit (Google) and CoreML. If you want a visual example of our first version, here it is: https://www.swivi.app/ https://www.swivi.app/. We started out on Android but switched to iOS because everyone in our area had iPhones lol. In short, the skeleton (the white lines) kept flickering a lot so we made our own implementation. Feel free to check out our iOS version history too! You can see our tracking capabilities from this stupid short: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/cGJs9pJW_nE https://www.youtube.com/shorts/cGJs9pJW_nE (Skip to the last part where I wave my arms around quickly) You're very right, the general body pose estimators are laggy and doesn't track very well. We worked full-time to implement our own solution that took YEARS XD. So this isn't smth that we just made. Admittedly, we were focused on building which I know isn't the best approach. But..at least, we got this tho ahaha For our full iterative building process, you can view it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5CAK40wTwo&t=17s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5CAK40wTwo&t=17s But the most important aspect that you pointed out which I liked is safety. Like all AI, you shouldn't completely trust it 100%. The app is good at what it does, but it's just a tool that can assist your needs. I tried to keep it brief, so I hope this is answered your points. Appreciate you!

mentalgear 2y ago
I appreciate the detailed answer! I saw your iterative process from the video and how long a way you have come. The UI is also nicely done, especially the small animated icons and looping videos. Yet, what could really place you apart in an already crowded market is objective benchmarks, where we can really see that your solution is more accurate than others.