4 ms·
Quora is in the same boat as FB (and to a certain extent, Twitter) They think that the experience of their largely 20-something staff is anything short of revo
by samstave 14y ago
Quora is in the same boat as FB (and to a certain extent, Twitter)
They think that the experience of their largely 20-something staff is anything short of revolutionary.
A bunch of kids running a digital media company with questionable morals and no connection to digital history.
I will delete me Quora account. So far I have gotten little value from it. Time for it to have no data on me.
Deactivated!
Edit:
I followed up with an email to FEEDBACK@QUORA.COM asking them to delete my account and data.. will see what happens. I dont like the idea of a limbo account that can be reactivated/mined.
I'd prefer to have it deleted.
- monsterix 14y agoAbsolutely. Their policy to force your true_full_name is an absolute no-go for many users. A friend of mine from south India has a very lengthy name. Few parts of his name are direct reference to his ancestors and the villages they come from. Sort of like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._D._Deve_Gowda http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._D._Deve_Gowda where H. D. parts of his name are references to ancestry, places etc. My friend was denied permission to use Quora, rather insultingly blocked, for not revealing his ancestor name. We thought it was plain stupid on part of Quora to behave this way, so didn't bother to follow up with them either. What's amazing here is that even Government passports don't force revealing names of ancestors like they do.
- cantrevealname 14y agoMy friend was denied permission to use Quora for not revealing his ancestor name. Could you explain how it happened in this specific case, since it sounds like the name that your friend gave appeared to be real. That it, it wasn't something like "Fake Name" or "Bite Me", so how did Quora know? And, in general, could someone explain how the likes of Quora and Facebook decide that a name isn't "real"? Does someone at Quora or Facebook manually scan new account names? Do they wait for complaints from other users? Is it something algorithmic like noting that you receive messages such as "Hi Mike" but where you registered as "Fred Flintstone"?
- JonnieCache 14y ago>Does someone at Quora or Facebook manually scan new account names? At facebook they certainly do. When you change your name you have to wait for some period of time before it gets approved by a human. The person doing it doesn't seem to give a shit though. It is the fashion amongst a certain sector of the youth to use utterly ludicrous pseudonyms on FB - most of my friends do. I would love to quote some of them here because they're very funny but I don't want to jeopardise anyones privacy. Personally I have changed my name several times on FB over the years and never had a problem. For a long time it was 15 letters with no vowels. That was fun at parties - "What are you called on facebook?" "I literally can't remember. Guess I'm going to have to add you."
- Lewton 14y agoI suspect the wait time for changing names on facebook are there to give the illusion that a real human looks at it. AFAIK if you try to change your name to something obviously fake, like "Superman", it will reject it immediately
- seunosewa 14y agoIt's likely that the system is setup to reject obviously wrong names instantly to save the manual reviewers' time.
- saurik 14y agoI've noticed the same phenomenon (knowing tons of people on Facebook--to be clear, just "normal people" I knew from college--with ludicrous handles on Facebook). It thereby really bugs me when people hold up Facebook as an example of why real name policies are good, or claim that forcing real names is ok because Facebook set a precedent, when it is fairly clear that Facebook doesn't really care.
- aangjie 14y agoI suspect in this case, he just used initials for the last name instead of expanding it. It's a common style followed in India. For example He use Deve G. or Fred F.
- Auguste 14y agoI didn't mind their real full-name policy until now, since you could still answer questions anonymously. Allowing other members to see the questions I'm viewing by default, however, crosses the line.
- tijs 14y agoapparently you have to e-mail privacy@quora.com to get your account deleted completely. That in itself is reason to delete your account btw. It speaks volumes of their regard for users and their privacy.
- Jacqued 14y agoUnfortunately this bad practice is widely adopted and only spreading. It's this kind of BS that makes me create fake facebook or twitter accounts to log on shady sites like Quora.
- samstave 14y agoThanks, It was non-obvious as to whom I needed to contact... Ill try that email as well. EDIT: Done.
- mtgx 14y agoWow. I'm certainly asking for a deletion now, too. I haven't used it in a while, but I hate these tactics of not allowing the user to delete the account when he wants to.
- sdqali 14y agoThanks for the correct email id. I just sent out a mail asking them to delete my account.
- Auguste 14y agoFirst I'm manually deleting all of my answers, then I'll ask Quora to delete the rest. I've had bad experience with deleting accounts in the past, where my content would remain on the website even though my account was gone. And not having an account, there's nothing I can do about that data afterwards. I want to be pretty sure that all my Quora content is gone. Fun fact: There's no way to get a list of your anonymous answers on Quora. They don't show up on your profile at all. All you can really do is browse through your list of followed questions and manually check each one to see if you responded anonymously.
- unimpressive 14y agoDon't forget /etc/hosts: 127.0.0.1 quora.com www.quora.com
- samstave 14y agoWhile I see that - its not that I dont want to be able to access them it is more that I want all data associated to me to be deleted...
- vog 14y agoAs far as I understand it, this /etc/hosts entry is not so much about you accessing Quora, but more about other sites that want your browser to connect to Quora (e.g. via embedded content or JavaScript).
- rblackwater 14y agoThat's not really necessary, after you delete your account they'll block you from reading by themselves.
- vog 14y agoOf course you could trust them not to track you. But for the same reason you prefer your account to be deleted (not just inactivated), you might want to make sure on your side that they can't track you (not just taking their word for it).
- rblackwater 14y agoI agree with you totally, of course; I was just joking that they won't let you read anything and that is what prompted the initial outrage.
- sp332 14y agoI recommend using RequestPolicy for that. It's a lot more convenient and fine-grained.
- 14y ago
- lifeinafolder 14y agoditto. I emailed privacy@quora.com to delete my account. Waiting for a response from them now.
- mozan_sykol 14y ago>>They think that the experience of their largely 20-something staff is anything short of revolutionary. >>A bunch of kids running a digital media company with questionable morals and no connection to digital history. I cannot comment on the morals but same thing applies to a lot of YCombinator companies - where the product is complete trash, gains traction just because they allow you to do something 'social', used by the cool kids because apparently they are developed in Lisp (or similar 'cool' languages) and is built to be sold. Most of them are bought by large companies where the decision makers are equally foolish. I am huge fan of Quora, primarily because it allows opinions. In technology, often a best answer is an opinion, recommendation and comparison between things - something which Stackoverflow discourages. I have found a lot of value in reading answers in Quora and this just a small price to pay.
- debacle 14y ago> anything short of revolutionary. I think you mean nothing short of revolutionary.
- IsaacL 14y agoI have to take the minority position and stand up for Quora here. I'm a huge fan of the service, and though I agree this latest move was a mis-step, I remain a loyal Quora user. Unlike you, I've gained a ton of value from it. Unlike the trivial discussions or content spam posted on Facebook or Twitter, Quora features tons of interesting conversations. The closest comparison to it might actually be Wikipedia, at least in terms of general scale of ambition. It's the one online community I've found that I think is better than Hacker News (though admittedly the quality of discussing has slid as the audience has grown wider). There's few other places where a question about politics might be answered by a Washington insider, or a question about startups might be answered by a top name Valley VC, or a question about snipers answered by an actual sniper. Their real name policy has generally been fairly sensibly and sensitively implemented (http://www.quora.com/Why-has-there-been-an-outcry-against-real-names-on-Google+-but-not-on-Quora http://www.quora.com/Why-has-there-been-an-outcry-against-re...) - they've always allowed anonymous posting, and they've been more flexible on the definition of "real name", than, say, G+. For example, danah boyd is able to post with the legal, lowercase form of her name. Whether they'll begin bowing to advertisers once they need to monetise of course remains an open question -- but I'm hoping they can find alternative revenue streams. For example, a lot of consultants post answers on there to gain clients -- that's an example of the concrete monetary value Quora creates, and if they can capture some of that value they can build a great company without stooping to Facebook-style data mining controversies.
- wpietri 14y agoYeah, I'm in the same camp. One of the most appealing things about Quora is the extent to which it creates a pleasant community. When I saw this, I thought, "Hey, neat! I'll have a better idea who's reading my answers." But I understand why people are upset. On the other hand, I almost murdered them when they started forcing people inbound from Facebook to log in with Facebook: http://www.quora.com/rage-against-quora/Rage-forcing-Facebook-signup-on-inbound-links-from-Facebook http://www.quora.com/rage-against-quora/Rage-forcing-Faceboo... So I've got my eye on them. The extent to which they can square the community vibe and their relatively high moral standards with the expectations of their investors is still unclear.
- JoelSutherland 14y agoThey could be morons for any number of reasons besides age. No need to speculate.
- mnicole 14y agoI believe the age thing is more about them not having an accrued history of personally-attributed content on the internet and how that weighed into making this decision. Whether or not that's related to their age is debatable, but one would assume that people who have been publishing on the web for awhile -- bylined or anonymously -- would understand the negative impact this would have on their community or at least would have learned from previous companies' mistakes that just isn't something you do (both the deploying a global change that opts users into something they didn't initially sign up for and the very concept of making previously private things public). There are separate services out there that one can use if they want others on the web to know where they are and what they're doing. I'll use those if I want to be transparent.